Signification of distal urinary acidification defects in hypocitraturic patients

Abstract

Background and objectives

Hypocitraturia has been associated with metabolic acidosis and mineral disorders. The aim of this study was to investigate the occurrence of urinary acidification defects underlying hypocitraturia.

Materials and methods

This retrospective observational study included 67 patients (32 men), aged 40.7±15.1 years with hypocitraturia (<1.67 mmol/24-h) and nephrolithiasis, nephrocalcinosis, and/or bone demineralization, referred to our center from 2000 to 2015. We aimed to assess renal distal acidification capacity, prevalence and mechanisms of urinary acidification defects. Patients with low baseline plasma HCO₃^- (<22 mmol/L) were studied by bicarbonate loading or furosemide/fludrocortisone tests. Patients with normal baseline plasma HCO₃^- had an ammonium-chloride challenge test. A normal response was a decrease in urinary pH <5.3 and an increase in urinary NH₄⁺ ≥33 μmol/min and defined idiopathic hypocitraturia.

Results

Eleven patients (16.4%) had low HCO₃^- and overt distal acidification defect. Three had a mutation in the gene encoding AE1, 4 had Gougerot-Sjögren syndrome and no cause was found in the remaining 4 cases. Fifty-six patients (83.6%) had normal HCO₃^-; of those, 33 (58.9%) had idiopathic hypocitraturia. Among the 23 (41%) remaining patients, 12 were unable to increase urinary NH₄⁺ excretion (among them, 8 were able to decrease urinary pH and 4 were not) whereas 11 were able to increase urinary NH₄⁺ excretion but unable to decrease urinary pH. These 11 patients had higher fasting urinary calcium, reflecting bone resorption, than the other 12 patients: median 0.41 [0.24–0.47] vs. 0.22 [0.08–0.37] mmol/mmol creatinine (P = 0.04).

Conclusions

Patients with hypocitraturia and normal plasma HCO₃^- frequently show a latent acidification defect that can be further dissected into one of several subtypes based on urinary pH and NH₄⁺ response to the acid load. Those patients with impaired urine acidification capacity but preserved NH₄⁺ excretion exhibit particularly high calciuria and should be identified to optimize nephrolithiasis prevention.

About the Authors:

Valentina Forni Ogna

Affiliation: Centre d’Investigations Cliniques, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France

Anne Blanchard

Affiliations Centre d’Investigations Cliniques, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France, Centre de Référence des Maladies Rénales Héréditaires de l’Enfant et de l’Adulte (MARHEA), Paris, France, Université Paris Descartes, Faculté de Médecine, Paris, France

Rosa Vargas-Poussou

Affiliations Centre de Référence des Maladies Rénales Héréditaires de l’Enfant et de l’Adulte (MARHEA), Paris, France, Service de Génétique, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France

Adam Ogna

Affiliation: INSERM CIC 14.29, Hôpital Raymond Poincaré, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Garches, France

Stéphanie Baron

Affiliations Université Paris Descartes, Faculté de Médecine, Paris, France, Département de Physiologie, Unité rénale, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France

Jean-Philippe Bertocchio

Affiliations Université Paris Descartes, Faculté de Médecine, Paris, France, Département de Physiologie, Unité rénale, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France

Caroline Prot-Bertoye

Affiliations Université Paris Descartes, Faculté de Médecine, Paris, France, Département de Physiologie, Unité rénale, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France

Jérôme Nevoux

Affiliations Service d’ORL, Hôpital Bicêtre, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France, Université Paris-Saclay, Paris, France, INSERM 1182, Paris, France

Julie Dubourg

Affiliation: Centre d’Investigations Cliniques, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France

Gérard Maruani

Affiliations INSERM CIC 14.29, Hôpital Raymond Poincaré, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Garches, France, Institut Necker Enfants-Malades, INSERM U1151 –CNRS UMR 8253, Paris, France

Margarida Mendes

Affiliation: Centre d’Investigations Cliniques, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France

Alejandro Garcia-Castaño

Affiliation: Service de Génétique, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France

Cyrielle Treard

Affiliation: Service de Génétique, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France

Nelly Lepottier

Affiliation: Service de Génétique, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France

Pascal Houillier

Affiliations Université Paris Descartes, Faculté de Médecine, Paris, France, Département de Physiologie, Unité rénale, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France, INSERM UMR_S1138, CNRS ERL8228, Paris, France

Marie Courbebaisse

* E-mail: [email protected]

Affiliations Université Paris Descartes, Faculté de Médecine, Paris, France, Département de Physiologie, Unité rénale, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris, France, Institut Necker Enfants-Malades, INSERM U1151 –CNRS UMR 8253, Paris, France

Introduction

Hypocitraturia is a risk factor for nephrolithiasis, since citrate is a potent inhibitor of the crystallization of stone forming salts [1] and has been associated with low bone density [2]. Once filtered, citrate is reabsorbed in the proximal tubule, so that only 10–35% of filtered citrate is excreted [3]. The urinary excretion rate of citrate is extremely sensitive to the acid-base balance [3]. Hypocitraturia is always present in patients with overt metabolic acidosis but can also reveal subtle defects in urinary acidification [3, 4]. These defects may be insufficient to cause an overt acidosis when the subject is in the steady state but may induce an acid-base imbalance that modifies citrate metabolism [5]. Whether hypocitraturia is a marker of a subtle defect in urinary acidification has never been established [6]. Distal renal tubular acidosis (dRTA) may result from either hereditary or acquired diseases. Inactivating mutations in the SLC4A1 gene encoding the chloride bicarbonate exchanger AE1 are the main causes of autosomal dominant dRTA [7]. Loss of function mutations in ATP6V1B1 and ATP6V0A4, genes encoding the B1 and a4 subunits of the apical H⁺-ATPase, are responsible for autosomal recessive dRTA, often associated with sensorineural deafness [6]. Acquired dRTA frequently develops as a consequence of Gougerot-Sjögren syndrome [8] and other autoimmune diseases [9, 10]. Very few studies have evaluated the utility of screening for a urinary acidification defects in non-acidotic patients with concomitant hypocitraturia, recurrent nephrolithiasis [11, 12], and/or bone demineralization [13, 14]. In the present study, we retrospectively analyzed data from patients with low citrate excretion and nephrolithiasis, nephrocalcinosis, and/or bone demineralization. We compared the clinical and biological characteristics of patients with overt acidosis to those of patients with normal acid-base status and here report results of acute acid load, genetic and immunological tests in hypocitraturic patients without overt acidosis. We develop hypotheses about the pathophysiological mechanisms underlying the subtle acidification defects that do not lead to overt acidosis.

Materials and methods

Patients

This study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and approved by the French national regulatory board (CNIL, 915528 and 1922081). According to the French national regulatory board, all patients were informed before any exploration that their data could be used anonymously for clinical research. Given that the study was observational and only implied current care, they only had to give their oral informed consent. However, all patients gave written informed consent for biobanking (DC2009950) and, if required, specific written consent for genetic testing. The written consents for biobanking and genetic testing were recorded in the patient’s chart stored in our department and a copy was given to the patient

Patients were referred to our unit for the assessment of mineral disorders: recurrent kidney stones, nephrocalcinosis, and/or bone demineralization. Urinary citrate excretion is routinely measured in these patients.

In our retrospective analysis we included patients with low citrate excretion (<1.67 mmol/24-h), defining hypocitraturia [15], having undergone a renal acidification capacity test. Subjects with urinary bacterial contamination (≥10⁵ colonies/mL) or incomplete 24-hour urinary collection [16] were not included in the study because of the risk of falsely low urinary citrate excretion. We deliberately included patients with hypokaliemia, a confounding factor of hypocitraturia [3], since it is also a frequent finding in dRTA. Patients with overt metabolic acidosis (baseline venous plasma HCO₃^-<22 mmol/L), underwent a bicarbonate loading test [17] until 2009 and a furosemide/fludrocortisone test [18] thereafter. Patients with normal (≥22 mmol/L) baseline plasma HCO₃^- underwent a short acid-loading test.

Functional tests

The tests and analytical methods are fully described in the supplementary material (S1 File).

Bicarbonate loading test.

Urine and venous blood samples were collected for measurement of pH and pCO₂ at baseline and at hourly intervals for 4 hours during IV infusion of 1.4% sodium bicarbonate [17]. Maximal transport of HCO₃^- should be >22 mmol/L of glomerular filtration rate (GFR) and, in the absence of urinary concentration defects, the urine-to-blood PCO₂ difference should increase >20 mmHg during infusion [19].

Furosemide/fludrocortisone test.

After plasma and urine sampling, 40 mg furosemide and 1 mg fludrocortisone were orally administered. Normal response is a decrease in urinary pH<5.3 at least once within 6 hours [18].

Acute acid loading test.

Oral administration of 2 mmol/kg body weight ammonium chloride (NH₄Cl) was performed after baseline plasma and urine sampling. Normal response is a decrease in urine pH<5.3 at least once and an increase in urinary NH₄⁺ excretion ≥33 μEq/min. at least once within 6 hours [4]. We used both criteria to classify patients within four patterns of urinary acidification response: subjects able to acidify urine to a pH<5.3 and to increase urinary NH₄⁺-excretion rate ≥33 μEq/min. ("idiopathic hypocitraturia"); patients unable to decrease urine pH but able to increase NH₄⁺ ("high U.pH, high U.NH₄"); patients able to acidify urine but unable to increase NH₄⁺ ("low U.pH, low U.NH₄"); patients unable to reduce the urine pH and to increase NH₄⁺ ("high U.pH, low U.NH₄").

Analytical methods.

The pH and pCO₂ in plasma and urine were measured using an automated pH and gas analyzer (ABL 555330 then 705; Radiometer, Copenhagen, Denmark). Plasma and urine HCO₃^- concentration were calculated using the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation, with an α of 0.03, as follows: pH = 6.1 + log (total CO₂ αPCO₂); HCO₃^- = total CO₂-αPCO₂.

Urine concentrations of NH₄⁺ and TA were measured by titration [20, 21]. Calculation of net acid excretion (NAE) employed the standard formula [22]: NAE = NH₄⁺ + TA−HCO₃^-. Percentage of acid load excreted was defined as the ratio of the total NAE after NH₄Cl administration, divided by total NH₄Cl load.

Etiological screening

Genetic testing for SLC4A1 mutation and missense polymorphism (p.Glu161Lys) of the ATP6V1B1 gene was systematically proposed to patients with overt acidosis without evidence of an autoimmune disease and in patients with normal acid-base status if urinary pH remained >5.3 after acid load. Genetic testing for other mutations in ATP6V1B1 and ATP6V0A4 genes was performed only in patients with overt acidosis after exclusion of mutations in SLC4A1 [23]. Sequencing methods are detailed in supplementary material (S1 File). If past or current clinical signs suggested an autoimmune disease, a biological screening including serum electrophoresis and antinuclear antibodies was performed. Sjogren’s syndrome was defined according to the American-European-Consensus-Group (AECG) criteria [24].

Statistics

Statistical analyses were performed using STATA 12.0 (StataCorp) and R 3.1.2 statistical software (R Core Team 2014, GNU General Public License). Median and interquartile ranges (IQR) are used to describe continuous variables; numbers and frequencies to describe categorical variables. We used the Wilcoxon rank sum test and Chi-squared test to compare the characteristics of groups when appropriate, and the nonparametric Kruskas-Wallis test to assess differences in urinary acidification defect subgroups. Statistical significance was defined as P<0.05.

Results

Study population

From 2000 to 2015, 67 patients meeting the inclusion criteria were investigated.

Patients were first grouped based on the presence (N = 11, 16.4%) or the absence (N = 56, 83.6%) of an overt metabolic acidosis at baseline. In all the patients with overt metabolic acidosis, dRTA was confirmed using a bicarbonate-loading test (N = 5) or a furosemide/fludrocortisone test (N = 6).

When compared with patients without overt metabolic acidosis (Table 1,column 2), patients with overt metabolic acidosis (Table 1,column 1) were more frequently of female gender and more frequently had a nephrocalcinosis.

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Table 1. Demographic and medical characteristics of the patients.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0177329.t001

Patients with overt metabolic acidosis (Table 2,column 1) had significantly lower plasma potassium levels, significantly higher fasting urinary pH and lower 24-h urinary citrate excretion than patients without overt metabolic acidosis (Table 2,column 2).

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Table 2. Biological characteristics of the 67 patients.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0177329.t002

Supplemental biological results are reported in Table A of the S1 File.

The 56 patients with normal plasma HCO₃^- underwent a short NH₄Cl loading test [4]. The evolution of the urinary pH over time enabled us to split the patients in two groups (Fig 1A): the first group (N = 41) displayed a normal urinary acidification response with pH decreasing <5.3; in the second group (N = 15) urinary pH remained >5.3. Patients were further subdivided according to their ability to excrete acid load, as reflected by the maximal urinary NH₄⁺-excretion rate (Fig 1B). In 33/56 patients (58.9%), urinary pH decreased <5.3 and urinary NH₄⁺ excretion rate increased ≥33 μmol/min after an acute acid load. These patients were diagnosed as having idiopathic hypocitraturia. They excreted 15.9% [13.9–17.9] of the acid load within 6 hours, showing an appropriate response to acidification. The other 23 patients (41.1%) had normal baseline plasma HCO₃^- but did not decrease urinary pH <5.3 or did not increase urinary NH₄⁺ excretion rate ≥33 μmol/min., or both. According to these two criteria, we observed three subtypes of atypical responses to the acid load test. Eleven patients failed to decrease urinary pH but increased urinary NH₄⁺ to normal levels (the “high U.pH, high U.NH₄” group). Four patients failed to decrease urinary pH and to increase urinary NH₄⁺ (the “high U.pH, low U.NH₄” group). Finally, 8 patients had appropriate decreases in urinary pH but insufficient increase in urinary NH₄⁺ excretion rate (the “low U.pH, low U.NH₄” group).

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Fig 1. Urinary response to an acute acid load in patients with a normal acid-base status.

A) Subdivision in 2 subgroups, according to the ability of the patients to decrease urinary pH below 5.3 (upper panel) or not (lower panel). B) Subdivision into four subgroups according the ability of the subjects to decrease urinary pH below 5.3 and to reach maximal urinary ammonium excretion (U.NH₄⁺) to 33 μEq/min. Green: idiopathic hypocitraturia defined to both appropriate adaptation of both pH and U.NH₄⁺). Blue: appropriate maximal urinary ammonium excretion in spite of insufficient urinary acidification (high U. pH, high U.NH₄⁺ group); Purpura: Inappropriate urinary acidification but appropriate U.NH₄⁺ (high U. pH, low U.NH₄⁺ group); Red: Appropriate urinary acidification and U.NH₄⁺ (low U. pH, low U.NH₄⁺ group). Points represent the median value, whiskers represent the interquartile range.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0177329.g001

Table 3 shows the baseline characteristics and Table 4 the responses to acute acid load of patients with normal baseline HCO₃^-. Significant differences between groups were found in age (higher in "low U.pH, low U.NH₄"), fasting urinary calcium excretion and 24-hour calcium excretion (higher in "high U.pH, high U.NH₄"), plasma potassium values (higher in the 2 "low U.NH₄" subgroups), in eGFR and 24-hour citrate excretion (lower in the 2 "low U.NH₄" subgroups) and urinary morning pH (lower in "low U.pH, low U.NH₄"). Importantly, urinary calcium excretion was higher in the "high U.pH, high U.NH₄” group despite similar natriuresis between groups (Table B of the S1 File).

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Table 3. Demographic and biological characteristics of the 56 patients with normal baseline plasma HCO₃^- undergoing the acute acid load test.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0177329.t003

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Table 4. Biological results after the acute acid load test of the 56 patients with normal baseline plasma HCO₃^-.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0177329.t004

Supplemental biological results are reported in Table B of the S1 File.

Of note, urinary citrate excretion overlapped between patients with and without a normal response to the acid load, not allowing defining a threshold to predict the response.

Only one of the 33 patients classified into the idiopathic hypocitraturia group had an eGFR <60 mL/min/1.73 m², compared to 7/23 patients with abnormal response to the acid load (P = 0.004), allocated in the “high U.pH, high U.NH₄” (N = 1), in the “high U.pH, low U.NH₄” (N = 3) and in the “low U.pH, low U.NH₄” (N = 3) subgroups.

In multivariate logistic regression including age and protein intake, a normal response (“idiopathic hypocitraturia”) to the acid load was independently associated with higher eGFR (P = 0.01) and higher urinary citrate excretion (P = 0.04) but no with other characteristics. All groups compounded, the capacity to eliminate the exogenous acid decreased linearly with declining eGFR, both when considering the maximal attained NH₄⁺-excretion rate (r = 0.484,P<0.001) and the ratio of the net acid excretion (NAE) divided by NH₄Cl load (r = 0.507,P<0.001).

To assess interstitial NH₄⁺ availability, we plotted all NH₄⁺-excretion results measured during the test as a function of urinary pH (Fig 2). The downward shift of the relationship suggests a decreased interstitial availability in NH₃ in these patients. When compared to the idiopathic hypocitraturia subgroup, patients with reduced buffer availability had lower NH₄⁺ values for similar urinary pH values.

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Fig 2. Urinary ammonium excretion rates after acute acid load in patients with a normal acid-base status, according to the urinary acidification defect.

All urinary pH values measured within the 6 hours after the acid load are plotted against all the corresponding NH₄⁺ excretion rates (logarithmic value). Patients were classified in four subgroups according to the minimal pH value and to the maximal NH₄⁺ excretion rate obtained within this 6 hours: idiopathic hypocitraturia (green): min. urine pH < 5.3, max. NH₄⁺ ≥ 33 μEq/min.; high U. pH, high U. NH₄ (blue): min. urine pH ≥ 5.3, max. NH₄⁺ ≥ 33 μEq/min.; high U. pH, low U. NH₄ (purpura): min. urine pH ≥5.3, max. NH₄⁺ < 33 μEq/min.; low U. pH, low U. NH₄ (red): min. urine pH < 5.3, max. NH₄⁺ < 33 μEq/min. The thick line represents the regression line and the thin lines the 95% confidence intervals of the idiopathic hypocitraturia group (reference group). The horizontal dotted line is the NH₄⁺ excretion rate cut-off set at 33 μEq/min. The vertical dotted line is the urinary pH cut-off set at 5.3.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0177329.g002

Acidification capacity and related causative diseases

Four out of 11 patients with overt metabolic acidosis (36.4%) had dRTA caused by a Gougerot-Sjögren syndrome. Genetic testing was performed in the seven remaining patients: three patients (42.9%) were heterozygous for the Arg589Cys mutation in the gene encoding AE1 [25]. None of the remaining four patients had mutations in ATP6V0A4 or ATP6V1B1 genes or the missense polymorphism (p.Glu161Lys) of the ATP6V1B1 gene [26] and no cause of dRTA was found in these patients.

Six subjects (10.7%) with normal baseline HCO₃^- had an autoimmune disease (Fig 3). Genetic testing was accepted by 10/11 patients (90.9%) with a normal acid-base status who were unable to decrease the urinary pH<5.3 and without autoimmune disease. These patients had neither mutations in SLC4A1 (Fig 3) nor the previously described ATP6V1B1 polymorphism [26].

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Fig 3. Study results flow chart.

Subgroups classifications: idiopathic hypocitraturia: min. urine pH < 5.3, max. NH₄⁺ ≥ 33 μEq/min.; high U. pH, high U. NH₄: min. urine pH ≥ 5.3, max. NH₄⁺ ≥ 33 μmol/min.; high U. pH, low U. NH₄: min. urine pH ≥5.3, max. NH₄⁺ < 33 μEq/min.; low U. pH, low U. NH₄: min. urine pH < 5.3, max. NH₄⁺ < 33 μEq/min. AE1: chloride bicarbonate exchanger; AI: autoimmune disease; E161K: missense polymorphism (p.Glu161Lys) of the ATP6V1B1 gene; H+-ATPase: B1 and a4-subunits of the apical H+-ATPase, including missense polymorphism (p.Glu161Lys) of the ATP6V1B1 gene; HCO3-: plasma bicarbonate; NH4Cl: ammonium chloride. AI diseases are allocated as follows: "idiopathic hypocitraturia": spondyloarthritis (N = 1), rheumatic polyarthritis (N = 1); "high U.pH, high U.NH4": Gougerot-Sjögren disease (N = 1), spondylarthritis (N = 1), primary biliary cirrhosis (N = 1); "high U.pH, low U.NH₄⁺": Crohn’s disease (N = 1).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0177329.g003

Discussion

In our investigations of patients with hypocitraturia, underlying conditions were overt dRTA (16.4%), idiopathic hypocitraturia (49.3%), and subtle abnormalities in response to acid load (34.3%). The latter group was subdivided on the bases of urinary pH and NH₄⁺-excretion in response to an acute acid load.

In patients with overt dRTA, etiologic screening was profitable, with a genetic cause being identified in 42.9% of cases (N = 3) without autoimmune disease (N = 7), all having the same missense mutation in Arg589 of the SLC4A1 gene, common in Europe [6, 25]. Four were diagnosed with Gougerot-Sjögren syndrome. In the remaining 4 cases, no genetic/autoimmune cause was found. We cannot exclude that they will manifest in the future an autoimmune disease or that they have a predisposing genetic mutation, not yet identified.

Patients with normal baseline acid-base status were challenged with acute acid load test. Urine pH may be misleading when trying to assess the integrity of the distal urinary acidification, since it measures only the activity of free hydrogens ions, which is less than 1% of the total amount of protons excreted. In the presence of a high amount of buffer in the urine, as observed in patients with chronic extrarenal acidosis, urinary pH may remain >5.3 despite appropriate acid excretion. Conversely, in the presence of low buffer availability, an apparent appropriate low urine pH does not exclude a defect in net acid excretion [27]. We thus took both parameters into account.

Of patients with normal acid-base status under basal conditions, 58.9% had idiopathic hypocitraturia (normal evolution of urinary pH and NH₄⁺ after acute acid load). Excepted for low urinary citrate excretion, the biological profiles of these patients were within the normal ranges. We found no easily available adjunctive element that allows prediction of the response to an acid challenge test, with the exception of an impaired eGFR (<60 mL/min/1.73 m²), which is virtually always predictive of an abnormal response to the acid load test.

Among patients with a normal acid-base status, 41.1% were either unable to decrease urinary pH <5.3 and/or to increase NH₄⁺-excretion rate ≥33 μEq/min. when challenged with an acid load. The pathophysiological signification of these defects is in question. In 1959, Wrong [4] described the cases of three patients with nephrocalcinosis, who were unable to decrease their urinary pH after an acute acid challenge. Some of these patients displayed an appropriate response in terms of NH₄⁺ and NAE, suggesting that NH₃/NH₄⁺ accumulates in the renal interstitium. In line with this, 11/56 patients (19.6%) in our study with normal basal acid-base status failed to appropriately acidify their urine after the acute acid load, although they did show an appropriate increase in urinary NH₄⁺. The relevance of this defect that does not impair NAE is questionable. This abnormality could reflect increased ammoniogenesis due either to a primary event in proximal tubule [4, 28] or to subtle extrarenal bicarbonate loss/acid load that may chronically stimulate ammoniogenesis, and explain the low urinary citrate excretion. Whatever the underlying mechanism, it has been proposed that the resulting accumulation in medullary interstitium of NH₃/NH₄⁺ might be deleterious for the kidney [28, 29]. These patients had however conserved eGFR and showed no increase in 24-hour urinary NH₄⁺-excretion, suggesting no extrarenal acidosis. Interestingly, this group had a higher 24-hour urinary calcium excretion than all other subgroups, as well as a higher urinary fasting calcium/creatinine ratio (median of 0.41 mmol/mmol for a upper limit of 0.37 mmol/mmol), reflecting higher net bone resorption (fasting calcium/creatinine ratio is measured after 12-hours fasting; the calcium measured with this test comes mainly from bone and reflects net bone resorption, i.e. the difference between the rates of mineralization and resorption). These findings suggest that this form of urinary acidification dysregulation may have deleterious repercussions on bone and kidney. Of note, higher urinary calcium excretion in this group was not due to higher sodium intake since 24-hour natriuresis was similar in all groups. Even if these patients are not considered to have abnormal adaptation to acid load, since they were able to adapt their acid rate excretion, it is worthy of further investigation to determine whether these patients have extrarenal disease or primary proximal tubular defects. Due to the deleterious effect of NH₃/NH₄⁺ on kidney interstitium [28], this early presentation with “high U.pH, high U.NH₄” could switch to a later presentation with lower GFR and lower availability in interstitial NH₃/NH₄⁺, such as observed in the “low U.pH, low U.NH₄” group and illustrated by the relationship between pH and NH₄⁺ excretion.

When challenged with the acid load, 8/56 patients (14.3%) were able to adapt their urinary pH but not their NH₄⁺ excretion rate. These patients are systematically missed when considering only the urinary pH response to the acid load. A low NH₄⁺ excretion may be due to a blunted ammoniogenesis in the proximal tubule by the metabolism of glutamine or to a NH₃ transfer defect through the renal interstitium to the collecting duct lumen, the latter being explained for example by an interstitial disease (impaired countercurrent system) or by hyperkalemia [27]. None of our patients presented with hyperkalemia, but patients of this subgroup were older and their eGFRs were lower (more than expected considering physiologic loss of GFR with aging) than in patients with idiopathic hypocitraturia. The capacity of these patients to eliminate the acid load was almost halved when compared to patients with normal renal acid handling.

Finally, 4/56 patients (7.2%) were unable to adapt both their urinary pH and NH₄⁺-excretion rate to the acid load, defining a renal acidification defect usually referred as incomplete dRTA.

Regarding the etiologic screening of patients with a masked urinary acidification defect, the prevalence of an autoimmune disorder was 17% (vs. 36% in the overt dRTA group) and included several types of autoimmune disease. We suggest screening for symptoms indicative of a systemic immunologic disease, based on previous demonstrations of the relationships of several autoimmune diseases with acquired urinary acidification defects [9, 10]. Some case series demonstrated dominant SLC4A1 mutations in patients with a masked acidification defect [25, 30] or the presence of the missense polymorphism (p.Glu161Lys) of the ATP6V1B1 gene [26]. In our series, neither mutations in the SLC4A1 gene nor this polymorphism were detected in hypocitraturic patients with normal basal acid-base status and altered urinary acidification capacity.

The main question is whether characterization of the masked urinary acidification defect would influence the management of the patients. In patients with alkaline urine and preserved ammoniogenesis, the administration of citrate is the priority, as this treatment corrects intracellular acidosis. Thiazide diuretics, used to decrease hypercalciuria, should be carefully titrated to avoid hypokalemia and aggravation of hypocitraturia [3]. Whether citrate treatment is sufficient (without the use of thiazide diuretics) to normalize fasting calciuria deserves a dedicated study. In patients with reduced availability of NH₄⁺, the therapy should focus on the reason for lack of buffer (i.e., impaired ammoniogenesis or defects in ammonium transfer through the medullary interstitium) with correction of hyperkalemia if present. The therapeutic approach should induce reductions in the exogenous acid load (e.g., animal protein intake). The prescription of potassium citrate should be considered, but plasma potassium should carefully be monitored if renal function is impaired.

Our study has several limitations. Because of its retrospective design, we could not determine whether the masked phenotype (with normal baseline plasma HCO3^-) progresses to the overt metabolic acidosis phenotype or whether there is a continuum that bridges the different subgroups with subtle urinary acidification defects. Concerning the etiologic screening, biomarkers for autoimmune diseases were investigated only in presence of clinical signs. Thus, the real prevalence of an autoimmune disorder cannot be formally assessed, and a random association cannot be excluded. Screening for SLC4A1 mutations was refused by three patients with a masked urinary acidification defect; therefore, we cannot exclude the occurrence of a hereditary cause in patients presenting with normal HCO₃^-. DXA was not systematically performed. Consequently, we could not assess the impact of a latent urinary acidification defect on bone mineralization.

We did not repeat acid load in our patients since we conducted a retrospective study including all the patients explored in our department due to hypocitraturia. Of note, the acidification test takes time (usually more than 6 hours) and cannot be repeated easily. Given the complexity and the length of this exploration, this question would require a dedicated prospective study, which has never been performed before to our best knowledge. However, in healthy volunteers previously explored in our department for another work, we could check that the inter-individual variability of the response to the acidification test was very low suggesting a low intra-individual variability for a given patient.

Conclusions

In conclusion, in hypocitraturic patients with normal plasma HCO₃^-, an accurate diagnosis of a masked urinary acidification defect requires a functional acid challenge test, which should consider both urinary NH₄⁺ and urinary pH response. Indeed, in a significant number of patients, inappropriately high urinary pH was associated with appropriate adaptation of NH₄⁺ excretion. We have shown that these patients should be screened for high urinary fasting calcium excretion and should benefit from further investigation to determine whether they have extrarenal disease or primary proximal tubular defects. Conversely, we have highlighted that apparently appropriate low urinary pH could be associated with blunted adaptation in NH₄⁺ excretion. Even if these patients were until now theoretically not considered to have abnormal adaptation to acid load, we have shown that these patients were at risk of having low GFR.,

Consequently, the precise characterization of the biological phenotype underlying hypocitraturia is of high importance to adapt etiologic screening and therapeutic management to optimize the care of patients with nephrolithiasis.

Supporting information

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

S1 File. Additional method’s details.

Table A. Biological characteristics of the patients, according to the basal abnormalities in the acid-base status. Values are expressed as median [interquartile range]. Ca²⁺: calcium; P: plasma. * p < 0.05 compared to the overt metabolic acidosis group. Table B. Biological characteristics of patients with a normal acid-base status undergoing the acute acid load test. Values are expressed as median [interquartile range]. Ca²⁺: calcium; NH₄⁺: ammonium; P: plasma; NH₄Cl: ammonium chloride. Subgroups classification: Idiopathic Hypocitraturia: urine pH min < 5.3, NH₄⁺ max ≥ 33 μEq/min.; high U.pH, high U.NH4: urine pH min < 5.3, NH₄⁺ max ≥ 33 μEq/min.; high U.pH, low U.NH₄: urine pH min ≥5.3, NH₄⁺ max ≥ 33 μEq/min.; low U.pH, low U.NH₄: urine pH min < 5.3, NH₄⁺ max < 33 μEq/min.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0177329.s001

(DOCX)

Author Contributions

1. Conceptualization: VFO AB RV PH MC.

2. Data curation: VFO.

3. Formal analysis: VOF AO.

4. Investigation: JN JD GM MM AGC CT NL.

5. Methodology: VFO AB PH MC AO.

6. Project administration: VFO MC.

7. Resources: VFO MC.

8. Software: AO.

9. Supervision: MC.

10. Validation: MC RV AB PH.

11. Visualization: MC RV AB PH.

12. Writing – original draft: VFO AB MC AO.

13. Writing – review & editing: PH JPB CPB SB AO.

Citation: Forni Ogna V, Blanchard A, Vargas-Poussou R, Ogna A, Baron S, Bertocchio J-P, et al. (2017) Signification of distal urinary acidification defects in hypocitraturic patients. PLoS ONE 12(5): e0177329. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0177329

References

1. Kok DJ, Papapoulos SE, Bijvoet OL. Crystal agglomeration is a major element in calcium oxalate urinary stone formation. Kidney Int. 1990;37(1):51–6. pmid:2299809

2. Arrabal-Polo MA, Arrabal-Martin M, Arias-Santiago S, Garrido-Gomez J, Poyatos-Andujar A, Zuluaga-Gomez A. Importance of citrate and the calcium: citrate ratio in patients with calcium renal lithiasis and severe lithogenesis. BJU international. 2013;111(4):622–7. pmid:22757744

3. Simpson DP. Citrate excretion: a window on renal metabolism. Am J Physiol. 1983;244(3):F223–34. pmid:6338740

4. Wrong O, Davies HE. The excretion of acid in renal disease. Q J Med. 1959;28(110):259–313. pmid:13658353

5. Buckalew VM Jr, McCurdy DK, Ludwig GD, Chaykin LB, Elkinton JR. Incomplete renal tubular acidosis. Physiologic studies in three patients with a defect in lowering urine pH. Am J Med. 1968;45(1):32–42. pmid:5658867

6. Batlle D, Haque SK. Genetic causes and mechanisms of distal renal tubular acidosis. Nephrol Dial Transplant.27(10):3691–704. pmid:23114896

7. Fry AC, Su Y, Yiu V, Cuthbert AW, Trachtman H, Karet Frankl FE. Mutation conferring apical-targeting motif on AE1 exchanger causes autosomal dominant distal RTA. J Am Soc Nephrol.23(7):1238–49. pmid:22518001

8. Cohen EP, Bastani B, Cohen MR, Kolner S, Hemken P, Gluck SL. Absence of H(+)-ATPase in cortical collecting tubules of a patient with Sjogren's syndrome and distal renal tubular acidosis. J Am Soc Nephrol. 1992;3(2):264–71. pmid:1391725

9. Wrong OM, Feest TG, MacIver AG. Immune-related potassium-losing interstitial nephritis: a comparison with distal renal tubular acidosis. Q J Med. 1993;86(8):513–34. pmid:8210309

10. Batlle DC, Sehy JT, Roseman MK, Arruda JA, Kurtzman NA. Clinical and pathophysiologic spectrum of acquired distal renal tubular acidosis. Kidney Int. 1981;20(3):389–96. pmid:6795380

11. Araujo NC, Rebelo MA. Study of urinary acidification in patients with idiopathic hypocitraturia. Braz J Med Biol Res. 2000;33(2):205–10. pmid:10657060

12. Hess B, Michel R, Takkinen R, Ackermann D, Jaeger P. Risk factors for low urinary citrate in calcium nephrolithiasis: low vegetable fibre intake and low urine volume to be added to the list. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 1994;9(6):642–9. pmid:7970090

13. Pongchaiyakul C, Domrongkitchaiporn S, Stitchantrakul W, Chailurkit LO, Rajatanavin R. Incomplete renal tubular acidosis and bone mineral density: a population survey in an area of endemic renal tubular acidosis. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2004;19(12):3029–33. pmid:15479744

14. Arampatzis S, Ropke-Rieben B, Lippuner K, Hess B. Prevalence and densitometric characteristics of incomplete distal renal tubular acidosis in men with recurrent calcium nephrolithiasis. Urol Res.40(1):53–9. pmid:21713545

15. Chow K, Dixon J, Gilpin S, Kavanagh JP, Rao PN. Citrate inhibits growth of residual fragments in an in vitro model of calcium oxalate renal stones. Kidney Int. 2004;65(5):1724–30. pmid:15086911

16. Forni Ogna V, Ogna A, Vuistiner P, Pruijm M, Ponte B, Ackermann D, et al. New anthropometry-based age- and sex-specific reference values for urinary 24-hour creatinine excretion based on the adult Swiss population. BMC Med.13:40. pmid:25858764

17. Halperin ML, Goldstein MB, Haig A, Johnson MD, Stinebaugh BJ. Studies on the pathogenesis of type I (distal) renal tubular acidosis as revealed by the urinary PCO2 tensions. The Journal of clinical investigation. 1974;53(3):669–77. pmid:4812435

18. Walsh SB, Shirley DG, Wrong OM, Unwin RJ. Urinary acidification assessed by simultaneous furosemide and fludrocortisone treatment: an alternative to ammonium chloride. Kidney Int. 2007;71(12):1310–6. pmid:17410104

19. DuBose TD Jr, Caflisch CR. Validation of the difference in urine and blood carbon dioxide tension during bicarbonate loading as an index of distal nephron acidification in experimental models of distal renal tubular acidosis. The Journal of clinical investigation. 1985;75(4):1116–23. pmid:3921566

20. Jorgensen K. Titrimetric determination of the net excretion of acid/base in urine. Scand J Clin Lab Invest 1987(9):287–91.

21. Nutbourne DM. The effect of dilution on the titratable acid in urine and acidified phosphate buffer solutions, and the correction for this effect in the determination of the rate of elimination of hydrogen ions from the body by the renal tubules. Clin Sci. 1961;20:263–78. pmid:13729937

22. Elkinton JR, Huth EJ, Webster GD Jr, McC R. The renal excretion of hydrogen ion in renal tubular acidosis. I. quantitative assessment of the response to ammonium chloride as an acid load. Am J Med. 1960;29:554–75. pmid:13726399

23. Vargas-Poussou R, Houillier P, Le Pottier N, Strompf L, Loirat C, Baudouin V, et al. Genetic investigation of autosomal recessive distal renal tubular acidosis: evidence for early sensorineural hearing loss associated with mutations in the ATP6V0A4 gene. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2006;17(5):1437–43. pmid:16611712

24. Vitali C, Bombardieri S, Jonsson R, Moutsopoulos HM, Alexander EL, Carsons SE, et al. Classification criteria for Sjogren's syndrome: a revised version of the European criteria proposed by the American-European Consensus Group. Annals of the rheumatic diseases. 2002;61(6):554–8. pmid:12006334

25. Bruce LJ, Cope DL, Jones GK, Schofield AE, Burley M, Povey S, et al. Familial distal renal tubular acidosis is associated with mutations in the red cell anion exchanger (Band 3, AE1) gene. The Journal of clinical investigation. 1997;100(7):1693–707. pmid:9312167

26. Dhayat NA, Schaller A, Albano G, Poindexter J, Griffith C, Pasch A, et al. The Vacuolar H+-ATPase B1 Subunit Polymorphism p.E161K Associates with Impaired Urinary Acidification in Recurrent Stone Formers. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2015.

27. Carlisle EJ, Donnelly SM, Halperin ML. Renal tubular acidosis (RTA): recognize the ammonium defect and pHorget the urine pH. Pediatr Nephrol. 1991;5(2):242–8. pmid:2031845

28. Donnelly S, Kamel KS, Vasuvattakul S, Narins RG, Halperin ML. Might distal renal tubular acidosis be a proximal tubular cell disorder? Am J Kidney Dis. 1992;19(3):272–81. pmid:1553972

29. Vallet M, Metzger M, Haymann JP, Flamant M, Gauci C, Thervet E, et al. Urinary ammonia and long-term outcomes in chronic kidney disease. Kidney Int. 2015;88(1):137–45. pmid:25760321

30. Rysava R, Tesar V, Jirsa M Jr, Brabec V, Jarolim P. Incomplete distal renal tubular acidosis coinherited with a mutation in the band 3 (AE1) gene. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 1997;12(9):1869–73. pmid:9306337