Increasing habitat complexity on seawalls: Investigating large- and small-scale effects on fish assemblages

Abstract

The construction of artificial structures in the marine environment is increasing globally. Eco-engineering aims to mitigate the negative ecological impacts of built infrastructure through designing structures to be multifunctional, benefiting both humans and nature. To date, the focus of eco-engineering has largely been on benefits for benthic invertebrates and algae. Here, the potential effect of eco-engineered habitats designed for benthic species on fish was investigated. Eco-engineered habitats (“flowerpots”) were added to an intertidal seawall in Sydney Harbour, Australia. Responses of fish assemblages to the added habitats were quantified at two spatial scales; large (among seawalls) and small (within a seawall). Data were collected during high tide using cameras attached to the seawall to observe pelagic and benthic fish. At the larger spatial scale, herbivores, planktivores, and invertebrate predators were generally more abundant at the seawall with the added flowerpots, although results were temporally variable. At the smaller spatial scale, certain benthic species were more abundant around flowerpots than at the adjacent control areas of seawall, although there was no general pattern of differences in species density and trophic group abundance of pelagic fish between areas of the seawall with or without added habitats. Although we did not find consistent, statistically significant findings throughout our study, the field of research to improve fish habitat within human-use constraints is promising and important, although it is in its early stages (it is experimental and requires a lot of trial and error). To advance this field, it is important to document when effects were detected, and when they were not, so that others can refine the designs or scale of habitat enhancements or their study approaches (e.g., sampling protocols).

REFERENCES Able, K. W., Manderson, J. P., & Studholme, A. L. (1998). The distribution of shallow water juvenile fishes in an urban estuary: The effects of manmade structures in the lower Hudson river. Estuaries, 21, 731–744. Airoldi, L., Abbiati, M., Beck, M. W., Hawkins, S. J., Jonsson, P. R., Martin, D., … Aberg, P. (2005). An ecological perspective on the deployment and design of low-crested and other hard coastal defence structures. Coastal Engineering, 52, 1073–1087. Airoldi, L., & Beck, M. W. (2007). Loss, status and trends for coastal marine habitats of Europe. In R. N. Gibson, R. J. A. Atkinson, & J. D. M. Gordon (Eds.), Oceanography and marine biology: An annual review, Vol. 45 (pp. 345–405). Florida, United States: CRC Press. Anderson, M. J., & Connell, S. D. (1999). Predation by fish on intertidal oysters. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 187, 203–211. Baine, M. (2001). Artificial reefs: A review of their design, application, management and performance. Ocean & Coastal Management, 44, 241–259. Bishop, M. J., Mayer-Pinto, M., Airoldi, L., Firth, L. B., Morris, R. L., Loke, L. H. L., … Dafforn, K. A. (2016). Effects of ocean sprawl on ecological connectivity: Impacts and solutions. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 492, 7–30. Brown, J. H. (1984). On the relationship between abundance and distribution of species. The American Naturalist, 124, 255–279. Browne, M. A., & Chapman, M. G. (2011). Ecologically informed engineering reduces loss of intertidal biodiversity on artificial shorelines. Environmental Science & Technology, 45, 8204–8207. Browne, M. A., & Chapman, M. G. (2014). Mitigating against the loss of species by adding artificial intertidal pools to existing seawalls. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 497, 119–129. Bulleri, F., & Chapman, M. G. (2010). The introduction of coastal infrastructure as a driver of change in marine environments. Journal of Applied Ecology, 47, 26–35. Burt, J. A., Feary, D. A., Cavalcante, G., Bauman, A. G., & Usseglio, P. (2013). Urban breakwaters as reef fish habitat in the Persian Gulf. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 72, 342–350. Cappo, M., Harvey, E., & Shortis, M. (2007). Counting and measuring fish with baited video techniques – An overview. In D. Furlani, & J. P. Beumer (Eds.), Proceedings of the Australian Society for Fish Biology Workshop, Hobart, August 2007 (pp. 101–114). Australia: Australian Society of Fish Biology. Carlile, D. W., Skalski, J. R., Batker, J. E., Thomas, J. M., & Cullinan, V. I. (1989). Determination of ecological scale. Landscape Ecology, 2, 203–213. Chapman, M. G. (2003). Paucity of mobile species on constructed seawalls: Effects of urbanization on biodiversity. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 264, 21–29. Chapman, M. G. (2012). Restoring intertidal boulder-fields as habitat for “specialist” and “generalist” animals. Restoration Ecology, 20, 277–285. Chapman, M. G., & Blockley, D. J. (2009). Engineering novel habitats on urban infrastructure to increase intertidal biodiversity. Oecologia, 161, 625–635. Chapman, M. G., & Clynick, B. G. (2006). Experiments testing the use of waste material in estuaries as habitat for subtidal organisms. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 338, 164–178. Chapman, M. G., & Underwood, A. J. (2011). Evaluation of ecological engineering of “armoured” shorelines to improve their value as habitat. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 400, 302–313. Chapman, M. G., Underwood, A. J., & Browne, M. A. (2017). An assessment of the current usage of ecological engineering and reconciliation ecology in managing alterations to habitats in urban estuaries. Ecological Engineering, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoleng.2017.06.050 Clynick, B. G. (2008). Characteristics of an urban fish assemblage: Distribution of fish associated with coastal marinas. Marine Environmental Research, 65, 18–33. Clynick, B. G., Chapman, M. G., & Underwood, A. J. (2007). Effects of epibiota on assemblages of fish associated with urban structures. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 332, 201–210. Connell, S. D., & Anderson, M. J. (1999). Predation by fish on assemblages of intertidal epibiota: Effects of predator size and patch size. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 241, 15–29. Dafforn, K. A., Glasby, T. M., Airoldi, L., Rivero, N. K., Mayer-Pinto, M., & Johnston, E. L. (2015). Marine urbanization: An ecological framework for designing multifunctional artificial structures. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 13, 82–90. Dugan, J. E., Airoldi, L., Chapman, M. G., Walker, S. J., & Schlacher, T. (2011). Estuarine and coastal structures: Environmental effects, a focus on shore and nearshore structures. In E. Wolanski, & D. McLusky (Eds.), Treatise on estuarine and coastal science, Vol 8: Human-induced problems (pp. 17–41). London: Elsevier. Favaro, C., & Moore, J. W. (2015). Fish assemblages and barriers in an urban stream network. Freshwater Science, 34, 991–1005. Feary, D. A., Burt, J. A., & Bartholomew, A. (2011). Artificial marine habitats in the Arabian Gulf: Review of current use, benefits and management implications. Ocean & Coastal Management, 54, 742–749. Ferrario, F., Iveša, L., Jaklin, A., Perkol-Finkel, S., & Airoldi, L. (2015). The overlooked role of biotic factors in controlling the ecological performance of artificial marine habitats. Journal of Applied Ecology, 53, 16–24. Firth, L. B., Browne, K. A., Knights, A. M., Hawkins, S. J., & Nash, R. (2016). Eco-engineered rock pools: A concrete solution to biodiversity loss and urban sprawl in the marine environment. Environmental Research Letters, 11, 094015. https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/11/9/094015 Firth, L., Knights, A., Thompson, R., Mieszkowska, N., Bridger, D., Evans, A., … Hawkins, S. (2016). Ocean sprawl: Challenges and opportunities for biodiversity management in a changing world. Oceanography and Marine Biology: An Annual Review, 54, 189–262. Firth, L. B., Thompson, R. C., Bohn, K., Abbiati, M., Airoldi, L., Bouma, T. J., … Hawkins, S. J. (2014). Between a rock and a hard place: Environmental and engineering considerations when designing coastal defence structures. Coastal Engineering, 87, 122–135. Firth, L. B., Thompson, R. C., White, F. J., Schofield, M., Skov, M. W., Hoggart, S. P. G., … Hawkins, S. J. (2013). The importance of water-retaining features for biodiversity on artificial intertidal coastal defence structures. Diversity and Distributions, 19, 1275–1283. Glasby, T. M. (1997). Analysing data hom post-impact studies using asymmetrical analyses of variance: A case study of epibiota on marinas. Australian Journal of Ecology, 22, 448–459. Gratwicke, B., & Speight, M. R. (2005). The relationship between fish species richness, abundance and habitat complexity in a range of shallow tropical marine habitats. Journal of Fish Biology, 66, 650–667. Guidetti, P., Fanelli, G., Fraschetti, S., Terlizzi, A., & Boero, F. (2002). Coastal fish indicate human-induced changes in the Mediterranean littoral. Marine Environmental Research, 53, 77–94. Harborne, A. R., Mumby, P. J., Kennedy, E. V., & Ferrari, R. (2011). Biotic and multi-scale abiotic controls of habitat quality: Their effect on coral-reef fishes. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 437, 201–214. Hixon, M. A., & Brostoff, W. N. (1996). Succession and herbivory: Effects of differential fish grazing on Hawaiian coral-reef algae. Ecological Monographs, 66, 67–90. Johnson, A. F., Jenkins, S. R., Hiddink, J. G., & Hinz, H. (2013). Linking temperate demersal fish species to habitat: Scales, patterns and future directions. Fish and Fisheries, 14, 256–280. Kennelly, S. J. (1991). Caging experiments to examine the effects of fishes on understorey species in a sublittoral kelp community. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 147, 207–230. Komyakova, V., Munday, P. L., & Jones, G. P. (2013). Relative importance of coral cover, habitat complexity and diversity in determining the structure of reef fish communities. PLoS ONE, 8, e83178. https://doi.org/83110.81371/journal.pone.0083178 Loke, L. H. L., Ladle, R. J., Bouma, T. J., & Todd, P. A. (2015). Creating complex habitats for restoration and reconciliation. Ecological Engineering, 77, 307–313. MacArthur, R. H., & MacArthur, J. W. (1961). On bird species diversity. Ecology, 42, 594–598. Mayer-Pinto, M., Johnston, E. L., Bugnot, A. B., Glasby, T. M., Airoldi, L., Mitchell, A., & Dafforn, K. A. (2017). Building ‘blue’: An eco-engineering framework for foreshore developments. Journal of Environmental Management, 189, 109–114. Munsch, S. H., Cordell, J. R., & Toft, J. D. (2015a). Effects of seawall armoring on juvenile Pacific salmon diets in an urban estuarine embayment. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 535, 213–229. Munsch, S. H., Cordell, J. R., & Toft, J. D. (2015b). Effects of shoreline engineering on shallow subtidal fish and crab communities in an urban estuary: A comparison of armored shorelines and nourished beaches. Ecological Engineering, 81, 312–320. Munsch, S. H., Cordell, J. R., & Toft, J. D. (2017). Effects of shoreline armouring and overwater structures on coastal and estuarine fish: Opportunities for habitat improvement. Journal of Applied Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2664.12906 Pielou, E. C. (1984). Population and community ecology principles and methods. New York, NY: Gordon and Breach Science Publishers Ltd.. Pradella, N., Fowler, A. M., Booth, D. J., & Macreadie, P. I. (2014). Fish assemblages associated with oil industry structures on the continental shelf of north-western Australia. Journal of Fish Biology, 84, 247–255. Rilov, G., & Benayahu, Y. (1998). Vertical artificial structures as an alternative habitat for coral reef fishes in disturbed environments. Marine Environmental Research, 45, 431–451. Rilov, G., & Benayahu, Y. (2000). Fish assemblage on natural versus vertical artificial reefs: The rehabilitation perspective. Marine Biology, 136, 931–942. Rilov, G., Figueira, W. F., Lyman, S. J., & Crowder, L. B. (2007). Complex habitats may not always benefit prey: Linking visual field with reef fish behavior and distribution. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 329, 225–238. Rosenzweig, M. L. (2003). Win-win ecology: How the earth's species can survive in the midst of human enterprise. New York: Oxford University Press. Sella, I., & Perkol-Finkel, S. (2015). Blue is the new green – ecological enhancement of concrete based coastal and marine infrastructure. Ecological Engineering, 84, 260–272. Sokal, R. R., & Rohlf, F. J. (2012). Biometry, the principles and practice of statistics on biological research. New York: W. H. Freeman and Company. Strain, E. M. A., Morris, R. L., Coleman, R. A., Figueira, W. F., Steinberg, P. D., Johnston, E. L., & Bishop, M. J. (2017). Designing urban structures to reduce fish predation on native bivalves. Ecological Engineering, https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2664.12961 Strain, E. M. A., Olabarria, C., Mayer-Pinto, M., Combo, V., Morris, R. L., Bugnot, A. B., … Bishop, M. J. (2017). Eco-engineering urban infrastructure for marine and coastal biodiversity: Which interventions have the greatest ecological benefit? Journal of Applied Ecology, https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2664.12961 Stuart-Smith, R. D., Bates, A. E., Lefcheck, J. S., Duffy, J. E., Baker, S. C., Thomson, R. J., … Edgar, G. J. (2013). Integrating abundance and functional traits reveals new global hotspots of fish diversity. Nature, 501, 539–542. Syms, C. (1995). Multiscale analysis of habitat association in a guild of blennioid fishes. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 125, 31–43. Thom, R. M. (2000). Adaptive management of coastal ecosystem restoration projects. Ecological Engineering, 15, 365–372. Toft, J. D., Cordell, J. R., Simenstad, C. A., & Stamatiou, L. A. (2007). Fish distribution, abundance, and behavior along city shoreline types in puget sound. North American Journal of Fisheries Management, 27, 465–480. Toft, J. D., Ogston, A. S., Heerhartz, S. M., Cordell, J. R., & Flemer, E. E. (2013). Ecological response and physical stability of habitat enhancements along an urban armored shoreline. Ecological Engineering, 57, 97–108. Tuya, F., Wernberg, T., & Thomsen, M. S. (2009). Habitat structure affect abundances of labrid fishes across temperate reefs in south-western Australia. Environmental Biology of Fishes, 86, 311–319. Underwood, A. J. (1993). The mechanics of spatially replicated sampling programs to detect environmental impacts in a variable world. Australian Journal of Ecology, 18, 99–116. Underwood, A. J. (1997). Experiments in ecology: Their logical design and interpretation using analysis of variance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Vergés, A., Vanderklift, M. A., Doropoulos, C., & Hyndes, G. A. (2011). Spatial patterns in herbivory on a coral reef are influenced by structural complexity but not by algal traits. PLoS ONE, 6, e17115. Walters, C. J., & Holling, C. S. (1990). Large-scale management experiments and learning by doing. Ecology, 71, 2060–2068. Wen, C. K. C., Pratchett, M. S., Shao, K. T., Kan, K. P., & Chan, B. K. K. (2010). Effects of habitat modification on coastal fish assemblages. Journal of Fish Biology, 77, 1674–1687.