Evaluation and validation of HPV real-time PCR assay for the detection of HPV DNA in oral cytobrush and FFPE samples

Abstract

Specific HPV genotypes have been recognized as risk factors inducing head and neck cancers (HNC). The aim of this study was to validate a real-time PCR assay to detect accurately High Risk HPV DNA in Formalin Fixed Paraffin Embedded (FFPE) and oral cytobrush samples and compare the results with conventional PCR. Repeatability, reproducibility and limit of detection of Cobas assay were estimated for oral cytobrush and FFPE samples of patients with HNC. 53 samples of patients with a HNC were then used for assay comparison with conventional PCR. Finally, 26 samples of patients with anogenital neoplasia cancer were analyzed as control and assays comparison. Among the 53 samples of patients with HNC, 12 (26.7%) were HPV positive, 33 (73.3%) were HPV negative and 8 (15.1%) were non contributive with the Cobas assay. Among the 26 samples of patients with anogenital neoplasia, 15 (57.7%) were HPV positive and 11 were HPV negative (42.3%). One sample was found with an HPV 16 and HPV 18 co-infection. Only 3 samples were found with discrepant results. Cobas assay was found suitable for routine HPV detection with a very good repeatability and reproducibility for all HPV genotypes (CV < 0.6% and <0.4% respectively). Sensitivity and specificity for Cobas assay were 91.7% [61.5%;99.8%] and 96.9% [83.8%;99.9%] respectively. Ten nanograms of DNA were sufficient for the detection of HPV 16, HPV 18 and HPV in FFPE and oral cytobrush samples. Cobas assay was found comparable to conventional PCR and can detect accurately and rapidly HPV DNA in FFPE and oral cytobrush samples for the management of HNC and other types of HPV-associated neoplasia.