The Heterogeneity of Hearing: Reconceiving Perception Through Audition
Abstract (summary)
Perception is our primary means of acquiring information about and interacting with the environment: we hear the hum of a dryer, smell rancid milk, and see a bird catch a worm. Yet historically, both philosophy and perceptual science have been dominated by vision, which has been treated as the paradigmatic sense, whose findings have consequently been extended to other exteroceptive modalities (Biggs, Matthen, and Stokes 2014; O’Callaghan 2009, 2020).
From Hermann von Helmholtz’s pioneering work on optics, to the influential work of David Hubel and Torsten Wiesel on vision, and David Marr’s computational theory, vision has shaped the view that perception consists of discrete modalities implemented by specialized systems which function to produce specific perceptual features (Barlow 1972, 1982; Martin 1994; Wurtz 2009). This is further reinforced by Aristotle’s influential taxonomy which individuates each exteroceptive sense by its proper sensible, a sensible that is uniquely accessed by a single modality (Grice 1962; Everson 1995; Pasnau 2000; Macpherson 2011; Blum 2017).
These traditions have shaped accounts of what the senses are, how they are related to one another, and how they provide us with knowledge of our external environment. This dissertation asks what we can learn by beginning not with vision, but with audition. Audition has traditionally been understood as analogous to vision: The auditory modality is typically treated as a discrete mode of perceiving that is implemented by the auditory system which functions to produce the perception of perceiver-independent sounds and their qualitative features. I argue that these assumptions are misguided.
Drawing on recent findings from philosophy, psychology, psychophysics, cognitive science, and neuroscience, I show that audition is implemented by multiple sensory and cognitive systems, and is sustained by inputs to multiple sensory modalities, forming a distributed network for the realization of its function. Moreover, its product is not perceiver-independent sounds, but sounds whose qualities are partly perceiver-dependent and partly environment-dependent. Hearing therefore provides a powerful case for reassessing assumptions that have been inherited from the study of vision.
Indexing (details)
Neurosciences;
Audiology;
Cognitive psychology
0300: Audiology
0317: Neurosciences
0633: Cognitive psychology