Ernst Mayr through time on the biological species concept — a conceptual analysis

Abstract

Summary

An analysis is made of Ernst Mayr’s treatment of the biological species definition over time. To avoid misunderstandings, it is important to distinguish between the varying conceptual assumptions which Mayr associates with this definition and the unchanged wording of the definition.

A polytypic species, that is a geographical aggregate of allopatric populations, does not fit the biological species definition very well. There is an undeniable tension between these two aspects [the polytypic and nondimensional] of the word species and from 1942 until the present time, I have never ceased to struggle with this problem (Mayr 1992b, p. 9).

... indeed, I pride myself on having changed my mind on frequent occasions (Mayr 1982a, p. 9).