A 14-Year Trend in Intended Illegal Protest Activities of 8th-Grade Students: Do Civic Knowledge and Individual Students’ Backgrounds Count?

Abstract

Legal protests are recognized as a legitimate form of civic participation. Illegal protests, on the other hand, are an effective form of civil disobedience, which, however, can take a rather excessive form. This article tracks the trends in expected participation in illegal protests of 8th-grade students using data from thirteen countries participating in all three cycles of the International Civic and Citizenship Education Study (2009, 2016, and 2022). The results of the countries’ overall trends show that students’ anticipation for participation in illegal protest activities has increased in most participating countries. The general trend across the participating countries is that male students have a higher anticipation of participating in all cycles, although in nine countries, the gap between male and female students is shrinking over time, and in two countries, the trends are increasing for both male and female students. In general, students with an immigrant background have higher expectations to participate in illegal protest activities. These findings can inform the development of curricula and teaching strategies to promote critical thinking, ethical decision-making, and constructive civic engagement. The results also suggest that integrating lessons on peaceful advocacy, conflict resolution, and democratic processes can channel student activism into lawful and impactful forms of participation and engagement.