Content area
Full text
This reprint of Timothy Larsen's extremely well-received 1999 study is most welcome. A sure guide to issues of religious equality between 1847 and 1867, Larsen is not frightened of questioning received historiography, regardless of the status of those he criticises, especially when using mistaken or anachronistic stereotypes of mid-century nonconformity. Dissent's coherent world-view was formulated out of a particular theological understanding, which impelled its voluntarist convictions and campaigns for religious equality. Sense cannot be made of the history Larsen analyses without taking theology seriously: only so can these men and movements be properly understood. Proper distinctions must be made, distinguishing the specifically nonconformist approach from the evangelical and the Protestant [anti-catholic]. 'Nonconformist politics was rooted theology, but not in the soteriology of Evangelicalism, but rather in the ecclesiology of Congregationalism.' The traditional agenda of nonconformist grievances, here comprehensively considered, leads Larsen to differentiate situations with practical consequences from those of simply iconographic significance, that is of limited day-to-day impact, but which were perceived to be demeaning to nonconformists. Manipulated by the hard core of militant dissent to advance its more radical demands for disestablishment, the question arises whether government's failure to resolve such issues radicalised dissenting aspirations. The disestablishment case, based on the primacy of Christ as the head of the Church, also raised the distinction between a 'gathered' and a national Church, faith-commitment not geography determining its character. The campaign consumed much energy to little effect, at least in England, though successful in Ireland and later in Wales. Failure here curbed efforts to secure full religious equality, though the consistency of nonconformist attitudes is seen in their espousal of Roman Catholic and Jewish rights in Britain, and Hindu rights in India. In an age of