Benefits and costs of ecological restoration: Rapid assessment of changing ecosystem service values at a U.K. wetland

Abstract

Restoration of degraded land is recognized by the international community as an important way of enhancing both biodiversity and ecosystem services, but more information is needed about its costs and benefits. In Cambridgeshire, U.K., a long-term initiative to convert drained, intensively farmed arable land to a wetland habitat mosaic is driven by a desire both to prevent biodiversity loss from the nationally important Wicken Fen National Nature Reserve (Wicken Fen NNR) and to increase the provision of ecosystem services. We evaluated the changes in ecosystem service delivery resulting from this land conversion, using a new Toolkit for Ecosystem Service Site-based Assessment (TESSA) to estimate biophysical and monetary values of ecosystem services provided by the restored wetland mosaic compared with the former arable land. Overall results suggest that restoration is associated with a net gain to society as a whole of $199 ha⁻¹y⁻¹, for a one-off investment in restoration of $2320 ha⁻¹. Restoration has led to an estimated loss of arable production of $2040 ha⁻¹y⁻¹, but estimated gains of $671 ha⁻¹y⁻¹ in nature-based recreation, $120 ha⁻¹y⁻¹ from grazing, $48 ha⁻¹y⁻¹ from flood protection, and a reduction in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions worth an estimated $72 ha⁻¹y⁻¹. Management costs have also declined by an estimated $1325 ha⁻¹y⁻¹. Despite uncertainties associated with all measured values and the conservative assumptions used, we conclude that there was a substantial gain to society as a whole from this land-use conversion. The beneficiaries also changed from local arable farmers under arable production to graziers, countryside users from towns and villages, and the global community, under restoration. We emphasize that the values reported here are not necessarily transferable to other sites.

References Anderson-Teixeira, K. J., and E. H. DeLucia. 2010. The greenhouse gas value of ecosystems. Glob. Change Biol. 17:425–438. Bagstad, K. J., F. Villa, G. W. Johnson, and B. Voigt. 2011. ARIES—artificial intelligence for ecosystem services: a guide to models and data, version 1.0. ARIES report series n.1. Available at http://www.ariesonline.org/docs/ARIESModelingGuide1.0.pdf (accessed 13th September 2013). Bateman, I. J., G. M. Mace, C. Fezzi, G. Atkinson, and K. Turner. 2011. Economic analysis for ecosystem service assessments. Environ. Resource Econ. 48:177–218. Bockstael, N. E., and K. E. McConnell. 2006. Environmental and resource valuation with revealed preferences: a theoretical guide to empirical models, the economics of non-market goods and services Vol. 7. Springer, Dordrecht. Bradley, R. I. 1997. Carbon Loss from Drained Lowland Fens. Carbon Sequestration in Vegetation and Soils, report, March 1997. Department of the Environment, Global Atmosphere Division. Brander, L. M., R. J. G. M. Florax, and J. E. Vermaat. 2006. The empirics of wetland valuation: a comprehensive summary and a meta-analysis of the literature. Environ. Resource Econ. 33:223–250. Bullock, J. M., J. Aronson, A. C. Newton, R. F. Pywell, and J. M. Rey-Benayas. 2011. Restoration of ecosystem services and biodiversity: conflicts and opportunities. Trends Ecol. Evol. 26:541–549. CBD. 2010. COP 11 Decision X/2. Strategic plan for biodiversity 2011–2020. Available at http://www.cbd.int/decision/cop/?id=12268 (accessed 21 April 2014). CBD. 2012. Report of the High-Level Panel on global assessment of resources for implementing the Strategic Plan for Biodiversity 2011–2020. Available at http://www.cbd.int/doc/meetings/cop/cop-11/information/cop-11-inf-20-en.pdf (accessed 21 April 2014). Colston, A. 2003. Beyond preservation: the challenge of ecological restoration. Pp. 247–267 in W. M. Adams, M. Mulligan, eds. Decolonizing nature: strategies for conservation in a post-colonial era. Earthscan, London. Colston, A., and L. E. Friday. 1999. Wicken Fen – 100 years either side of the Millennium. Nat. Cambridgeshire 41:46–57. Convine, C. J., and P. G. Starling. 1988. Cambridgeshire Lodes CDP No. 1R 1003 and CDP No. 1R 1030 Stage B Project Appraisal (App-88-009 Cam Lodes). A report by the Cambridge Division of Anglian Water in association with Sir M. MacDonald and Partners. Cook, J. 2009. Current land use survey of the Wicken Fen vision area. [M.Sc. thesis], Manchester Metropolitan University, U.K. Couwenberg, J., J. Augustin, D. Michaelis, and H. Joosten. 2008. Emission reductions from rewetting of peatlands. Greifswald University, Duene. Davidson, Eric A., and Ivan A. Janssens. Temperature sensitivity of soil carbon decomposition and feedbacks to climate change. Nature 440.7081 (2006): 165–173. DEFRA. 2010. Fertiliser manual (RB209), 8th ed. TSO, London. Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, Department for Agriculture and Rural Development (Northern Ireland), Welsh Assembly Government, The Department for Rural Affairs and Heritage, The Scottish Government, Rural and Environment Research and Analysis Directorate. 2014. UK National Statistics. East Cambridgeshire District Council. 2011. Wicken Fen Vision. A report for a meeting of East Cambridgeshire District Council in November 2011. Agenda item No. 13. Environment Agency. 2010. The costs of the Summer 2007 floods in England. Project: SC070039/R1, Environment Agency. Farber, S. C., R. Constanza, and M. A. Wilson. 2002. Economic and ecological concepts for valuing ecosystem services. Ecol. Econ. 41:375–392. Firbank, L., R. B. Bradbury, D. I. McCracken, and C. Stoate. 2013. Delivering multiple ecosystem services from enclosed farmland in the UK. Agricult. Ecosyst. Environ. 166:65–75. Fisher, B., R. B. Bradbury, J. E. Andrews, M. Ausden, S. Bentham-Green, S. White, et al. 2011. Impacts of species-led conservation on ecosystem services of wetlands: understanding co-benefits and tradeoffs. Biodivers. Conserv. 20:2461–2481. Forster, P., V. Ramaswamy, P. Artaxo, T. Berntsen, R. Betts, D. W. Fahey, et al. 2007. Changes in Atmospheric Constituents and in Radiative Forcing. Pp. 129–234 in S. Solomon, D. Qin, M. Manning, Z. Chen, M. Marquis, K. B. Averyt, M. Tignor, H. L. Miller, eds. Climate change 2007: the physical science basis. contribution of working group i to the fourth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge and New York. Friday, L. E., and T. A. Rowell. 1997. Patterns and processes. Pp. 11–21 in L. Friday, ed. Wicken Fen: the making of a wetland nature reserve. Harley Books, Colchester. Graves, A. R., and J. Morris. 2013. Restoration of fenland peatland under climate change. A report to the adaptation Committee of the Committee on Climate Change. Cranfield University, Bedford. Greenspan Bell, R., and D. Callan. 2011. More than meets the eye: the social cost of carbon in U.S. climate policy, in plain english. Policy brief. World Resources Institute, Washington, DC. Håkanson, L., and A. C. Bryhn. 2008. Goals and remedial strategies for water quality and wildlife management in a coastal lagoon: a case study of Ringkjøbing Fjord, Denmark. J. Environ. Manage. 86:498–519. Holman, I. P. 2009. An estimate of peat reserves and losses in the East Anglian Fens commissioned by the RSPB. Department of Natural Resources Cranfield University, Cranfield, Bedfordshire. Hughes, F. M. R., P. A. Stroh, W. A. Adams, K. Kirby, J. O. Mountford, and S. Warrington. 2011. Monitoring and evaluating large-scale, open-ended habitat creation projects: a journey rather than a destination. J. Nat. Conserv. 19:245–253. IPCC. 2006. 2006 IPCC guidelines for national greenhouse gas inventories, prepared by the national greenhouse gas inventories programme, (eds H.S. Eggleston, L. Buendia, K. Miwa, T. Ngara & K. Tanabe). IGES, Hayama Japan. Kivimäki, S. K., M. Yli-petäys, and E.-S. Tuittila. 2008. Carbon sink function of sedge and Sphagnum patches in a restored cut-away peatland: increased functional diversity leads to higher production. J. Appl. Ecol. 45:921–929. Lang, B.. 2011. Crop production in England 2009/2010. Rural Business Research, Cambridge, U.K. Levy, P. E., A. Burden, M. D. A. Cooper, K. J. Dinsmore, J. Drewer, C. Evans, et al. 2012. Methane emissions from soils: synthesis and analysis of a large UK data set. Glob. Change Biol. 18:1657–1669. Lloyd, C. R. 2006. Annual carbon balance of a managed wetland meadow in the Somerset Levels, UK. Agric. For. Meteorol. 138:168–179. Moore, N. W. 1997. The Fenland Reserves. Pp. 3–8 in L. Friday, ed. Wicken Fen: the making of a wetland nature reserve. Harley Books, Colchester. Moreno-Mateos, D., M. E. Power, F. A. Comin, and R. Yockteng. 2012. Structural and functional loss in restored wetland ecosystems. PLoS Biol. 10:e1001247. Morris, J., A. Graves, A. Angus, T. Hess, C. Lawson, M. Camino, et al. 2010. Restoration of Lowland Peatland in England and Impacts on Food Production and Security. Report to Natural England. Cranfield University, Bedford. Morrison, R., J. Kelvin, P. A. Stroh, S. E. Page, F. M. R. Hughes, J. Kaduk, et al. 2012. Net ecosystem carbon dioxide exchange at semi-natural and regenerating temperate fens. Extended abstract 6 pages, 14th International Peat Congress, Bangor, UK. Morrison, R., A. M. J. Cumming, H. E. Taft, J. Kaduk, S. E. Page, D. L. Jones, et al. 2013. Carbon dioxide fluxes at an intensively cultivated temperate lowland peatland in the East Anglian Fens, UK. Biogeosci. Discuss. 10:4193–4223. Moss, T. 2008. Policy shifts and delivery gaps: contexts of floodplain restoration in England and Wales. Pp. 119–147 in T. Moss, J. Monstadt, eds. Restoring floodplains in Europe. IWA Publishing, London. Mountford, J. O., A. Colston, and M. Lester. 2005. Management for diversity: the sedge and litter vegetation at Wicken Fen NNR in 2004. Nat. Cambridgeshire 47:15–23. National Trust. 2009. Wicken Fen Vision: A National Trust strategy to create a 53 square kilometre nature reserve for wildlife and people in Cambridgeshire. Report published by National Trust. Natural England. 2010. England's peatlands. Carbon storage and greenhouse gases. Natural England Report NE257. Available at http://publications.naturalengland.org.uk/publication/30021. (accessed 15th September 2014). Palmer, M. A., and S. Filoso. 2009. Restoration of ecosystem services for environmental markets. Science 325:575–576. Peh, K. S.-H., A. P. Balmford, R. B. Bradbury, C. Brown, S. H. M. Butchart, F. M. R. Hughes, et al. 2013. TESSA: a toolkit for rapid assessment of ecosystem services at sites of biodiversity conservation importance. Ecosyst. Serv. 5:51–57. Perring, M. P., R. J. Standish, and R. J. Hobbs. 2013. Incorporating novelty and novel ecosystems into restoration planning and practice in the 21^st century. Ecol. Process. 2:18. Peters-Stanley, M., K. Hamilton, T. Marcello, and M. Sjardin. 2011. Back to the Future: State of the Voluntary Carbon Markets 2011. Ecosystem Marketplace and Bloomberg New Energy Finance Point Carbon. 2012. Volume of carbon traded in 2011 grew 19%, bucking downturn. Available at http://www.pointcarbon.com/aboutus/pressroom/pressreleases/1.1714530 (accessed 21 April 2014). Rey Benayas, J. M., A. C. Newton, A. Diaz, and J. M. Bullock. 2009. Enhancement of biodiversity and ecosystem services by ecological restoration: a meta-analysis. Science 325:1121–1124. Rowell, T. A. 1997. The history of Wicken Fen. Pp. 187–212 in L. Friday, ed. Wicken Fen: the making of a wetland nature reserve. Harley Books, Colchester. Rural Business Research (RBR) Farm Business Survey database. 2012. Available at http://www.farmbusinesssurvey.co.uk/regional/Reports.asp. (accessed 21 April 2014). Rydin, H., and J. K. Jeglum. 2006. The biology of peatlands. Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford. Samos Juarez, A., and R. Bernabeu Canete. 2013. Valuation of the recreational use of the Calares del Mundo and Sima Natural Park through the travel cost method. Forest Systems 22:189–201. Stern, N. H., S. Peters, V. Bakhshi, A. Bowen, C. Cameron, S. Catovsky, et al. 2006. Stern review: the economics of climate change. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge. Stroh, P. A., J. O. Mountford, Y. N. Araya, and F. M. R. Hughes. 2013. Quantifying soil hydrology to explain the development of vegetation at an ex-arable wetland restoration site. Wetlands 33:311–320. Tallis, H. T., T. Ricketts, A. D. Guerry, S. A. Wood, R. Sharp, E. Nelson, et al. 2013. InVEST 2.5.3 User's Guide.The natural capital project, Stanford. Available at http://www.naturalcapitalproject.org/InVEST.html. (accessed on 13th September 2014). Tol, R. S. J. 2010. The costs and benefits of EU climate policy for 2020. Copenhagen Consensus Center, Lowell, MA, USA. Walpole, M. J., and H. J. Goodwin. 2000. Local economic impacts of dragon tourism in Indonesia. Ann. Tourism Res. 27:559–576. Wells, M. P. 1997. Economic perspectives on nature tourism, conservation and development. Environment Department Paper No. 55, Pollution and Environmental Economics Division, World Bank, Washington.