Content area
Full text
Crossroads to Islam: The Origins of the Arab Religion and the Arab State. By YEHUDA D. NEVO and JUDITH KOREN. Amherst, New York: PROMETHEUS, 2003. Pp. viii + 462. $32.
Crossroads to Islam is a work of profound historical and religious revisionism, based on the research and ideas of the eccentric Israeli archaeologist Yehuda Nevo, collected and completed by Judith Koren after Nevo's death in 1992. Nevo spent much of his career in the Negev desert, studying early Arabic inscriptions and rethinking the origins of Islam. In his controversial article "Towards a Pre-History of Islam" (JSAI 17 [1994] 108-41), Nevo argued that these inscriptions reveal a gradual process in which Islam developed from an indeterminate monotheism to the religion we now know through the first two centuries AH. Crossroads to Islam is still more ambitious. Here Nevo and Koren present a radically new vision for the development of Islam and the Islamic empire, in which the familiar events and personalities of early Islamic history-including the Prophet Muhammad and the first four caliphs-are characters of myth, not history.
There is, then, a certain ideological similarity between this work and that of Wansbrough. Indeed, in the conclusion the authors note (pp. 343-44) that their date for the canonization of the Qur'an (late 2nd/8th century), arrived at through material evidence, is not far from that of Wansbrough, arrived at through literary analysis. Crossroads to Islam, meanwhile, is published by Prometheus Press, known for sponsoring projects of religious skepticism, including the second edition of Wansbrough's Qur 'anic Studies. Nevertheless, the great intellectual presence looming behind this work is not Wansbrough but rather Shlomo Pines, whose belief in the survival and influence of heterodox Judaeo-Christian movements shapes the Nevo/Koren thesis.
Yet Crossroads to Islam does not begin with religion at all, but rather with history. In part I, Nevo and Koren reconsider the relation of Byzantium with the Arabs through the early Islamic period, rewriting this period of Byzantine history in a way no less radical than their treatment of Islamic history. The Islamic conquests, they argue, were not conquests at all. Byzantium withdrew her forces south of Antioch of her own will, in a gradual process that can be traced all the way back to the third century, when...