From Emergency Remote Teaching to Hybrid Models: Faculty Perceptions Across Three Spanish Universities

Abstract

This study examines university teachers’ digital competences during Emergency Remote Teaching at three Spanish institutions—the University of La Laguna, the University of Extremadura, and the University of Valladolid—and, from the faculty perspective, appraises hybrid teaching experiences and institutional support services. We employed a qualitative multi-case design using semi-structured focus-group interviews and discussion groups with 57 instructors from Social Sciences and Humanities, Engineering, and Health Sciences, selected via purposive sampling. Data were deductively coded in Atlas.ti 24. Faculty perceive hybrid teaching as useful for widening access and repositioning the virtual campus as a communicative hub; they highlight Moodle, videoconferencing, content-authoring tools such as H5P, and methodologies like gamification and flipped learning to enhance motivation. Nonetheless, generational gaps and concerns about the authenticity of online assessment persist, supporting continued reliance on in-person examinations. Technical and training support services are viewed positively, yet respondents call for more staffing and stronger dissemination of teaching resources. Consolidating teachers’ digital competences requires institutional policies that integrate robust infrastructure, contextualized continuous professional development, and communities of practice to ensure the sustainability of hybrid models in higher education at the national level.