Content area
Full Text
Although there is some consensus among theorists regarding attributes of parents that associate with optimal child outcomes, translation of the theory into measures has been variable and inconsistent. These inconsistencies have been surprisingly little noted in the literature and present a particular problem to researchers seeking to study parenting in little examined cultures. This article describes these inconsistencies, and suggests some practical resolutions based on the writers' recent experience of studying parenting in Islamic cultures. Some dilemmas and choice points described are: the use of typologies vs. dimensions; measures of parenting styles vs. practices; the limited number of items in most current scales of 'style' as opposed to 'practice' domains; strategies to assess the validity of parenting practices when the culture-specific 'meaning' of the behaviour is not known; and the implications of the greater degree of gender differentiation in cultures studied. Steps proposed as criteria for assembling scales and determining psychometric acceptability when adapting measures to new cultures are outlined. It is the goal of this article to raise discussion both about the inconsistencies and lack of standardization of measures in the study of parenting, and about guidelines for future studies charting new territory. Such discussion is timely as developmental psychology takes on an increasingly global perspective.
Although some important conceptual studies have appeared in the last decade regarding central issues in parenting (e.g. Darling & Steinberg, 1997; Maccoby, 1992), there is a shortage of discussion of practical issues related to measuring parenting. An important practical issue is the great variability that presently exists in the composition of scales purported to measure constructs given similar names. Furthermore, there are no practical guidelines for designing studies of parenting in 'new' cultures, where measures of the constructs relevant to parenting have not been tested previously. This article is the result of the writers' experience in conducting several recent studies of parenting in Islamic cultures. Some general conceptual and measurement issues with regard to the study of parenting are addressed first. We then follow this with some case examples to illustrate the dilemmas that were faced and the resolutions we adapted. We expect that our observations will be relevant to those planning research in any lessstudied culture, and may also help to clarify problematical issues for our...