Reconceptualizing synergism and antagonism among multiple stressors

Abstract

The potential for complex synergistic or antagonistic interactions between multiple stressors presents one of the largest uncertainties when predicting ecological change but, despite common use of the terms in the scientific literature, a consensus on their operational definition is still lacking. The identification of synergism or antagonism is generally straightforward when stressors operate in the same direction, but if individual stressor effects oppose each other, the definition of synergism is paradoxical because what is synergistic to one stressor's effect direction is antagonistic to the others. In their highly cited meta-analysis, Crain et al. (Ecology Letters, 11, 2008: 1304) assumed in situations with opposing individual effects that synergy only occurs when the cumulative effect is more negative than the additive sum of the opposing individual effects. We argue against this and propose a new systematic classification based on an additive effects model that combines the magnitude and response direction of the cumulative effect and the interaction effect. A new class of “mitigating synergism” is identified, where cumulative effects are reversed and enhanced. We applied our directional classification to the dataset compiled by Crain et al. (Ecology Letters, 11, 2008: 1304) to determine the prevalence of synergistic, antagonistic, and additive interactions. Compared to their original analysis, we report differences in the representation of interaction classes by interaction type and we document examples of mitigating synergism, highlighting the importance of incorporating individual stressor effect directions in the determination of synergisms and antagonisms. This is particularly pertinent given a general bias in ecology toward investigating and reporting adverse multiple stressor effects (double negative). We emphasize the need for reconsideration by the ecological community of the interpretation of synergism and antagonism in situations where individual stressor effects oppose each other or where cumulative effects are reversed and enhanced.

References Ban, S. S., N. A. Graham, and S. R. Connolly. 2014. Evidence for multiple stressor interactions and effects on coral reefs. Glob. Change Biol. 20:681–697. Berenbaum, M. C. 1989. What is synergy? Pharmacol. Rev. 41:93–141. Breitburg, D., S. Seitzinger, and J. Sanders. 1999a. The effects of multiple stressors on freshwater and marine ecosystems - Preface. Limnol. Oceanogr. 44:737–738. Breitburg, D. L., J. G. Sanders, C. C. Gilmour, C. A. Hatfield, R. W. Osman, G. F. Riedel, et al. 1999b. Variability in responses to nutrients and trace elements, and transmission of stressor effects through an estuarine food web. Limnol. Oceanogr. 44:837–863. Brown, C. J., M. I. Saunders, H. P. Possingham, and A. J. Richardson. 2013. Managing for interactions between local and global stressors of ecosystems. PLoS ONE 8:e65765. Chou, T. C. 2010. Drug combination studies and their synergy quantification using the Chou–Talalay method. Cancer Res. 70:440–446. Christensen, M. R., M. D. Graham, R. D. Vinebrooke, D. L. Findlay, M. J. Paterson, and M. A. Turner. 2006. Multiple anthropogenic stressors cause ecological surprises in boreal lakes. Glob. Change Biol. 12:2316–2322. Crain, C. M., K. Kroeker, and B. S. Halpern. 2008. Interactive and cumulative effects of multiple human stressors in marine systems. Ecol. Lett. 11:1304–1315. Darling, E. S., and I. M. Cote. 2008. Quantifying the evidence for ecological synergies. Ecol. Lett. 11:1278–1286. Darling, E. S., T. R. Mcclanahan, and I. M. Côté. 2010. Combined effects of two stressors on Kenyan coral reefs are additive or antagonistic, not synergistic. Conserv. Lett. 3:122–130. Dunne, R. 2010. Synergy or antagonism—interactions between stressors on coral reefs. Coral Reefs 29:145–152. Folt, C. L., C. Y. Chen, M. V. Moore, and J. Burnaford. 1999. Synergism and antagonism among multiple stressors. Limnol. Oceanogr. 44:864–877. Greco, W. R., H. Faessel, and L. Levasseur. 1996. The search for cytotoxic synergy between anticancer agents: a case of Dorothy and the ruby slippers? J. Natl Cancer Inst. 88:699–700. Gurevitch, J., J. A. Morrison, and L. V. Hedges. 2000. The interaction between competition and predation: a meta-analysis of field experiments. Am. Nat. 155:435–453. Halpern, B. S., K. L. Mcleod, A. A. Rosenberg, and L. B. Crowder. 2008. Managing for cumulative impacts in ecosystem-based management through ocean zoning. Ocean Coast. Manag. 51:203–211. Hay, M. E. 1996. Defensive synergisms? Reply to pennings. Ecology 77:1950–1952. Hay, M. E., Q. E. Kappel, and W. Fenical. 1994. Synergisms in plant defenses against herbivores: interactions of chemistry, calcification, and plant quality. Ecology 75:1714–1726. Holmstrup, M., A. M. Bindesbol, G. J. Oostingh, A. Duschl, V. Scheil, H. R. Kohler, et al. 2010. Interactions between effects of environmental chemicals and natural stressors: a review. Sci. Total Environ. 408:3746–3762. Kendler, K. S., and C. O. Gardner. 2010. Interpretation of interactions: guide for the perplexed. Br. J. Psychiatry 197:170–171. Klaminder, J., M. Jonsson, J. Fick, A. Sundelin, and T. Brodin. 2014. The conceptual imperfection of aquatic risk assessment tests: highlighting the need for tests designed to detect therapeutic effects of pharmaceutical contaminants. Environ. Res. Lett. 9:084003. MEA. 2005. Millennium ecosystem assessment synthesis report. Island Press, United Nations Environment Programme, Washington, DC. Mothersill, C., I. Mosse, and C. Seymour. 2007. Multiple stressors: a challenge for the future. Springer, Netherlands. Nakagawa, S., and I. C. Cuthill. 2007. Effect size, confidence interval and statistical significance: a practical guide for biologists. Biol. Rev. 82:591–605. Nelson, A. C., and T. A. Kursar. 1999. Interactions among plant defense compounds: a method for analysis. Chemoecology 9:81–92. Niyogi, D. K., M. Koren, C. J. Arbuckle, and C. R. Townsend. 2007. Stream communities along a catchment land-use gradient: subsidy-stress responses to pastoral development. Environ. Manage. 39:213–225. Odum, E. P., and G. W. Barrett. 2005. Fundamentals of ecology. Thomson/Brooks/Cole, Belmont, CA. Paine, R. T., M. J. Tegner, and E. A. Johnson. 1998. Compounded perturbations yield ecological surprises. Ecosystems 1:535–545. Pelletier, E., P. Sargian, J. Payet, and S. Demers. 2006. Ecotoxicological effects of combined UVB and organic contaminants in coastal waters: a review. Photochem. Photobiol. 82:981–993. Piggott, J. J., R. K. Salis, G. Lear, C. R. Townsend, and C. D. Matthaei. 2015a. Climate warming and agricultural stressors interact to determine stream periphyton community composition. Glob. Change Biol. 21:206–222. Piggott, J. J., C. R. Townsend, and C. D. Matthaei. 2015b. Climate warming and agricultural stressors interact to determine stream macroinvertebrate community dynamics. Glob. Change Biol. doi:10.1111/gcb.12861. Przeslawski, R., A. Davis, and K. Benkendorff. 2005. Synergistic effects associated with climate change and the development of rocky shore molluscs. Glob. Change Biol. 11:515–522. Quinn, G. P., and M. J. Keough. 2002. Experimental design and data analysis for biologists. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, U.K. Sala, O. E., J. J. Armesto, E. Berlow, J. Bloomfield, F. S. Chapin III, R. Dirzo, et al. 2000. Global biodiversity scenarios for the year 2100. Science 287:1770. Sargian, P., S. Mas, E. Pelletier, and S. Demers. 2007. Multiple stressors on an Antarctic microplankton assemblage: water soluble crude oil and enhanced UVBR level at Ushuaia (Argentina). Polar Biol. 30:829–841. Scheffer, M., S. Carpenter, J. A. Foley, C. Folke, and B. Walker. 2001. Catastrophic shifts in ecosystems. Nature 413:591–596. Strain, E. M. A., R. J. Thomson, F. Micheli, F. P. Mancuso, and L. Airoldi. 2014. Identifying the interacting roles of stressors in driving the global loss of canopy-forming to mat-forming algae in marine ecosystems. Glob. Change Biol. 20:3300–3312. Swanson, A. K., and C. H. Fox. 2007. Altered kelp (Laminariales) phlorotannins and growth under elevated carbon dioxide and ultraviolet-B treatments can influence associated intertidal food webs. Glob. Change Biol. 13:1696–1709. Townsend, C. R., S. S. Uhlmann, and C. D. Matthaei. 2008. Individual and combined responses of stream ecosystems to multiple stressors. J. Appl. Ecol. 45:1810–1819. Vanhoudt, N., H. Vandenhove, A. Real, C. Bradshaw, and K. Stark. 2012. A review of multiple stressor studies that include ionising radiation. Environ. Pollut. 168:177–192.