Nitrate transformation and immobilization in particulate organic matter incubations: Influence of redox, iron and (a)biotic conditions

Abstract

Nitrate can be reduced to other N inorganic species via denitrification and incorporated into organic matter by immobilization; however, the effect of biotic/abiotic and redox condition on immobilization and denitrification processes from a single system are not well documented. We hypothesize nitrate (NO3-) transformation pathways leading to the formation of dissolved- and solid-phase organic N are predominantly controlled by abiotic reactions, but the formation of soluble inorganic N species is controlled by redox condition. In this study, organic matter in the form of leaf compost (LC) was spiked with 15NO3- and incubated under oxic/anoxic and biotic/abiotic conditions at pH 6.5. We seek to understand how variations in environmental conditions impact NO3- transformation pathways through laboratory incubations. We find production of NH4+ is predominantly controlled by redox whereas NO3- conversion to dissolved organic nitrogen (DON) and immobilization in solid-phase N are predominantly controlled by abiotic processes. Twenty % of added 15N-NO3- was incorporated into DON under oxic conditions, with abiotic processes accounting for 85% of the overall incorporation. Nitrogen immobilization processes resulted in N concentrations of 4.1–6.6 μg N (g leaf compost)-1, with abiotic processes accounting for 100% and 66% of the overall (biotic+abiotic) N immobilization under anoxic and oxic conditions, respectively. 15N-NMR spectroscopy suggests 15NO3- was immobilized into amide/aminoquinones and nitro/oxime under anoxic conditions. A fraction of the NH4+ was produced abiotically under anoxic conditions (~10% of the total NH4+ production) although biotic organic N mineralization contributed to most of NH4+ production. Our results also indicate Fe(II) did not act as an electron source in biotic-oxic incubations; however, Fe(II) provided electrons for NO3- reduction in biotic-anoxic incubations although it was not the sole electron source. It is clear that, under the experimental conditions of this investigation, abiotic and redox processes play important roles in NO3- transformations. As climatic conditions change (e.g., frequency/intensity of rainfall), abiotic reactions that shift transformation pathways and N species concentrations from those controlled by biota might become more prevalent.

About the Authors:

Fiona R. Kizewski

Roles Conceptualization, Formal analysis, Writing – original draft

Affiliation: Department of Ecosystem Science and Management, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, United States of America

Jason P. Kaye

Roles Funding acquisition, Writing – review & editing

Affiliation: Department of Ecosystem Science and Management, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, United States of America

Carmen Enid Martínez

Roles Conceptualization, Formal analysis, Funding acquisition, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

* E-mail: [email protected]

Affiliation: Soil and Crop Sciences, School of Integrative Plant Science, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, United States of America

ORCID logo http://orcid.org/0000-0001-8553-2118

Introduction

Nitrogen (N) is an essential nutrient that exists within a tight global cycle. Increased anthropogenic additions (e.g., NO3-) have however resulted in excess N that short-circuits this natural cycle; the consequences of this short-circuiting (i.e., bypass) are pollution of our air and water resources. Nitrate can be reduced to other N inorganic species via denitrification (NO2-, NO, N2O, N2) and incorporated into organic matter by immobilization (Org-N). Immobilization is understood as a mechanism of NO3- transformation that entails the reduction of NO3- possibly to more reactive NO2- before immobilization into organic N. The formation of organic-N species can potentially prevent NO3- leaching losses and the production of N2O, a potent greenhouse gas, while retaining N within ecosystems in chemical forms that are available for plant and microbial uptake. Although abiotic pathways for the formation of N trace gases are relatively well recognized [1–4], abiotic pathways and the extent of these chemical processes to the formation of dissolved and solid-phase organic-N species is still subject to debate. Expected changes in climatic conditions (e.g., frequency and intensity of precipitation that affects redox gradients and microbial growth rates and metabolism) may increase the prominence and occurrence of abiotic transformations. Since anoxic/suboxic conditions are likely to increase the concentration of species presumed active in abiotic N cycling (e.g., NO2-, Fe2+, reduced forms of organic matter), studies focused on abiotic pathways and redox conditions, and their contribution to the global N cycle are warranted [5].

Studies on forest ecosystems show that soils, rather than plants, are the primary sink for applied inorganic N (Ni) [6,7]. Nitrogen retention in soils is largely attributable to N immobilization, a process that converts Ni to organic nitrogen (No) [8–10]. Huygens et al. (2008) [11] demonstrated that, one day after addition to volcanic soils, 50% and 60% of the NH4+ and NO3- were retained in solid organic matter, respectively. It has been generally accepted that N immobilization is primarily driven by microbial activity [12,13]. Yet, N immobilization can occur very rapidly (within minutes to hours), so rapidly that it cannot be explained solely by microbial activity [14–16]. In addition, CO2 respiration (a consequence of organic carbon mineralization), often deemed necessary to fuel microbial N immobilization [17], was not detected during the time when Ni was rapidly immobilized [18]. The implication of these findings is that Ni can be immobilized to No via abiotic processes as well. In the past decades, evidence supporting abiotic N immobilization has been accumulating [15,19–23]. However, contrasting results have also been reported. Colman et al. (2007) [24] found little N was retained in any of the 44 sterilized soils amended with NO3-. The controversy on abiotic N immobilization exemplifies that our understanding of this process is still insufficient; much remains to be learned about the magnitude and mechanisms that control abiotic N immobilization.

Nitrate is the most mobile N species in soils, likely due to the lack of non-bonding electrons in its electronic structure. In comparison, nitrite (NO2-), which has a pair of non-bonding electrons, is expected to have a stronger ability to bind to organic matter. Nitrogen in NO3- is in its highest oxidation state (5+). NO3- transformation to No involves a decrease in N oxidation state due to the formation of C-N bonds. Therefore, it has been hypothesized that NO3- is first reduced to NO2- (3+ oxidation state) prior to immobilization and that ferrous iron (Fe(II)) can serve as an electron donor in NO3- reduction [23,25]. If this theory holds, anoxic conditions found in the interior of soil aggregates, flooded soils, low oxygen zones in streams, or wetlands are expected to facilitate NO3- immobilization. However, when a soil’s redox condition is conducive to NO3- reduction, the reduction may not be arrested at NO2- formation but may continue to produce gaseous N species (e.g., N2) by microbial denitrification or NH4+ by dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium (DNRA) [26–29]. In addition, reducing conditions may facilitate anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox). All these processes can lead to NH4+ production and/or to gaseous N loss to the atmosphere. As a result, immobilization may be competing with these NO3- attenuation processes for the available N under anoxic conditions. Currently, there is insufficient information to enable evaluation of the influence of redox conditions on NO3- immobilization, particularly abiotic immobilization.

While some studies have shown that NO3- was largely retained in SOM [11,21], rapid NO3- transformation to DON has also been observed [15,20,23,30]. In comparison with NO2- and NH4+, NO3- was found more prone to conversion to DON. Both Dail et al. (2001) [15] and Fitzhugh et al.(2003) [20] found the amount of NO2- retained in SOM was more than five times that of NO3-. Nitrate transformation to DON potentially explains the unrecovered N in 15N tracer studies and N loss from ecosystems [31]. Indeed, after investigating more than 100 streams, Perakis and Hedin (2002) [32] concluded that DON loss from unpolluted forests was the primary source for N input to nearby streams. Yet it is, again, largely unclear how environmental variables regulate this process. It has been suggested that NO3- conversion to DON occurs via abiotic reactions [15,23,33,34] but well-designed abiotic experiments are required to verify the involvement of microbial activity in NO3- transformation to DON.

Whether Ni transformations lead to the formation of dissolved- and solid-phase organic N, the molecular structures of No and the influence of No on the storage and release of this essential nutrient into plant-available forms are largely unknown [35,36]. Recent studies on the characterization of No forms have found pyridines, anilides, amines, and amides are important components of soil and humic acid N [37–42]. Furthermore, the identity of these dissolved and solid-phase molecular structures is important in N biological availability, and in N retention/mobility and accumulation in soils. For example, anilide-N structures have been postulated to result in decreased N availability and reduced crop (rice) yields as these structures are presumed to be less easily mineralized into available forms [43] than more labile N forms such as amino N [35]. Identification of No molecular structures could therefore lead to a better understanding of the reactions that result in the formation of stable N [44].

Although strictly abiotic conditions are not likely to exist in soils, abiotic (micro)sites prevail due to heterogeneous distribution of microbial colonies [45]. In a broader environmental context, NO3- and leaf-derived organic matter interact in oxic and anoxic conditions in streams, wetlands, sediments, and organic layers of forest soils. Nitrate transformations in these environmental settings are expected to be controlled by both biotic and abiotic processes; thus it is important to understand the circumstances under which these processes govern the fate of NO3-. The existing disparate results on abiotic N immobilization and the uncertainty of how redox conditions affect N immobilization justify more in-depth investigations into NO3- transformations under different environmental conditions. In the present study, we investigate how variations in biotic-abiotic and oxic-anoxic conditions influence the dynamics of NO3- transformations when 15N-NO3- is added to leaf compost and incubated in an aqueous suspension for 5 days. We hypothesize nitrate (NO3-) transformation pathways leading to the formation of dissolved- and solid-phase organic N are predominantly controlled by abiotic reactions, whereas the formation of soluble inorganic N species is controlled by redox condition. Our experimental set up permits answers to questions such as: which nitrate transformation processes are predominantly controlled by redox condition and which are predominantly controlled by biota? In particular, we define the redox condition that exert the greatest influence on N immobilization and the significance of abiotic N immobilization. In addition to the magnitude of N immobilization, we attempted to identify molecular structures of solid-phase N species resulting from N immobilization using 15N-NMR spectroscopy. The experiments we conduct provide a comprehensive assessment of macroscopic processes and are critical to understanding the character of N stored in terrestrial ecosystems and ultimately the release of this essential nutrient into bioavailable forms. Knowledge of the environmental conditions that lead to specific N transformation products is important to understanding controls of nutrient losses that will improve water and air quality.

Materials and methods

Incubation materials and experimental set-up

The organic matter used in this study is a sugar maple (Acer saccharumm L.) leaf compost (LC) collected from a rural location near Ithaca, NY [46]. The LC was air-dried, ground and sieved to obtain the size fraction <1 mm. The LC contains 374 g OC kg-1 and 19.4 g N kg-1. The LC was rinsed twice with deionized water and then with 0.01 M KCl to remove residual N before oven-drying at 60°C overnight. Each incubation was conducted in a LC suspension prepared by mixing the solid material (2 g) with 500 mL of 0.01 M KCl background electrolyte solution. A nitrate solution (50 mM) was made with 98% 15N enriched K15NO3 (Sigma Aldrich, U.S.A.) and 2 mL of this solution was spiked into the LC suspension to obtain a NO3- concentration of 200 μM and 15N input of 750 μg 15N g-1 LC. Leaf compost suspensions without NO3- addition were also included and represented blank incubations. The suspensions (experimental and blank) were incubated for five days under four sets of conditions: biotic-oxic (Oxic), abiotic-oxic (γ-Oxic), biotic-anoxic (Anox), and abiotic-anoxic (γ-Anox).

The reaction vessel containing the LC suspension had two openings through which a pH and an Eh electrode were inserted, in addition to ports for sampling and gas dispersion. The pH electrode was connected to an automatic acid/base titrator to achieve a constant pH of 6.5. Anoxic conditions (Eh ~ -330 mV) were attained by passing a constant N2 gas flow into the vessel. For abiotic incubations, the LC was sterilized by gamma (γ) irradiation (6 Mrad dose) at the Breazeale Nuclear Reactor, The Pennsylvania State University. To test the sterility of the γ-irradiated LC, 0.1 g of material was incubated in 25 ml of peptone-tryptone-yeast extract-glucose (PTYG) growth media at 25°C for two weeks. The incubated PTYG growth media (0.1 ml) was then evenly plated onto an R-2A filled cell culture dish, which was then incubated at 25°C for two weeks. At the end of the incubation, microbial colonies were not detected under a microscope. Appropriate aseptic techniques were used during all abiotic incubations. At the end of an experimental γ-Oxic incubation, the LC suspension was subjected to a most probable number (MPN) analysis with 2-fold dilution and five replicates. The experimental result was 1-0-0-0, indicating an estimated cell count of 0.2 cells/ml suspension or 50 cells g-1 LC (approximately 106 to 109 cells g-1 live soil) [47], thus confirming sterility was well maintained throughout the entire incubation period. During the incubations, aliquots of the suspensions (~25 ml) were withdrawn each day and filtered with 0.2 μm membranes to separate solutions from solid materials. Solutions were frozen immediately for future analyses while the solids were air-dried and then oven dried at 40°C for 6 h. Experimental and blank incubations, each under the four set of conditions, were conducted twice and the data reported are averages of duplicate experiments.

Analytical methods

Concentrations of NO3-+NO2-, NO2-, and NH4+ in filtered solutions were determined colorimetrically with sulfanilamide (with VCl3 for NO3-+NO2-, without VCl3 for NO2-) and salicylate/nitroprusside (for NH4+). The method used for NO3-+NO2- determination utilizes VCl3, sulfanilamide and N-1-napthylethylenediamine under acidic conditions, which prevents Fe2+ interference in the determination of NO3- concentrations (SI for additional discussion). Total dissolved nitrogen (TDN) was determined by measuring total NO3- in solutions after digestion with potassium persulfate. The difference between TDN and the sum of NO3-+NO2- and NH4+ is defined as dissolved organic nitrogen (DON). The concentration of ferrous iron (Fe(II)) in the LC was determined by mixing 2 ml of the LC suspension with 2 ml of 1 M HCl in an anaerobic chamber for 24 h. The mixture was filtered (0.2 μm membrane) and the filtrate analyzed for total Fe(II) with the Ferrozine reagent. Measured Fe(II) is defined as 0.5 M extractable Fe(II) in the system.

The 15N isotope ratio (15N/(14N+15N)) in NO3- and NH4+ was determined. For NO3-, solutions were treated with a microbial denitrifier and the 15N isotope ratio in the resultant N2O gas was measured while dissolved NH4+ was trapped onto acidified discs [48]. Solutions were also freeze-dried and the solid residue reconstituted in 50 μL of deionized H2O. An aliquot (7 μL) of the reconstituted solutions was deposited onto an acidified disc for 15N isotope ratio determination of TDN. The magnitude of N immobilization (i.e., transformation of Ni to SON) is defined as the amount of 15N recovered in the solid-phase, calculated as the difference in 15N enrichment of the LC before and after incubation. Standard isotope mixing models [49] were used to calculate the fraction of tracer 15NO3- in solid-phase, NO3-, NH4+, and DON pools. Nitrogen (15N) isotope ratio measurements were conducted at the Stable Isotope Facility at the University of California, Davis and at the Boston University Stable Isotope Laboratory.

Results

Nitrate, nitrite, and Fe(II) concentrations

Under oxic conditions, both the experimental biotic-oxic and abiotic-oxic (i.e., γ-irradiated oxic) systems illustrated initially abrupt, yet incomplete, decreases in aqueous NO3- concentration (≈20%) immediately after its addition (Fig 1A). Similar initial (immediate) decreases were not observed in anoxic incubations (Fig 1B). These results therefore suggest that under oxic conditions a portion of the spiked NO3- was rapidly transformed to other N species in abiotic-oxic incubations. Following an additional ≈5% decrease within 20 h, NO3- concentration remained unchanged throughout the abiotic-oxic incubation but increased slightly towards the end of the biotic-oxic incubation (Fig 1A). A decrease in 15N isotope ratio in NO3- (from 98 to 94 atom %) was found in solution at the end of the biotic-oxic incubation (Table A in S1 File), thus confirming that newly generated NO3- contributed to the NO3- pool, likely due to microbial nitrification. The 15N isotope ratio in NO3- did not change in the abiotic-oxic incubation, indicating that there was no NO3- production in γ-irradiated incubations.

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Fig 1. Nitrate (NO3-), nitrite (NO2-) and ferrous iron (Fe(II)) concentrations as a function of incubation time.

Panels A and B represent NO3- and NO2- concentrations in experimental (NO3- spiked) incubations under oxic and anoxic conditions, respectively. Panel C and D present 0.5 M HCl extractable Fe(II) concentrations in blank (no NO3- spiked) and experimental (NO3- spiked) incubations under biotic-oxic and biotic-anoxic conditions, respectively. Initial NO3- concentration was 200 μM. Error bars represent standard deviation of duplicate values. Note different scale for x-axis in panel B.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0218752.g001

Nitrate concentrations dropped to zero after ~20 h in anoxic incubations (Fig 1B). The highest NO2- concentrations were also observed in these systems at ~ 20 h, and dropped to zero at ~50 h (Fig 1B). Nitrite detection in biotic-anoxic and abiotic-anoxic incubations indicates NO3- went through reduction and that NO3- reduction in the biotic-anoxic system was likely a chemical process since the patterns of change in NO3- and NO2- concentrations observed in the biotic-anoxic incubation are identical to those observed in the abiotic-anoxic incubation. It is worth noting that the amount of NO2- at its peak concentration accounts for ~1/3 of the initial NO3- spike. Under anoxic conditions, several processes may have led to NO3-/NO2- disappearance: 1) NO3- reduction to NH4+; 2) NO3- reduction to NO2- and then to gaseous nitrogen species (i.e., NOx, N2), which are lost to the atmosphere; 3) NO3-/NO2- incorporation into either solid or dissolved organic matter (i.e., SON, DON). It is likely a combination of these processes was operative in both the biotic-anoxic and abiotic-anoxic incubations, as shown by the 15N isotope ratio data presented in Table A in S1 File.

The concentration of Fe(II) remained relatively constant throughout experimental and blank biotic-oxic incubations, indicating the addition of NO3- had no influence on Fe(II) concentrations (Fig 1C). Fe(II) concentrations in blank biotic-anoxic incubations increased initially but remained constant after ~30 h (Fig 1D). In contrast, a decrease in Fe(II) concentrations was observed within 8 h in experimental biotic-anoxic incubations followed by a steady increase that resulted in equal concentration in blank and experimental incubations at 120h.

Ammonium and dissolved organic nitrogen

Experimental and blank incubations displayed significant changes in DON and NH4+ concentrations with time (Fig 2). DON concentrations in experimental biotic-oxic and abiotic-oxic incubations rose by ~40 μM immediately after NO3- addition (Fig 2A and 2B), an increase equal in magnitude to the initial rapid decrease in NO3- concentrations under oxic conditions. An increase in 15N enrichment was found in the DON pool in both the experimental biotic-oxic and abiotic-oxic system (Table A in S1 File). Collectively, these data confirm that ~17% of the 15N-NO3- added was rapidly transformed to 15N-DON in γ-irradiated LC under oxic conditions. Following the initial rapid increase, DON in the experimental biotic-oxic and abiotic-oxic incubations rose gradually with time and paralleled DON increases in blank incubations. The same amount of NH4+ was produced in the experimental and blank biotic-oxic incubations (Fig 2A). Ammonium was at or close to the detection limit in experimental and blank abiotic-oxic incubations (Fig 2B).

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Fig 2. Ammonium (NH4+) and dissolved organic nitrogen (DON) concentrations in experimental (NO3- spiked) and blank (no NO3- spiked) incubations under four sets of conditions.

Error bars represent standard deviation of duplicate values.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0218752.g002

Under biotic-anoxic conditions, DON concentrations in the blank incubation increased during the first ~50 h when a plateau was reached but remained constant in the experimental incubation (Fig 2C). Ammonium increased in both the blank and experimental biotic-anoxic incubations; but the NH4+ increase in the experimental system was twice that in the blank at the end of incubation (Fig 2C). In contrast, the blank and experimental abiotic-anoxic incubations showed a decrease in DON concentration and the greatest increase in NH4+ concentration among all systems (Fig 2D). The magnitude of NH4+ increase and DON decrease in the experimental abiotic-anoxic incubation are comparable to those in its blank incubation.

Nitrogen immobilization

Nitrogen immobilization in solid-phase leaf compost (Fig 3) fluctuated with time in the biotic-oxic incubation with an average of 6.2 μg 15N per g leaf compost. In the abiotic-oxic incubation, N immobilization increased slightly over time, with ~80% of the immobilization completed within 30 min of incubation. Thus, N was immobilized rapidly by organic matter under oxic conditions. If N immobilization in the biotic-oxic system is considered a combined result of biotic and abiotic processes, then the difference in magnitude between N immobilization in the biotic-oxic system and that in the abiotic-oxic system can be regarded as the magnitude of biotic N immobilization. As derived from the data shown in Fig 3A, under oxic conditions, ~66% of the overall N immobilization can be attributed to abiotic processes.

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Fig 3.

Nitrogen immobilization in biotic and abiotic systems under oxic (a) and anoxic (b) conditions. Error bars represent standard deviation of duplicate values.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0218752.g003

In contrast to oxic incubations, N immobilization proceeded gradually in the biotic-anoxic and abiotic-anoxic incubations (Fig 3B). N immobilization reached a plateau of ~6.0 μg 15N per g leaf compost at ~60 h, the time when NO3- and NO2- concentrations had dropped to zero. The similarity in NO3- reduction dynamics (Fig 1B) and N immobilization (Fig 3B) between the biotic-anoxic and abiotic-anoxic systems suggest abiotic processes dominate NO3- transformation under anoxic condition with 100% of the overall N immobilization attributed to abiotic processes. About 0.8% of the added 15N-NO3- was retained in solid leaf compost in the experimental biotic-anoxic and abiotic-anoxic systems, and NO3- was not converted to DON as evidenced by 15N isotope measurements (Table A in S1 File). By mass balance, it can be concluded that the majority of the spiked 15N-NO3- was either reduced to gaseous N (lost from the system) or to NH4+ (remained in the system) under anoxic conditions.

We attempted to identify N species resulting from N immobilization processes using CP MAS 15N-NMR (Figure A in S1 File and Tables B and C in S1 File). Although the results are somewhat inconclusive (signal to noise ratios equal to or greater than 3:1 are desirable), they suggest new 15N (from 15N-NO3- addition) was immobilized in the LC (i.e., a signal was present in experimental incubations while no signal was detected in blank incubations). 15N-NMR spectra suggest the formation of amine-N under oxic conditions whereas under anoxic conditions the dominant N species seem to be amide/aminoquinones and nitro/oxime [(R-NO2)/(R1(R/H)2C = NOH)] (see discussion in S1 File). These results suggest additional studies on the formation of organic N species, perhaps utilizing more challenging NMR experiments, are warranted.

Discussion

Nitrate transformation pathways

Transformation pathways for NO3- under the four incubation conditions are presented schematically in Fig 4. Our results indicate both redox and abiotic conditions govern the dynamics of NO3- transformations in organic matter systems. Specifically, oxic incubations indicate that 15NO3- was not recovered in the NH4+ pool; the dominant pathway for NO3- transformation is conversion to DON, accounting for 20 and 17% of the spiked 15NO3- in biotic-oxic and γ-irradiated abiotic-oxic systems, respectively (Table A in S1 File, Fig 4). Hence, under oxic conditions NO3- is more prone to being incorporated abiotically into DOM than into SOM when incubations were conducted in suspension. A similar trend was also found in several studies [15,20,34]. Davidson et al. (2003) [25] proposed that NO3- is first reduced to NO2- prior to its incorporation into DOM. Their hypothesis is based on the results of two discrete experiments. The first experiment showed nitrate reduction by Fe(II) in the presence of a Cu catalyst under anoxic conditions; the second experiment showed nitrite incorporation into dissolved organic matter (i.e., solutions of several organic compounds). In the first experiment, a decrease in nitrate concentration with time, not an increase in nitrite concentration, was measured; therefore, it was not demonstrated that NO2- is the intermediary between NO3- and DOM. In addition, Schmidt and Matzner (2009) [45] showed that NO2- transformation to DOM under oxic conditions did not occur after NO2- was added to sterilized DOM. Matus et al. (2019) [23] however demonstrated that under abiotic-anoxic conditions, and in the presence of Fe2+, DOM reacts with NO3- to form DON. Based on our experimental results we cannot confirm nor completely refute whether NO3- was reduced to NO2- under the oxic conditions in which NO3- was converted to DOM (NO2- was not detected in oxic incubations at values above 1 μM). However, we can use the Nernst equation to calculate the theoretical concentration of nitrite (NO2-) that would result from the NO3-/NO2- redox couple: ½ NO3- + H+ + e- → ½ NO2- + ½ H2O (Eho = 0.834 V). With parameter values of pH = 6.5, Eh = 500 mV and [NO3-] = 200 μM (i.e., NO3- initially added), we calculated [NO2-] = 4.1 μM, which is above our detection limit of 1 μM. Higher NO2- concentrations are expected at lower redox potentials whereas lower NO2- concentrations are expected at higher redox potentials. Our oxic incubations, with a redox potential of ~300 mV, should have in theory resulted in a nitrite concentration of 199 μM, a concentration easily detectable. Therefore, the conversion of NO3- to DOM that we observed in experiments conducted under oxic conditions does not seem to follow the path hypothesized by Davidson et al. (2003) [25]. Although NO2- was not detected, it is possible the kinetics of NO2- consumption were as fast (or faster) than those of NO2- production, which would have prevented NO2- accumulation in the system. A potential pathway is that NO3- undergoes an electrophilic aromatic substitution (aromatic nitration) in which a nitro group (R-NO2) is introduced into an organic chemical compound. Yet, we do not have conclusive evidence in support of this reaction as a legitimate possibility. Recent studies have demonstrated that UV irradiation effects the incorporation of nitrate and nitrite into natural organic matter via nitration and nitrosation yielding a variety of organic-N functionalities [50]. These reactions present additional evidence in support of abiotic pathways leading to the incorporation of inorganic N species into organic matter [51].

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

Fig 4. Schematic representation of 15N-NO3- transformation pathways as affected by incubation conditions.

Percentage values indicate the amount of the initial 15N-NO3- added (750 μg 15N / g LC) that partitioned into specific N species. Note: since no change in 15N was detected in the NH4+ pool of oxic incubations (Table A in S1 File), it is possible the remaining N label (~6.6% in biotic-oxic and ~14.9% in abiotic-oxic incubations) could have transformed to gaseous N species under oxic conditions [1,2].

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0218752.g004

Under anoxic conditions, all of the spiked 15N-NO3- was transformed within 24 h (Fig 1B). About 8.6% of the spiked 15N-NO3- was recovered as 15N-NH4+ (Table A in S1 File, Fig 4) by the end of the biotic-anoxic and γ-irradiated abiotic-anoxic system incubations, with no 15N recovery in the DOM pool. Given that ~0.8% of 15N-NO3- was immobilized into SOM and that relatively large concentrations of NO2- were detected in anoxic incubations, we infer ~90% of the spiked 15N-NO3- was reduced to gaseous N species. Our inference is supported by the work of Zhang et al. (2010) [34] in which the authors found that up to 51% of the spiked NO3- was converted to N2 gas when NO3- was incubated with forest soils anaerobically. Although gaseous N species were not measured in this study, the low Eh (-330 mV) in all anoxic incubations suggests a very low oxygen level conducive to N2 gas production.

Although Fe(II) is expected to play a role in NO3- reduction, the results from biotic-oxic incubations show the addition of NO3- had no influence on Fe(II) concentrations (Fig 1C), therefore indicating Fe(II) did not act as an electron source in biotic-oxic incubations (but perhaps as a catalyst). However, the addition of nitrate under anoxic conditions affected Fe(II) concentrations. Fe(II) concentrations were consistently lower in experimental compared to blank anoxic incubations (except at 120 h) suggesting Fe(II) was directly involved in NO3- reduction (Fig 1D). These findings lend support for Davidson’s hypothesis that postulates NO3- reduction by Fe2+ under anoxic conditions [25]. Potential electron sources that would support NO3- reduction under anoxic conditions are reducing organic functional groups and Fe(II) present in the leaf compost (Fe(II) = 1.2 g Fe(II)/kg = 21.5 μmole Fe(II)/g = 43 μmole Fe(II) in reaction vessel; total Fe = 4.8 g Fe/kg = 85.9 μmole Fe/g = 171.8 μmole Fe in reaction vessel). Since 100 μmole NO3- were added to each experimental incubation, and given the fact that all of the added NO3- was transformed (reduced) to other species under anoxic conditions, reduction of NO3- to NO2- alone would require 100 μmole of electrons. Using the concentration of NO3- (~100 μM in solution), NO2- (~40 μM in solution) and Fe(II) (~4 μmole Fe(II)/g = difference between blank and experimental values) at 8 h in biotic-anoxic incubations, and our experimental parameters (2 g LC in 500 ml suspension), we calculate that ~50 μmole of NO3- were consumed, ~20 μmole of NO2- were produced and that Fe(II) was reduced by ~8 μmole in experimental compared to blank incubations. These calculations indicate Fe(II) provided electrons for NO3- reduction but was not the sole electron source for NO3- reduction in anoxic incubations, otherwise the Fe(II) concentration would have decreased considerably more. If Fe(II) had served as a catalyst (i.e., a substance that increases the rate of a chemical reaction without itself undergoing any permanent chemical change), the reduction of NO3- to NO2- would take place but the concentration of Fe(II) would remain constant. We suggest organic matter (i.e., LC in this work) provided electrons for NO3- reduction. Some studies have found that the rate of denitrification is highly correlated to DOC concentration in groundwater [52,53], suggesting microorganisms may prefer DOC over solid organic C (SOM) as the electron source to fuel denitrification. In this study, experimental and blank DOC concentrations in biotic-anoxic systems increased with time, independent of nitrate addition (Figure B in S1 File), thus suggesting the LC may have served as an additional electron source for NO3- reduction in anoxic incubations.

Nitrogen source for ammonium production

15N-NO3- was not recovered in the NH4+ pool of the experimental oxic systems which implies 15N-NO3- was not directly or indirectly converted to NH4+. The contrast in NH4+ production between the biotic-oxic and γ-irradiated abiotic-oxic systems (Fig 2A and 2B) indicate microbial activity was required for NH4+ production. Production of NH4+ can be explained by classic theory, namely, microbial generation of low molecular weight organics from solid-phase OM using extracellular enzymes, and organic N assimilation followed by NH4+ excretion [54,55]. The fact that NH4+ was not labeled but DON in the experimental biotic-oxic system was highly enriched in 15N due to 15N-NO3- conversion to DON is striking (Table A in S1 File). Although microbial utilization of non-labeled DON might be coincidental, we speculate microbes could release enzymes that convert solid phase OM into NH4+ (e.g., enzymes that cleave amino groups from proteinaceous material). The addition of NO3- did not seem to influence the outcome of microbial NH4+ production, as evidenced from the fact that the same amount of NH4+ was produced in experimental and blank oxic incubations. Schmidt et al. (2011) [56] also found that NO3- addition exerted no impact on the rate of DOM microbial mineralization.

As mentioned above, NH4+ produced in the experimental biotic-anoxic incubation was twice that in the blank (Fig 2C). This additional NH4+ production can be attributed to two processes, one of which is 15N-NO3- reduction to 15N-NH4+ as confirmed by increased 15N enrichment in the NH4+ pool (Table A in S1 File). We cannot confirm, however, whether the reduction was a biotic or abiotic process. Our calculation indicates that ~8.7% of the spiked 15N-NO3- was reduced to 15N-NH4+ (Table A in S1 File, Fig 4), accounting for ~14% of the total NH4+ production. Besides differences in NH4+ production, the experimental and blank biotic-anoxic systems also differ in DON production: DON concentration remained unchanged in the experimental biotic-anoxic incubation but increased in the blank. This suggests DON was mineralized (reduced) to NH4+ in the experimental biotic-anoxic system but not in the blank. A potential explanation for such difference is that DON mineralization under anoxic conditions was a microbially-driven process enhanced in the experimental incubation due to NO3- addition. 15N-NO3- was also reduced to 15N-NH4+ (~8.6%) in the experimental γ-irradiated abiotic-anoxic system (Table A in S1 File, Fig 4), accounting for ~10% of the total NH4+ production (Fig 2D). The remaining NH4+ production in experimental as well as blank γ-irradiated abiotic-anoxic incubations should be attributed to organic nitrogen chemical reduction. In these γ-irradiated anoxic systems, since a decrease in DON was associated with an increase in NH4+ production, it is most reasonable to conclude that DON was chemically reduced to NH4+ under abiotic-anoxic conditions.

Magnitude of nitrogen immobilization within SOM

The magnitude of N immobilization within SOM ranged from 4.1 to 6.6 μg 15N per g LC, accounting for 0.6–0.9% of the total added 15N. Nitrogen immobilization, expressed as percentage, appears to be lower than figures reported in similar studies. Dail et al. (2001) [15] and Fitzhugh et al. (2003) [20] reported that 5–10% of the total added 15N-NO3- (4–5 μg 15N per g soil) was immobilized by live or sterilized O-horizon forest soils; such immobilization translates to a magnitude less than 1 μg 15N per g soil. Thus, our seemingly low % N immobilization by leaf compost can simply be explained by the larger total 15N-NO3- input. Moreover, using a N immobilization value of 6.5 μg N g-1 leaf compost and a density of 1 g cm-3, we calculate 5.2 kg N ha-1 would be immobilized (stored) within an organic matter layer 8 cm in thickness (e.g., O-horizon of a forest soil). The amount of N stored within SOM would be 3.2 kg N ha-1 using an N immobilization value of 4 μg N g-1 leaf compost. Our estimates of N immobilization help to explain, at least in part, the observed decline in N export in some forest ecosystems [57].

As NO3- input from fossil fuel combustion and fertilizer application continues to bypass the natural N cycle, changes in climatic conditions (e.g., frequency and intensity of precipitation that affects redox gradients and microbial growth rates and metabolism) might enhance the prevalence of abiotic transformations (i.e., chemical processes) that shift pathways and N species concentrations from those controlled by biota.

Supporting information

[Figure omitted. See PDF.]

S1 File.

(Table A) Changes in 15N atom % in four N pools after 5-day incubation under a factorial of biotic/abiotic and oxic/anoxic conditions. (Table B) Compilation of 15N solid-state NMR data collection parameters used by referenced publications and in the current study. (Table C) Peak assignment for signals of solid-state CP/MAS 15N NMR. (Figure A) Solid-state CP MAS 15N NMR spectra of leaf compost after incubation with 15N labeled NO3- in Oxic (a) and Anoxic (b) systems. The spectra of the blank (rinsed, no NO3- addition) leaf compost (c, e) and of the original (non-rinsed, no NO3- addition) leaf compost (d, f) are also shown. Contact times (CT) of 2 ms and 5 ms were used in data collection as indicated in each panel. (Figure B) Nitrate (NO3-) and dissolved organic carbon (DOC) concentrations in experimental (NO3- spiked) and blank incubations under biotic-anoxic (a) and abiotic-anoxic (b) conditions. Initial NO3- concentration was 200 μM. Error bars represent standard deviation of duplicate values. Note left y-axis pertains to NO3- data and right y-axis pertains to DOC data. (Figure C) Measured NO3- concentration (y-axis) in solutions containing 10, 25, 80 and 200 μM NO3- and each containing 0, 1, 5, 10, 50, 100, 400 and 800 μM Fe2+. The 1:1 actual:measured NO3- concentration is represented by the solid line. Symbols represent all data points (average of 3 experimental replicates) for 200 (black circles), 80 (red squares), 25 (blue triangles) and 10 (pink diamonds) μM NO3- concentrations. (Figure D) Measured NO3- concentration in solutions containing 10, 25, 80 and 200 μM NO3- in the presence of 0, 1, 5, 10, 50, 100, 400 and 800 μM Fe2+. Dashed horizontal lines represent actual NO3- concentrations. Symbols represent measured NO3- concentrations (average of three experimental replicates) and error bars their standard deviation (200, circles; 80, squares; 25, triangles; 10, diamonds). (A) shows all of the data; for clarity (B) presents an expanded x-axis with results for 0–10 μM Fe2+. (Figure E) Sequence of reactions involved in the analytical method used for the determination of NO3- concentrations.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0218752.s001

(DOCX)

Acknowledgments

The authors thank Dr. Benesi and Dr. Hatzakis for their assistance with NMR data collection and Dr. Govere for his assistance with DOC analyses.

Citation: Kizewski FR, Kaye JP, Martínez CE (2019) Nitrate transformation and immobilization in particulate organic matter incubations: Influence of redox, iron and (a)biotic conditions. PLoS ONE 14(7): e0218752. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0218752

References

1. Wei J, Amelung W, Lehndorff E, Schloter M, Vereecken H, Brüggemann N. N2O and NOx emissions by reactions of nitrite with soil organic matter of a Norway spruce forest. Biogeochemistry 2017; 132: 325–342.

2. Qin S, Pang Y, Clough T, Wrage-Mönnig N, Hu C, Zhang Y, et al. N2 production via aerobic pathways may play a significant role in nitrogen cycling in upland soils. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 2017; 108: 36–40.

3. Phillips RL, Song B, McMillan AMS, Grelet G, Weir BS, Palmada T, et al. Chemical formation of hybrid di-nitrogen calls fungal codenitrification into question. Scientific Reports 2016; 6: 39077. pmid:27976694

4. Nelson DW, Bremner JM. Factors affecting chemical transformations of nitrite in soils. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 1969; 1: 229–239.

5. Doane TA. The abiotic nitrogen cycle. ACS Earth and Space Chemistry 2017; 1: 411–421.

6. Nadelhoffer KJ, Downs MR, Fry B, Sinks for N-15-enriched additions to an oak forest and a red pine plantation. Ecological Applications 1999; 9: 72–86.

7. Gundersen P, Emmett BA, Kjonaas OJ, Koopmans CJ, Tietema A. Impact of nitrogen deposition on nitrogen cycling in forests: a synthesis of NITREX data. Forest Ecology and Management 1998; 101: 1–3.

8. Nadelhoffer KJ, Emmett BA, Gundersen P, Kjonaas OJ, Koopmans CJ, Schleppi P, et al. Nitrogen deposition makes a minor contribution to carbon sequestration in temperate forests. Nature 1999; 398: 145–148.

9. Buchmann N, Gebauer G, Schulze ED. Partitioning of N-15-labeled ammonium and nitrate among soil, litter, below- and above-ground biomass of trees and understory in a 15-year-old Picea abies plantation. Biogeochemistry 1996; 33: 1–23.

10. Providoli I, Bugmann H, Siegwolf R, Buchmann N, Schleppi P. Pathways and dynamics of (NO3-)-N-15 and (NH4+)-N-15 applied in a mountain Picea abies forest and in a nearby meadow in central Switzerland. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 2006; 38: 1645–1657.

11. Huygens D, Boeckx P, Templer P, Paulino L, Van Cleemput O, Oyarzun C, et al. Mechanisms for retention of bioavailable nitrogen in volcanic rainforest soils. Nature Geoscience 2008; 1: 543–548.

12. Davidson EA, Hart SC, Firestone MK. Internal cycling of nitrate in soils of a mature coniferous forest. Ecology 1992; 73: 1148–1156.

13. Schimel JP, Firestone MK. Nitrogen incorporation and flow through a coniferous forest soil profile. Soil Science Society of America Journal 1989; 53: 779–784.

14. Berntson GM, Aber JD. Fast nitrate immobilization in N saturated temperate forest soils. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 2000; 32: 151–156.

15. Dail DB, Davidson EA, Chorover J. Rapid abiotic transformation of nitrate in an acid forest soil. Biogeochemistry 2001; 54: 131–146.

16. Davidson EA, Hart SC, Shanks CA, Firestone MK. Measuring gross nitrogen mineralization, immobilization, and nitrification by N-15 isotopic pool dilution in intact soil cores. Journal of Soil Science 1991; 42: 335–349.

17. Schimel DS. Calculation of microbial-growth efficiency from N-15 immobilization. Biogeochemistry 1988; 6: 239–243.

18. Aber J, McDowell W, Nadelhoffer K, Magill A, Berntson G, Kamakea M, et al. Nitrogen saturation in temperate forest ecosystems—Hypotheses revisited. Bioscience 1998; 48: 921–934.

19. Johnson DW, Cheng W, Burke IC. Biotic and abiotic nitrogen retention in a variety of forest soils. Soil Science Society of America Journal 2000; 64: 1503–1514.

20. Fitzhugh RD, Lovett GM, Venterea RT. Biotic and abiotic immobilization of ammonium, nitrite, and nitrate in soils developed under different tree species in the Catskill Mountains, New York, USA. Global Change Biology 2003; 9: 1591–1601.

21. Morier I, Schleppi P, Siegwolf R, Knicker H, Guenat C. 15N immobilization in forest soil: a sterilization experiment coupled with 15CPMAS NMR spectroscopy. European Journal of Soil Science 2008; 59: 467–475.

22. Miyajima T. Abiotic versus biotic immobilization of inorganic nitrogen in sediment as a potential pathway of nitrogen sequestration from coastal marine ecosystems. Geochemical Journal 2015; 49: 453–468.

23. Matus F, Stock S, Eschenbach W, Dyckmans J, Merino C, Nájera F, et al. Ferrous wheel hypothesis: Abiotic nitrate incorporation into dissolved organic matter. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 2019; 245: 514–524.

24. Colman BP, Fierer N, Schimel JP. Abiotic nitrate incorporation in soil: is it real? Biogeochemistry 2007; 84: 161–169.

25. Davidson EA, Chorover J, Dail DB. A mechanism of abiotic immobilization of nitrate in forest ecosystems: the ferrous wheel hypothesis. Global Change Biology 2003; 9: 228–236.

26. Ottley CL, Davison W, Edmunds WM. Chemical catalysis of nitrate reduction by iron(II). Geochimica Et Cosmochimica Acta 1997; 61: 1819–1828.

27. Buresh RJ, Moraghan JT. Chemical reduction of nitrate by ferrous iron. Journal of Environmental Quality 1976; 5: 320–325.

28. Korom SF. Natural denitrification in the saturated zone—a review. Water Resources Research 1992; 28: 1657–1668.

29. Hardison AK, Algar CK, Giblin AE, Rich JJ. Influence of organic carbon and nitrate loading on partitioning between dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium (DNRA) and N2 production. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 2015; 164: 146–160.

30. Perakis SS, Compton JE, Hedin LO. Nitrogen retention across a gradient of N-15 additions to an unpolluted temperate forest soil in Chile. Ecology 2005; 86: 96–105.

31. Vega-Jarquin C, Garcia-Mendoza M, Jablonowski N, Luna-Guido M, Dendooven L. Rapid immobilization of applied nitrogen in saline-alkaline soils. Plant and Soil 2003; 256: 379–388.

32. Perakis SS, Hedin LO. Nitrogen loss from unpolluted South American forests mainly via dissolved organic compounds. Nature 2002; 415: 416–419. pmid:11807551

33. Huygens D, Ruetting T, Boeckx P, Van Cleemput O, Godoy R, Mueller C. Soil nitrogen conservation mechanisms in a pristine south Chilean Nothofagus forest ecosystem. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 2007; 39: 2448–2458.

34. Zhang JB, Cai ZC, Cheng Y, Zhu TB. Nitrate Immobilization in Anaerobic Forest Soils along a North-South Transect in East China. Soil Science Society of America Journal 2010; 74: 1193–1200.

35. Stevenson FJ, Cole MA. Cycles of Soil: Carbon, Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Sulfur, Micronutrients. Second Edition ed.; John Wiley & Sons, Inc.; 1999.

36. Olk DC, Cassman KG, Schmidt-Rohr K, Anders MM, Mao JD, Deenik JL. Chemical stabilization of soil organic nitrogen by phenolic lignin residues in anaerobic agroecosystems. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 2006; 38: 3303–3312.

37. Abe T, Watanabe A. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy of nitrogen functional groups in soil humic acids. Soil Science 2004; 169: 35–43.

38. Jokic A, Cutler JN, Anderson DW, Walley FL. Detection of heterocyclic N compounds in whole soils using N-XANES spectroscopy. Canadian Journal of Soil Science 2004; 84: 291–293.

39. Maie N, Parish KJ, Watanabe A, Knicker H, Benner R, Abe T, et al. Chemical characteristics of dissolved organic nitrogen in an oligotrophic subtropical coastal ecosystem. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 2006; 70: 4491–4506.

40. Myneni SCB. Soft X-ray spectroscopy and spectromicroscopy studies of organic molecules in the environment. Applications of Synchrotron Radiation in Low-Temperature Geochemistry and Environmental Sciences Volume 49; 2002.

41. Vairavamurthy A, Wang S. Organic nitrogen in geomacromolecules: Insights on speciation and transformation with K-edge XANES spectroscopy. Environmental Science & Technology 2002; 36: 3050–3056.

42. Leinweber P, Kruse J, Baum C, Arcand M, Knight JD, Farrell R, et al. Advances in Understanding Organic Nitrogen Chemistry in Soils Using State-of-the-art Analytical Techniques. Advances in Agronomy 2013; 119: 83–151.

43. Schmidt-Rohr K, Mao JD, Olk DC. Nitrogen-bonded aromatics in soil organic matter and their implications for a yield decline in intensive rice cropping. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2004; 101: 6351–6354. pmid:15096605

44. Schulten HR, Hempfling R. Influence of agricultural soil management on humus composition and dynamics–classical and modern analytical techniques. Plant and Soil 1992; 142: 259–271.

45. Schmidt BHM, Matzner E. Abiotic reaction of nitrite with dissolved organic carbon? Testing the Ferrous Wheel Hypothesis. Biogeochemistry 2009; 93: 291–296.

46. Sauvé S, Martínez CE, McBride M, Hendershot W. Adsorption of free lead (Pb2+) by pedogenic oxides, ferrihydrite, and leaf compost. Soil Science Society of America Journal 2000; 64: 595–599.

47. Paul EA, Clark FE. Soil Microbiology and Biochemistry. Academic Press: San Diego, CA; 1996.

48. Stark JM, Hart SC. Diffusion technique for preparing salt solutions, Kjeldahl digests, and persulfate digests for nitrogen-15 analysis. Soil Science Society of America Journal 1996; 60: 1846–1855.

49. Fry B. Stable Isotope Ecology. Springer: New York, NY USA; 2006.

50. Thorn KA, Cox LG. Ultraviolet irradiation effects incorporation of nitrate and nitrite nitrogen into aquatic natural organic matter. Journal of Environmental Quality 2012; 41: 865–881. pmid:22565268

51. Heil J, Vereecken H, Brüggemann N. A review of chemical reactions of nitrification intermediates and their role in nitrogen cycling and nitrogen trace gas formation in soil. European Journal of Soil Science 2016; 67: 23–39.

52. Pabich WJ, Valiela I, Hemond HF. Relationship between DOC concentration and vadose zone thickness and depth below water table in groundwater of Cape Cod, USA. Biogeochemistry 2001; 55: 247–268.

53. Zarnetske JP, Haggerty R, Wondzell SM, Baker MA. Labile dissolved organic carbon supply limits hyporheic denitrification. Journal of Geophysical Research-Biogeosciences 2011; 116: G04036.

54. Schimel JP, Bennett J. Nitrogen mineralization: Challenges of a changing paradigm. Ecology 2004; 85: 591–602.

55. Geisseler D, Horwath WR, Joergensen RG, Ludwig B. Pathways of nitrogen utilization by soil microorganisms—A review. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 2010; 42: 2058–2067.

56. Schmidt BHM, Kalbitz K, Braun S, Fuss R, McDowell WH, Matzner E. Microbial immobilization and mineralization of dissolved organic nitrogen from forest floors. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 2011; 43: 1742–1745.

57. Bernal S, Hedin LO, Likens GE, Gerber S, Buso DC. Complex response of the forest nitrogen cycle to climate change. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2012; 109: 3406–3411. pmid:22331889