Content area
Full text
IN THE FIELD OF ROMANTIC SCHOLARSHIP CHARLOTTE SMITH S POETRY HAS in recent years come to be seen as one of the most paradigmatic literary sources revealing the artistic constructedness of gender. A lot of critical attention has been paid to the gender roles and meanings inscribed in her poetry in ways that not only illuminate their textuality but also display how modern critics read gender into Romantic texts, thereby contributing to the ongoing revision of the established norms of canonicity and tradition. In addition to the influence she had on the first male Romantics, notably Wordsworth and Coleridge,1 Smith's enormous importance for literary history and criticism today seems to lie chiefly in the deconstructive potential of her work as detected by scholars exploring the gendered and generic constructions of subjectivity and poetic identity in the Romantic lyric.2
Stuart Curran maintains that "Charlotte Smith was the first poet in England whom in retrospect we would call Romantic."3 It can be added that Smith is the major poet whose work reveals how deeply and inextricably the Romantic tradition is rooted in the sentimental. Embodying fusions and hybridizations of what modern literary criticism has come to differentiate as the sentimental and the Romantic traditions, Smith's poetry not only illustrates their common ground, but also their differential qualities with respect to each other, which, considering their continuity, should perhaps be reassessed under the categories of the sentimental and the sublime. As Stephen Behrendt writes, "we might consider to what extent Romanticism might fruitfuUy be deUneated by the ways in which writers and citizens alike position themselves, at various points in the period, in relation to an axis whose poles are the Sentimental and the SubUme."4
Against some readings that interpret Smith's poetic self in terms of an absence or faUure, not only of the sublime but also of subjectivity, I would suggest that her poetry inscribes a poetic subjectivity that is more a positive writing of the sentimental than a default of the sublime. In his influential article "The I Altered" Curran writes with reference to the women poets of the Romantic period, including Smith:
The humanitarianism of the Dissenting tradition makes women poets sympathetic to distress and victimization, but the void at the center of sensibility should...