High Prevalence of Nickel Allergy in an Overweight Female Population: A Pilot Observational Analysis

Abstract

Context

In our Allergy Unit, we incidentally observed that a low Nickel diet, prescribed for delayed allergy to Nickel sulfate, reduced body mass index (BMI) and waist circumference in overweight patients.

Objectives

This pilot cross-sectional analysis was undertaken to compare the prevalence of Nickel allergy of overweight individuals versus the general population. We also had the chance to report the efficacy of a low Nickel diet on BMI and waist circumference in Nickel-sensitive overweight subjects.

Methods

Eighty-seven overweight subjects, with a BMI >26 Kg/m2, were consecutively enrolled in a health prevention program, and screened for the presence of Nickel allergy. The enrolled population was mostly females (72/87) (82.8%). Forty-three overweight women and two men showed a Nickel allergy and started a low Nickel diet. After 6-months of dieting, 24 overweight allergic women could be traced and changes in BMI and waist circumference were calculated.

Main Outcome Measurements

Prevalence of Nickel allergy in overweight.

Results

Prevalence of Nickel allergy in overweight female was 59.7%, compared with a prevalence rate of 12.5% in the general population. A significant reduction in BMI was observed in 24 out of 43 overweight females with Nickel allergy after 24 weeks of a low Nickel diet. Relative to baseline, mean BMI decrease was 4.2±0.5 (P <0.001) and the mean decline in waist circumference was 11.7±0.6 cm (P< 0.001).

Conclusions

This pilot observational analysis showed a substantially higher prevalence of Nickel allergy among overweight females, especially those with metabolic syndrome and fatty liver disease. A normocaloric low Nickel diet was effective in reducing BMI in this population. Further research is strongly needed to confirm these preliminary findings.

About the Authors:

Elena Angela Lusi

* E-mail: [email protected]

Affiliation: St Vincent Private Hospital, Dublin, Ireland

Vincenzo Maria Di Ciommo

Affiliation: Ospedale Pediatrico Bambino Gesu’, Epidemiology and Biostatistics Unit, Rome, Italy

Tommaso Patrissi

Affiliation: Central Laboratory, Cardiology and Preventive Medicine Unit, Italian Red Cross, Rome, Italy

Paolo Guarascio

Affiliation: Liver Unit, St Camillo-Forlanini Hospital, Rome, Italy

Introduction

Nickel is the fourth most used metal in the world and its consumption is forecast to grow being used for several industrial products and medical appliances (Roskill analysis). As a natural element of the earth's crust small amounts are found in water, soil, and natural foods. Major dietary source of Nickel is plant food. Plant tissues contain more Nickel than animal tissues [1–2]. Nickel is an ideal sensitizing agent and it is responsible for the highest incidence of skin sensitization in the industrialized world, even in the pediatric age [3–5]. However, Nickel allergy not only affects the skin, but also results in systemic manifestations. Systemic Nickel allergy syndrome, is clinically characterized by cutaneous and systemic symptoms (such as headache, asthenia, itching, and gastrointestinal disorders related to histopathologic alterations of gastrointestinal mucosa) [6–8].

It has been estimated that the prevalence of Nickel allergy in the general population, is 8–15% for females and 1–3% for males [9–11]. However, in our Allergy Unit, we incidentally noticed an unusually high prevalence of Nickel allergy in overweight subjects, especially women with metabolic syndrome in the perimenopause age.

Therefore, we decided to undertake this pilot cross-sectional analysis to compare the prevalence of Nickel allergy of overweight individuals versus the general population. We also had the chance to report the efficacy of a low Nickel diet on BMI and waist circumference in Nickel-sensitive overweight subjects.

To our knowledge, this study is the first to evaluate the prevalence of Nickel allergy in overweight subjects and to evaluate the effectiveness of a low Nickel diet in reducing BMI.

Materials and Methods

This study was carried out in the Allergy and Clinical Immunology Unit of the Central Laboratory of the Italian Red Cross, in Rome.

We enrolled 87 consecutive subjects (15 males, 72 females) with high BMI (>26 Kg/m2) referred to the Preventive Health Service of the Italian Red Cross for general health check-up and we screened this cohort for the presence of Nickel allergy. Anthropometric measurements (height, weight, BMI, waist circumference), blood pressure and biochemical variables (liver panels, fasting glucose, insulin, total cholesterol, triglycerides) were measured in each enrolled subject. Metabolic syndrome was diagnosed according to the modified NCEP ATP III criteria [12]. The presence of echogenic liver steatosis was also determined. Insulin resistance was estimated with the homeostasis model assessment index (HOMA), calculated as fasting glucose (mmol/L) times fasting insulin (mIU/L) divided by 22.5. Percentage of body fat was calculated as described previously [13]. Nickel allergy was diagnosed with a patch test performed with Nickel sulfate 5% (Lofarma Diagnostic) on scan pore disks, with delayed reactions evaluated 72 hours from disk application.

According to the current guidance for Nickel allergy treatment, a normocaloric balanced diet, formulated to be low only in Nickel (80–100 µg/daily), was prescribed to allergic overweight patients. The diet plan was developed by selecting low Nickel content foods from published database and following Sharma’s points as a guide [1]. We included traditional foods common in western diets and acceptable to the study population. Milk, eggs, all types of meat, fish, refined flower, vegetables and fruit with low nickel content were permitted. Instead legumes, soy, whole-grain products were excluded and the consumption of tomatoes and some vegetables (cauliflower, carrots, onions, spinach, lettuce) restricted. An allergist and a nearby nutritionist gave both verbal and written instruction of the diet.

Forty-three overweight allergic women and two allergic men started the diet. They had regulars appointments at 4, 8, 12 weeks. A follow-up of 24 weeks was established as final end point, to evaluate the long term efficacy of a low Nickel diet in reducing anthropometric indices.

Statistical Analysis

Prevalence study

In order to determine if the prevalence of Nickel allergy in our sample study group was higher than the prevalence observed in the general population, we used as test method the one-sample z test for proportions (Minitab Statistical Software).

Analysis of BMI and waist circumference at the baseline and at six months

All data were analyzed using two-tailed paired sample t tests. A P value of less than 0.05 was considered significant.

Ethics Statement

A specific ethical committee approval was not looked for because a Nickel-free diet is the current preventive precaution for patients with nickel allergy and implies very low health risk. Follow-up was entirely free from charge as other preventive advices from the Red Cross. Patients did not receive any payment for participation. Approval for this study was obtained from the IRB of the Italian Red Cross (N 0053214). Each subject’s consent was documented in the medical notes.

Results

Nickel Prevalence in Overweight Subjects

Demographic characteristics, anthropometric measurements and laboratory values of the enrolled population are described in Tables 1 and 2 respectively.

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Table 1. Demographic characteristics of enrolled subjects at baseline.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0123265.t001

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Table 2. Anthropometric measurements and laboratory values of enrolled subjects.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0123265.t002

The patch test showed a considerable higher prevalence of Nickel allergy in overweight patients compared to the general population. In particular, the prevalence of Nickel allergy among overweight women and males was 59.7% (43/72) (95% CI: 47.5% -71.1%; P<0.001) and 13.3% (2/15) (95% CI: 0–31.0%; P<0.1) respectively, in contrast to a prevalence rate of Nickel allergy of 8–15% in women and 1–3% in males in the general population [9–11] (Table 3), (Fig 1).

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Table 3. Nickel Allergy Prevalence in our study sample of overweight subjects is significantly higher than in the general population.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0123265.t003

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Fig 1. Prevalence of Nickel Allergy in overweight subjects (BMI≥26 kg/m2) compared to the general population [9]-[11].

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0123265.g001

In the cases of overweight associated with metabolic syndrome and complicated by liver steatosis, the prevalence of Nickel allergy for females was slightly higher: 61.1% (22/36) (95% CI: 43%-77%).

Effects of a Low Dietary Nickel on Anthropometric Indices at six months

Since males were too few, our statistical analysis included only the females population. At 24 weeks, of the 43 allergic overweight females, who started the low Nickel treatment, 24 were still following the diet and completed the follow-up.

Relative to baseline, mean BMI decrease was 4.2±0.5 (P <0.001) and the mean decline in waist circumference was 11.7±0.6 cm (P< 0.001) (Table 4).

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Table 4. Changes in BMI, Body Fat and Waist circumference in 24 overweight females with Nickel allergy who completed the follow up at 6 months.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0123265.t004

The 19 overweight females were simply lost to follow-up. The main reasons for dropping out of the study were conflict with work schedule (15%) and having other health problems (13%). The rest of the dropouts were unavailable despite several phone calls. Interestingly, no subject complained about the diet and cited it as the reason for dropping out.

Discussion

In our Allergy Unit, we realized that the majority of overweight people, especially women of menopausal age, had a Nickel allergy. In particular, overweight females showed a prevalence of Nickel allergy of 59.7%. If we consider overweight cases associated with metabolic syndrome and complicated by liver steatosis, the prevalence of Nickel allergy is slightly higher (61.1%). This is noteworthy, if we consider that the mean prevalence of Nickel allergy for females in the general population is 12.5% [9–11].

When a normocaloric diet, formulated to be low only in Nickel (100 µg/daily), was prescribed to allergic overweight females as the established therapy for their allergy, they manifested a reduction in body mass index and waist circumference in the first three months of diet, and this reduction was maintained stable at six months of follow up.

Is there a chance that Nickel could be related to overweight? Dipping back to the Seventies, biochemists already taught us that exposure of Nickel in animal models induces insulin overload, glycogenolysis and hyperglycemia in a concentration dependent manner [14–23]. Dose-dependent relationships between the amount of ingested Nickel and dermatitis with systemic symptoms has been demonstrated in various studies in humans [24]. Individual diets may vary, leading to substantial variability in Nickel intake. For example, if an individual consumed the following daily diet: breakfast—a bowl of oatmeal (0.22mg of Nickel) and one banana (0.04mg); lunch—one whole grain bun (0.01mg) with a chicken breast (0.01mg), green beans (0.03mg), and a Hershey’s bar (0.01mg); dinner—a serving of broccoli (0.02mg), a baked potato (0.02mg), and a pork chop (0.005mg); snack—a half-cup of peanuts (0.22mg); his or her Nickel intake for the day would be 0.58mg, which is well above the amount shown to cause flares [25–26].

A low Nickel diet is the standard therapy for sensitive patients with dermatitis associated with systemic manifestations.

However, the efficacy of a low Nickel diet in reducing BMI and waist circumference has never been described. Which could be the link between Nickel allergy, overweight and females in perimenopause?

A review of current research illustrates that overweight is a chronic inflammatory state and pro-inflammatory cytokine IL-17 is up regulated in the blood of obese humans [27–28]. IL-17 is also considerably produced by Nickel-specific T lymphocytes [29–30]. During menopause, estrogen deficiency induces the differentiation of IL-17 secreting Th cells [31–32]. Since Nickel is also a potent inducer of IL-17 production, it could be argued that an high dietary Nickel load may act in a synergistic way to increase the level of inflammation in allergic women during menopause. We can speculate that a young woman with a Nickel allergy is likely to develop a skin eczema and irritable bowel abnormalities, while a woman with a Nickel allergy in her menopause age is mostly like to gain weight and develop metabolic abnormalities.

Obesity is not only an immunological inflammation, but other factors appear to be important. Recent evidences suggest that the gut microbes play a role in determining the obese phenotype. Germ free mice are protected against obesity and the transfer of gut microbes from obese animals results in dramatic increase in body fat and insulin resistance in the recipients [33]. Many bacterial strains use Nickel in their growing process. Helicobacter pylori stores Nickel to aid its host colonization and a low Nickel diet enhances its eradication [34–35]. Is it conceivable that the excess of Nickel intake, not being essential in the body, is needed for the development of the gut’s microflora? An interesting hypothesis is that an high Nickel concentration select Nickel specific bacteria which in turn trigger an inflammation process in the gut of obese people. It therefore appears that Nickel may have pleiotropic roles in determining overweight: immunological, biochemical and microbiological.

The results of this pilot analysis are definitively preliminary and must be interpreted with caution, since the evaluation of a low Nickel diet lacked a control group. If confirmed, however, a patch test for metals in diabetes and nutrition centres might be suggested.

Limitations

A potential limitation is that a low Nickel diet is relatively fiber poor and can lead to constipation in some patients, and we cannot give any information regarding the long-term consequences of consuming this special diet. Other limitations are the low sample size and the lack of a control group. Large cohorts of patients from multiple institutions and multivariate analysis are needed and tests should be carried out between different ethnicities, since this clinical study was performed only in the Italian population.

In this study, we could not evaluate males because of their small numbers and our findings are applicable only to females. Females were overrepresented in our study group, probably because more women are obese than men and Nickel allergy is more frequent in women than man. A larger sample would permit a sufficient number of male patients to be represented. Strategies to enhance the adherence to a low nickel diet program should also be adopted.

Conclusion

This pilot observational analysis showed a substantially higher prevalence of Nickel allergy among overweight females, especially those with metabolic syndrome and fatty liver disease. A normocaloric low Nickel diet was effective in reducing BMI in this population. Further research is strongly needed to confirm these preliminary findings.

Transparency Declaration

We affirm that this manuscript is an honest, accurate and transparent account of the study being reported; that no important aspects of the study has been omitted.

Acknowledgments

We thank the nurses of the Italian Red Cross for their excellent logistic support and Mrs. Paola Profili for her helpful contribution.

Author Contributions

Conceived and designed the experiments: EAL. Performed the experiments: EAL TP PG. Analyzed the data: VMDC EAL. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: EAL TP PG. Wrote the paper: EAL VMDC.

Citation: Lusi EA, Di Ciommo VM, Patrissi T, Guarascio P (2015) High Prevalence of Nickel Allergy in an Overweight Female Population: A Pilot Observational Analysis. PLoS ONE 10(3): e0123265. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0123265

References

1. Sharma AD. Low nickel diet in dermatology. Indian J Dermatol. 2013 May;58(3):240. pmid:23723489

2. Eskew DL, Welch RM, Cary EE. Nickel: an essential micronutrient for legumes and possibly all higher plants. Science. 1983 Nov 11;222(4624):621–3. pmid:17843840

3. Yoshihisa Y, Shimizu T. Metal Allergy and Systemic Contact Dermatitis: An Overview. Dermatol Res Pract. 2012;2012:749561. pmid:22693488

4. Zug KA, Pham AK, Belsito DV, DeKoven JG, DeLeo VA, Fowler JF Jr, et al. Patch testing in children from 2005 to 2012: results from the North American contact dermatitis group. Dermatitis. 2014 Nov-Dec;25(6):345–55. pmid:25384228

5. Admani S, Jacob SE. Allergic contact dermatitis in children: review of the past decade. Curr Allergy Asthma Rep. 2014 Apr;14(4):421 pmid:24504525

6. Braga M, Quecchia C, Perotta C, Timpini A, Maccarinelli K, Di Tommaso L, et al. Systemic nickel allergy syndrome: nosologic framework and usefulness of diet regimen for diagnosis. Int J Immunopathol Pharmacol. 2013 Jul-Sep;26(3):707–16. pmid:24067467

7. Ricciardi L, Arena A, Arena E, Zambito M, Ingrassia A, Valenti G, et al. Systemic nickel allergy syndrome: epidemiological data from four Italian allergy units. Int J Immunopathol Pharmacol. 2014 Jan-Mar;27(1):131–6. pmid:24674689

8. Pizzutelli S. Systemic nickel hypersensitivity and diet: myth or reality? Eur Ann Allergy Clin Immunol. 2011 Feb;43(1):5–18. pmid:21409856

9. Thyssen JP, Linneberg A, Menne’ T, Johansen JD. The epidemiology of contact allergy in the general population—prevalence and main findings. Contact Dermatitis. 2007 Nov;57(5):287–99. pmid:17937743

10. ESSCA Writing Group. The European Surveillance System of Contact Allergies (ESSCA): results of patch testing the standard series, 2004. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2008 Feb;22(2):174–81. pmid:18211410

11. Krob HA, Fleischer AB Jr, D’Agostino R Jr, Haverstock CL, Feldman S. Prevalence and relevance of contact dermatitis allergens: a meta-analysis of 15 years of published T.R.U.E. test data. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2004 Sep;51(3):349–53. pmid:15337975

12. Cornier MA, Dabelea D, Hernandez TL, Lindstrom RC, Steig AJ, Stob NR, et al. The metabolic syndrome. Endocr Rev 2008 Dec;29(7):777–822 pmid:18971485

13. Deurenberg P, Weststrate JA, Seidell JC. Body Mass Index as a measure of body fatness: age and sex specific prediction formulas. Br J Nutr 1991 Mar;65(2):105–14. pmid:2043597

14. Saggerson ED, Sooranna SR, Evans CJ. Insulin-like actions of nickel and other transition-metal ions in rat fat-cells. Biochem J. 1976 Feb 15;154(2):349–57. pmid:938454

15. Dormer RL, Kerbey AL, McPherson M, Manley S, Ashcroft SJ, Schofield JG, et al. The effect of nickel on secretory systems. Studies on the release of amylase, insulin and growth hormone. Biochem J. 1974 May;140(2):135–42. pmid:4375956

16. Bwititi PT, Ashorobi RB. Effects of chronic oral nickel chloride administration on glycaemia and renal function in normal and diabetic rats. Afr J Health Sci. 1998 Jul-Dec;5(3–4):198–201. pmid:17581019

17. Mayor P, Cabrera R, Ribas B, Calle C. Effect of long-term nickel ingestion on insulin binding and antilipolytic response in rat adipocytes. Biol Trace Elem Res. 1989 Oct;22(1):63–70. pmid:2484229

18. Kadota I, Kurita M. Hyperglycemia and islet cell damage caused by nickelous chloride. Metabolism. 1955 Jul;4(4):337–42. pmid:14393557

19. Cartana J, Arola L. Nickel-induced hyperglycaemia: the role of insulin and glucagon. Toxicology. 1992;71(1–2):181–92. pmid:1736418

20. Gupta S, Ahmad N, Husain MM, Srivastava RC. Involvement of nitric oxide in nickel-induced hyperglycemia in rats. Nitric Oxide. 2000 Apr;4(2):129–38. pmid:10835293

21. Tikare SN, Das Gupta A, Dhundasi SA, Das KK. Effect of antioxidants L-ascorbic acid andα-tocopherol supplementation in nickel exposed hyperglycemic rats. J Basic Clin Physiol Pharmacol. 2008;19(2):89–101. pmid:19024927

22. Novelli EL, Rodrigues NL, Ribas BO. Nickel chloride protection against alloxan- and q2 streptozotocin induced diabetes. Braz J Med Biol Res. 1988;21(1):129–32. pmid:2972332

23. Ol Kubrak, Rovenko BM, Husak VV, Storey JM, Storey KB, Lushchak VI. Nickel induces hyperglycemia and glycogenolysis and affects the antioxidant system in liver and white muscle of goldfish Carassius auratus L. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf. 2012 Jun;80:231–7. pmid:22444726

24. Jensen CS, Menné T, Lisby S, Kristiansen J, Veien NK. Experimental systemic contact dermatitis from nickel: a dose-response study. Contact Dermatitis. 2003;49(3):124–132. pmid:14678208

25. Joneja JM. Section III: specific food restrictions: nickel allergy. In: Joneja JM, editor. Managing Food Allergy & Intolerance: A Practical Guide. JA Hall Publications Ltd; 1995.

26. Zirwas MJ, Molenda MA. Dietary Nickel as a Cause of Systemic Contact Dermatitis. J Clin Aesthet Dermatol. Jun 2009; 2(6): 39–43. pmid:20729949

27. Ahmed M, Gaffen SL. IL-17 in Obesity and Adipogenesis. Cytokine Growth Factor Rev. Dec 2010:21(6):449–453. pmid:21084215

28. Winer S, Paltser G, Chan Y, Tsui H, Engleman E, Winer D et al. Obesity predisposes to Th17 bias. Eur J Immunol. 2009;39:2629–2635. pmid:19662632

29. Dyring-Andersen B, Skov L, Løvendorf MB, Bzorek M, Søndergaard K, Lauritsen JP, et al. CD4(+) T cells producing interleukin (IL)-17, IL-22 and interferon-γ are major effector T cells in nickel allergy. Contact Dermatitis 2013 Jun;68(6):339–47. pmid:23692034

30. Albanesi C, Cavani A, Girolomoni G. L-17 is Produced by Nickel-Specific T Lymphocytes and Regulates ICAM-1 Expression and Chemokine Production in Human Keratinocytes: Synergistic or Antagonist Effects with IFN-γ and TNF-α. J Immunol 1999; 162:494–502. pmid:9886425

31. Tyagi AM, Srivastava K, Mansoori MN, Trivedi R, Chattopadhyay N, et al. Estrogen Deficiency Induces the Differentiation of IL-17 Secreting Th17 Cells: A New Candidate in the Pathogenesis of Osteoporosis. PLoS One. 2012; 7(9): e44552. pmid:22970248

32. Monar I, Bohaty I, Somogvine-Vari É. High prevalence of increased interleukin-17A serum levels in postmenopausal estrogen deficiency. Menopause. 2014 Jul;21(7):749–52. pmid:24253487

33. Krajmalnik-Bown R., Ilhan ZE, Kang DW, DiBaise JK. Effects of gut microbes on nutrient absorption and energy regulation. Nutr Clin Pract. 2012 Apr;27(2):201–14. pmid:22367888

34. Benoit SL, Miller EF, Maier RJ. Helicobacter pylori stores Nickel to aid its host colonization Infect Immun. February 2013 vol. 81(2) 580–4. pmid:23230291

35. Campanale M, Nucera E, Ojetti V, Cesario V, Di Rienzo TA, D’Angelo G, et al. Nickel free-diet enhances the Helicobacter pylori eradication rate: a pilot study. Dig Dis Sci. 2014 Aug;59(8):1851–5. pmid:24595654