Top Skin-of-Color Publications in Dermatology

Abstract

Recurring themes in the top AAS skin-of-color (SoC) papers included skin cancer; cosmetic dermatology, notably pigmentation disorders; and inadequate knowledge among health care practitioners in identifying dermatologic conditions in SoC patients. Understanding nuances and optimizing treatment outcomes Alexis [3] 179 12 2014 JDDb United States Background and room illumination in color identification of skin lesions Maymone et al [4] 128 6 2017 JAMAcDermatology United States Skin cancer and photoprotection in people of color: A review and recommendations for physicians and the public Agbai et al [5] 122 120 2014 JAADd United States UV Exposure and the risk of cutaneous melanoma in skin of color: A systematic review Lopes et al [6] 102 7 2021 JAMA Dermatology United States Skin color in dermatology textbooks: An updated evaluation and analysis Adelekun et al [7] 98 17 2021 JAAD United States Skin cancer in skin of color Bradford [8] 80 196 2009 Dermatology Nursing United States The use of noncultured regenerative epithelial suspension for improving skin color and scars: A report of 8 cases and review of the literature Ren et al [9] 72 2 2019 Journal of CosmeticDermatology China Gaps in the understanding and treatment of skin cancer in people of color Kailas et al [10] 54 4 2016 JAAD United States How dermatology is failing melanoma patients with skin of color: Biology, structure, function, and implications for dermatologic disease Taylor [13] 34 220 2002 JAAD United States A mouse model of vitiligo with focused epidermal depigmentation requires IFN-gamma for autoreactive CD8(+) T-cell accumulation in the skin Harris et al [14] 24 159 2012 JIDe United States Skin cancer and photoprotection in people of color: A review and recommendations for physicians and the public Agbai et al [5] 122 120 2014 JAAD United States Acne vulgaris in skin of color Taylor et al [15] 2 102 2002 JAAD United States The Asian dermatologic patient review of common pigmentary disorders and cutaneous diseases Ho et al [16] 1 84 2009 American Journal of Clinical Dermatology China Melasma: an up-to-date comprehensive review Ogbechie-Godec et al [17] 10 61 2017 Dermatology and Therapy United States Development and validation of a vitiligo-specific quality-of-life instrument (VitiQoL) Lilly et al [18] 2 61 2013 JAAD United States Accuracy of self-report in assessing Fitzpatrick skin phototypes I through VI Eilers et al [19] 18 53 2013 JAMA Dermatology United States Defining pseudofolliculitis barbae in 2001: A review of the literature and current trends Perry et al [20] 3 52 2002 JAAD United States Table 2.

Introduction

Tools such as the Altmetric Attention Score (AAS) and Web of Science (WoS) allow researchers to qualify their work’s impact. WoS uses publication citation counts and is often utilized in academia, while the AAS analyzes online media attention to determine the impact of research [1].

Methods

Using Altmetric Explorer to obtain an article’s AAS and WoS to measure an article’s citation count, the top 50 papers from each search engine were collected using the keywords “skin of color” and “dermatology.” An article’s mention in news outlets and on blogs and Twitter were recorded from Altmetric Explorer as well as whether these mentions came from members of the public or practitioners; this we defined as metrics indicative of online media “attention.” The mean (SD), 95% CI, and P values were determined by comparing the metrics provided by the top 50 papers from Altmetric and WoS.

Results

Table 1 presents a comparison of the top 10 cited articles on WoS and the top 10 articles with the highest AAS.

The mean AAS for the top 50 papers from Altmetric and WoS were 39.1 and 24.2, respectively (P=.02). The P values were statistically significant in several of the categories compared, including the AAS (P=.02), news outlet mentions (P=.008), and Twitter mentions (P=.02) (Table 2). Recurring themes in the top AAS skin-of-color (SoC) papers included skin cancer; cosmetic dermatology, notably pigmentation disorders; and inadequate knowledge among health care practitioners in identifying dermatologic conditions in SoC patients. By contrast, the top-cited SoC papers from WoS involved basic science research of dermatologic conditions and recommendations for assessment tools for clinicians and patients.

Table 1. Top 10 cited dermatology papers on Web of Science compared to the top 10 high-scoring Altmetric papers.

Article title		Authors	Altmetric Attention Score	Total citations (on Web of Science), n	Publication year	Journal	Country
Top 10 Altmetric articles
	Postinflammatory hyperpigmentation: A review of the epidemiology, clinical features, and treatment options in skin of color	Davis et al [2]	211	359	2010	JCADa	United States
	Acne vulgaris in skin of color: Understanding nuances and optimizing treatment outcomes	Alexis [3]	179	12	2014	JDDb	United States
	Background and room illumination in color identification of skin lesions	Maymone et al [4]	128	6	2017	JAMAcDermatology	United States
	Skin cancer and photoprotection in people of color: A review and recommendations for physicians and the public	Agbai et al [5]	122	120	2014	JAADd	United States
	UV Exposure and the risk of cutaneous melanoma in skin of color: A systematic review	Lopes et al [6]	102	7	2021	JAMA Dermatology	United States
	Skin color in dermatology textbooks: An updated evaluation and analysis	Adelekun et al [7]	98	17	2021	JAAD	United States
	Skin cancer in skin of color	Bradford [8]	80	196	2009	Dermatology Nursing	United States
	The use of noncultured regenerative epithelial suspension for improving skin color and scars: A report of 8 cases and review of the literature	Ren et al [9]	72	2	2019	Journal of CosmeticDermatology	China
	Gaps in the understanding and treatment of skin cancer in people of color	Kailas et al [10]	54	4	2016	JAAD	United States
	How dermatology is failing melanoma patients with skin of color: Unanswered questions on risk and eye-opening disparities in outcomes are weighing heavily on melanoma patients with darker skin	Nelson [11]	53	3	2020	Cancer Cytopathology	United States
Top 10 Web of Science articles
	Skin cancer in skin of color	Gloster Jr et al [12]	26	301	2006	JAAD	United States
	Skin of color: Biology, structure, function, and implications for dermatologic disease	Taylor [13]	34	220	2002	JAAD	United States
	A mouse model of vitiligo with focused epidermal depigmentation requires IFN-gamma for autoreactive CD8(+) T-cell accumulation in the skin	Harris et al [14]	24	159	2012	JIDe	United States
	Skin cancer and photoprotection in people of color: A review and recommendations for physicians and the public	Agbai et al [5]	122	120	2014	JAAD	United States
	Acne vulgaris in skin of color	Taylor et al [15]	2	102	2002	JAAD	United States
	The Asian dermatologic patient review of common pigmentary disorders and cutaneous diseases	Ho et al [16]	1	84	2009	American Journal of Clinical Dermatology	China
	Melasma: an up-to-date comprehensive review	Ogbechie-Godec et al [17]	10	61	2017	Dermatology and Therapy	United States
	Development and validation of a vitiligo-specific quality-of-life instrument (VitiQoL)	Lilly et al [18]	2	61	2013	JAAD	United States
	Accuracy of self-report in assessing Fitzpatrick skin phototypes I through VI	Eilers et al [19]	18	53	2013	JAMA Dermatology	United States
	Defining pseudofolliculitis barbae in 2001: A review of the literature and current trends	Perry et al [20]	3	52	2002	JAAD	United States

Table 2. The top 50 Altmetric papers versus the top 50 cited papers in Web of Science.

	Altmetric Attention Score	Citations	News outlet mentions	Blog mentions	Twitter mentions	Count of mentions by members of the public	Count of mentions by practitioners
Top 50 skin-of-color Altmetric publications, mean (95% CI)	39.1 (27.1-51.1)	41.9 (20.2-63.6)	4.7 (3.0-6.4)	0.2 (0.1-0.4)	9.9 (6.2-13.6)	5.6 (3.5-7.8)	1.0 (0.5-1.5)
Top 50 skin-of-color Web of Science publications, mean (95% CI)	24.2 (14.6-33.8)	46.1 (31.2-61.0)	2.1 (1.1-3.2)	0.2 (0.1-0.4)	5.9 (2.9-8.8)	4.1 (2.0-6.2)	0.7 (0.2-1.2)
P valuea	.02	.34	.008	.42	.02	.17	.11

^aJCAD: Journal of Clinical & Aesthetic Dermatology.

^bJDD: Journal of Drugs in Dermatology.

^cJAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association.

^dJAAD: Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology.

^eJID: Journal of Investigative Dermatology.

^at test.

Discussion

Principal Findings

While highly cited publications often guide clinical recommendations and carry substantial influence on practitioners, they may fail to highlight the discussions taking place outside of the scientific community [21]. For SoC patients, their interests and concerns regarding dermatologic conditions must be understood by health care providers as disease processes often manifest differently in this population compared to the general public [13]. With over 70% of the US population using social media, these platforms will allow increased sharing of research topics, supporting the utility of Altmetric scoring compared to citation count alone [22]. Within our study, the difference in recurrent themes between top AAS versus top-cited publications indicated that the clinical mindset and patient-centered topics may not align.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations to our study include a small sample size, narrow inclusion criteria, and a lack of time constraints. Future studies comparing AAS and WoS should be confined to a short time period to mitigate temporal confounding factors due to the differing accrual rates of citation count and AAS [23]. Medical societies and health care providers can use insights from this study to shape the practice of dermatology to better understand the interests and expectations of SoC patients.

Conclusion

AAS and WoS provide different metrics on the influence of academic research. Factors that may generate greater social media attention include papers with more pictures and an author’s social media presence. Elements that may produce greater citation counts include a journal’s impact factor and an author’s academic reputation and home institution. Altmetric uniquely represents the attention of the general public, which can facilitate patient-centered decision-making.

Conflicts of Interest

RPD is editor-in-chief of JMIR Dermatology, a joint coordinating editor for Cochrane Skin, a dermatology section editor for UpToDate, a social media editor for the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, and a podcast editor for the Journal of Investigative Dermatology (JID). He is a coordinating editor representative on Cochrane Council. RPD receives editorial stipends (JID, JMIR Dermatology), royalties (UpToDate), and expense reimbursement from Cochrane Skin.

References

1. Bernstam EV, Herskovic JR, Aphinyanaphongs Y, Aliferis CF, Sriram MG, Hersh WR. Using citation data to improve retrieval from MEDLINE. J Am Med Inform Assoc 2006;13(1):96-105 [

References

Bernstam EV, Herskovic JR, Aphinyanaphongs Y, Aliferis CF, Sriram MG, Hersh WR. Using citation data to improve retrieval from MEDLINE. J Am Med Inform Assoc 2006;13(1):96-105

Davis EC, Callender VD. Postinflammatory hyperpigmentation: a review of the epidemiology, clinical features, and treatment options in skin of color. J Clin Aesthet Dermatol 2010 Jul;3(7):20-31

Alexis AF. Acne vulgaris in skin of color: understanding nuances and optimizing treatment outcomes. J Drugs Dermatol 2014 Jun;13(6):s61-s65.

Maymone MBC, Neamah HH, Wirya SA, Patzelt NM, Secemsky EA, Zancanaro PQ, et al. Background and room illumination in color identification of skin lesions: A cross-sectional study. JAMA Dermatol 2017 Oct 01;153(10):1059-1061

Agbai ON, Buster K, Sanchez M, Hernandez C, Kundu RV, Chiu M, et al. Skin cancer and photoprotection in people of color: a review and recommendations for physicians and the public. J Am Acad Dermatol 2014 Apr;70(4):748-762.

Lopes FCPS, Sleiman MG, Sebastian K, Bogucka R, Jacobs EA, Adamson AS. UV Exposure and the risk of cutaneous melanoma in skin of color: A systematic review. JAMA Dermatol 2021 Feb 01;157(2):213-219.

Adelekun A, Onyekaba G, Lipoff JB. Skin color in dermatology textbooks: An updated evaluation and analysis. J Am Acad Dermatol 2021 Jan;84(1):194-196.

Bradford PT. Skin cancer in skin of color. Dermatol Nurs 2009;21(4):170-7, 206; quiz 178

Ren J, Liu J, Yu N, Zhang W, Qian H, Liu Z, et al. The use of noncultured regenerative epithelial suspension for improving skin color and scars: A report of 8 cases and review of the literature. J Cosmet Dermatol 2019 Jul 26.

Kailas A, Solomon JA, Mostow EN, Rigel DS, Kittles R, Taylor SC. Gaps in the understanding and treatment of skin cancer in people of color. J Am Acad Dermatol 2016 May;74(5):1020-1021.

Nelson B. How dermatology is failing melanoma patients with skin of color: Unanswered questions on risk and eye-opening disparities in outcomes are weighing heavily on melanoma patients with darker skin. In this article, part 1 of a 2-part series, we explore the deadly consequences of racism and inequality in cancer care. Cancer Cytopathol 2020 Jan;128(1):7-8

Gloster HM, Neal K. Skin cancer in skin of color. J Am Acad Dermatol 2006 Nov;55(5):741-60; quiz 761.

Taylor SC. Skin of color: biology, structure, function, and implications for dermatologic disease. J Am Acad Dermatol 2002 Mar;46(2 Suppl Understanding):S41-S62.

Harris JE, Harris TH, Weninger W, Wherry EJ, Hunter CA, Turka LA. A mouse model of vitiligo with focused epidermal depigmentation requires IFN-γ for autoreactive CD8⁺ T-cell accumulation in the skin. J Invest Dermatol 2012 Jul;132(7):1869-1876

Taylor SC, Cook-Bolden F, Rahman Z, Strachan D. Acne vulgaris in skin of color. J Am Acad Dermatol 2002 Mar;46(2 Suppl Understanding):S98-106.

Ho SGY, Chan HHL. The Asian dermatologic patient: review of common pigmentary disorders and cutaneous diseases. Am J Clin Dermatol 2009;10(3):153-168.

Ogbechie-Godec OA, Elbuluk N. Melasma: an up-to-date comprehensive review. Dermatol Ther (Heidelb) 2017 Sep;7(3):305-318

Lilly E, Lu PD, Borovicka JH, Victorson D, Kwasny MJ, West DP, et al. Development and validation of a vitiligo-specific quality-of-life instrument (VitiQoL). J Am Acad Dermatol 2013 Jul;69(1):e11-e18.

Eilers S, Bach DQ, Gaber R, Blatt H, Guevara Y, Nitsche K, et al. Accuracy of self-report in assessing Fitzpatrick skin phototypes I through VI. JAMA Dermatol 2013 Nov;149(11):1289-1294.

Perry PK, Cook-Bolden FE, Rahman Z, Jones E, Taylor SC. Defining pseudofolliculitis barbae in 2001: a review of the literature and current trends. J Am Acad Dermatol 2002 Mar;46(2 Suppl Understanding):S113-S119.

Chavarro D, Ràfols I, Tang P. To what extent is inclusion in the Web of Science an indicator of journal ‘quality’? Res Eval 2018;27(2):106-118.

Dean B. How Many People Use Social Media in 2021? (65+ Statistics). Backlinko. 2021 Oct 10. URL: https://backlinko.com/social-media-users [accessed 2022-01-02]

Huang A, Weng CY. Correspondence. Retina 2022 Jun 01;42(6):e30.