Skip to main content
The New York Times, Nov 17, 2005, p. A1
By Beth McGough
Warning! Spoilers ahead.
Have you watched the Netflix series Making a Murderer? 
What is your conclusion?
Making a Murderer is a documentary series about Steven Avery. Avery was convicted of rape and assault in the 1980s, and then freed in 2003 when DNA evidence exonerated him. But, in 2006 he was accused of a brutal murder and, again, convicted. Though still imprisoned, Avery maintains his innocence. 
Making a Murderer has caused outrage and calls for Avery’s pardon, but some reviewers are criticizing the producers. Commentators indicate details from the trial were left out, which biased the series in favor of Avery. 
Looking for answers
The series included numerous clips of the television media, but did not include much newspaper content or explicitly mention scholarly sources. Newspapers, law journals, scholarly articles, and dissertations can illuminate facts and perspectives that will help you decide if Avery is guilty or innocent. 
Coverage of the trial from the local newspapers in Manitowoc county and Milwaukee
Pankratz, Pat. DNA Frees Man After 18 Years. Herald Times Reporter, Sep 11 2003, p. A1
Weaver, Amy. Avery Faces Homicide Charge. Herald Times Reporter, Nov 12 2005, p. A1
Kertscher, Tom. STEVEN AVERY TRIAL BEGINS; DA says blood, bone link Avery to killing; But defense contends burned bones likely were planted. Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Feb 13, 2007, p. B1
Little, Ken. Avery trial is lesson in courtroom reality of criminal cases. Herald Times Reporter, Feb 18, 2007, p. A4
Braley, Kevin. Keeping quiet. Herald Times Reporter, March 4, 2007, p. A1
STANFORD. AVERY TRIAL; The power of DNA; This time the jury got it right in convicting Steven Avery, once wrongly convicted in a 1985 rape case, of first-degree murder in the slaying of photographer Teresa Halbach. Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, March 20, 2007, p. A8
Little, Ken. Was Justice Served in Avery Verdict? If You Believe in System, Yes. Herald Times Reporter, March 19, 2007, p. A4
Steven Avery Denied New Trial in Teresa Halbach 2005 Homicide. Herald Times Reporter, Aug 25, 2011, p. A3
National coverage
Davey, Monica. Freed by DNA, Now Charged In New Crime. The New York Times, Nov 17, 2005, p. A1
Man Freed by DNA Test is Convicted of Murder. The New York Times, March 18, 2007, p. A13
COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMS STEVEN AVERY'S CONVICTION FOR 1ST-DEGREE INTENTIONAL HOMICIDE. US Federal News Service, Aug 25, 2011
Wang, Yanan. More than 170,000 call for pardon of 'Making a Murderer' subject Steven Avery. Washington Post – Blogs, Jan 4, 2016
Coverage in legal journals
Lampert Smith, Susan. Somber reflection at Project Innocence. The Wisconsin State Law Journal, March 5, 2006
Krieger, Steven A. Why Our Justice System Convicts Innocent People, and the Challenges Faced by Innocence Projects Trying to Exonerate Them. New Criminal Law Review, Summer 2011, p. 333-402
Coverage in scholarly journals and dissertations
Olson, Elizabeth Ann. Lies, damned lies, and alibis: How do evaluators process alibis? ProQuest Dissertations, March 2005
Bowman, Locke E. LEMONADE OUT OF LEMONS: CAN WRONGFUL CONVICTIONS LEAD TO CRIMINAL JUSTICE REFORM? Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, Summer 2008, p. 1501-1517
Note: You must have access to ProQuest through a library to access the articles in this post.

By Beth McGough

Warning! Spoilers ahead.

Have you watched the Netflix series Making a Murderer

What is your conclusion?

Making a Murderer is a documentary series about Steven Avery. Avery was convicted of rape and assault in the 1980s, and then freed in 2003 when DNA evidence exonerated him. But, in 2006 he was accused of a brutal murder and, again, convicted. Though still imprisoned, Avery maintains his innocence. 

Making a Murderer has caused outrage and calls for Avery’s pardon, but some reviewers are criticizing the producers. Commentators indicate details from the trial were left out, which biased the series in favor of Avery. 

Looking for answers

The series included numerous clips of the television media, but did not include much newspaper content or explicitly mention scholarly sources. Newspapers, law journals, scholarly articles, and dissertations can illuminate facts and perspectives that will help you decide if Avery is guilty or innocent. 

Coverage of the trial from the local newspapers in Manitowoc county and Milwaukee

Pankratz, Pat. DNA Frees Man After 18 Years. Herald Times Reporter, Sep 11, 2003, p. A1

Weaver, Amy. Avery Faces Homicide Charge. Herald Times Reporter, Nov 12, 2005, p. A1

Kertscher, Tom. STEVEN AVERY TRIAL BEGINS; DA says blood, bone link Avery to killing; But defense contends burned bones likely were planted. Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Feb 13, 2007, p. B1

Little, Ken. Avery trial is lesson in courtroom reality of criminal cases. Herald Times Reporter, Feb 18, 2007, p. A4

Braley, Kevin. Keeping quiet. Herald Times Reporter, March 4, 2007, p. A1

STANFORD. AVERY TRIAL; The power of DNA; This time the jury got it right in convicting Steven Avery, once wrongly convicted in a 1985 rape case, of first-degree murder in the slaying of photographer Teresa Halbach. Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, March 20, 2007, p. A8

Little, Ken. Was Justice Served in Avery Verdict? If You Believe in System, Yes. Herald Times Reporter, March 19, 2007, p. A4

Steven Avery Denied New Trial in Teresa Halbach 2005 Homicide. Herald Times Reporter, Aug 25, 2011, p. A3

National coverage

Davey, Monica. Freed by DNA, Now Charged In New Crime. The New York Times, Nov 17, 2005, p. A1

Man Freed by DNA Test is Convicted of Murder. The New York Times, March 18, 2007, p. A13

COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMS STEVEN AVERY'S CONVICTION FOR 1ST-DEGREE INTENTIONAL HOMICIDE. US Federal News Service, Aug 25, 2011

Wang, Yanan. More than 170,000 call for pardon of 'Making a Murderer' subject Steven Avery. Washington Post – Blogs, Jan 4, 2016

Coverage in legal journals

Lampert Smith, Susan. Somber reflection at Project Innocence. The Wisconsin State Law Journal, March 5, 2006

Krieger, Steven A. Why Our Justice System Convicts Innocent People, and the Challenges Faced by Innocence Projects Trying to Exonerate Them. New Criminal Law Review, Summer 2011, p. 333-402

Coverage in scholarly journals and dissertations

Olson, Elizabeth Ann. Lies, damned lies, and alibis: How do evaluators process alibis? ProQuest Dissertations, March 2005

Bowman, Locke E. LEMONADE OUT OF LEMONS: CAN WRONGFUL CONVICTIONS LEAD TO CRIMINAL JUSTICE REFORM? Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, Summer 2008, p. 1501-1517

Note: You must have access to ProQuest through a library to view the articles in this post.

10 Feb 2016

Related Posts

Matthews, R. (1943, Jan 09). The truth about HOLLYWOOD VIEWPOINT EXCLUSIVE AND THE RACE ISSUE FROM THE ACTORS. Afro-American (1893-1988)

Academy Awards in the (Historical) News…Again

Blog post connecting ProQuest Historical Newspapers to the recent Academy Awards, highlighting the fact that out of the 2,947 Oscars awarded, very few have been awarded to actors of color. Written by Jennifer Cornell, Training and Consulting…

Learn More

Cover of first edition of the Diary of Anne Frank

Anne Frank in the (Historical) News

Blog post discussing the January 1, 2016 online publication of The Diary of Anne Frank. Regardless of what comes of the latest turn of events related to this momentous work, installments of the diary, as well as related information, can be seen…

Learn More

Lisa Tuite

CSI, Librarian-style: Research Forensics in the News Library

As a librarian at The Boston Globe, Lisa Tuite helped uncover the 2001 story about sexual abuse in the Catholic Church with “research forensics.”…

Learn More

Search the Blog

Archive

Follow