“My mother told me that I should not”: a qualitative study exploring the restrictions placed on adolescent girls living with HIV in Zambia

Abstract

Introduction

Adolescent girls in sub-Saharan Africa are disproportionately affected by HIV due to a range of social and structural factors. As they transition to adulthood, they are recipients of increasing blame for HIV infection and ‘improper’ sex, as well as increasing scrutiny, restrictions and surveillance. This study used a qualitative and participatory approach to explore the messaging and restrictions imposed on adolescent girls living with HIV in Zambia.

Methods

Thirty-four in-depth interviews and four participatory workshops were carried out with 24 adolescent girls aged 15 to 19 years old living with HIV in Lusaka, Zambia. Key themes explored included experiences living with HIV, finding out about HIV status, disclosure, experiences with antiretroviral treatment, and support needs. Data were organized, coded and analysed using a grounded theory approach to thematic analysis. This analysis uses data on participants’ experiences of living with HIV and their interactions with their parents, guardians and healthcare providers.

Results

Family and healthcare providers, partly in a quest to protect both the health of adolescent girls living with HIV and also to protect them from blaming discourse, imposed restrictions on their behaviour around three main topics: don't disclose your HIV status, don't have sex, and don't miss your medicines. These restrictions were often delivered using tactics of fear, and usually disconnected from other options. Participants responded to these messages in several ways, including internalizing the messages, changing their behaviour either to comply with or resist the restrictions, by remaining silent and anxious when restrictions were broken, and developing concerns around their own health and sexual and reproductive aspirations. Participants also sometimes experiencing stigma when restrictions could not be maintained.

Conclusions

Restrictive messages were delivered to adolescent girls living with HIV through the broader social discourses of stigma, religion, and global and local narratives about HIV. Programmes aiming to support adolescent girls living with HIV need to work together with parents and healthcare providers to reflect on the impact of sanctioning messages, and to encourage more enabling and empowering messaging for adolescent girls living with HIV.

References Patton G, Sawyer S, Santelli J, Ross D, Afifi R, Allen N, et al. Our future: a Lancet commission on adolescent health and wellbeing. Lancet. 2016;387(10036):2423–78. Dellar RC, Dlamini S, Karim QA. Adolescent girls and young women: key populations for HIV epidemic control. J Int AIDS Soc. 2015;18(2 Suppl 1):19408. PEPFAR, Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, Girl Effect, Johnson & Johnson. DREAMS: working together for an aids-free future for girls and women. 2015. Chandra-Mouli V, Armstrong A, Amin A, Ferguson J. A pressing need to respond to the needs and sexual and reproductive health problems of adolescent girls living with HIV in low- and middle-income countries. J Int AIDS Soc. 2015;18 (Suppl 5):20297. Mofenson L, Cotton F. The challenges of success: adolescents with perinatal HIV infection. JIAS. 2013;16(18650):1–3. Bernays S, Jarrett P, Kranzer K, Ferrand RA. Children growing up with HIV infection: the responsibility of success. Lancet. 2014;383(9925):1355–7. Santelli JS, Edelstein ZR, Wei Y, Mathur S, Song X, Schuyler A, et al. Trends in HIV acquisition, risk factors and prevention policies among youth in Uganda, 1999-2011. AIDS. 2015;29(2):211–9. Santelli JSEZ, Mathur S, Wei Y, Zhang W, Orr MG, Higgins JA, et al. Behavioral, biological, and demographic risk and protective factors for new HIV infections among youth in Rakai, Uganda. JAIDS. 2013;63(3):393–400. Abdool Karim Q, Kharsany A, Frohlich J, Werner L, Mlotshwa M, Madlala B, et al. HIV incidence in young girls in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa-Public health imperative for their inclusion in HIV biomedical intervention trials. AIDS Behav. 2013;16(7):1870–18876. De Schacht C, Mabunda N, Ferreira O, Ismael N, Calú N, Santos I, et al. High HIV incidence in the postpartum period sustains vertical transmission in settings with generalized epidemics: a cohort study in Southern Mozambique. J Int AIDS Soc. 2014;17:18808. Vandormael A, Newell ML, Barnighausen T, Tanser F. Use of antiretroviral therapy in households and risk of HIV acquisition in rural KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa, 2004-12: a prospective cohort study. Lancet Global Health. 2014;2(4):e209–15. UNAIDS. All in to end adolescent AIDS: Zambia. Geneva, Switzerland: UNAIDS; 2015. UNAIDS. An ambitious treatment target to help end the AIDS epidemic. Geneva: UNAIDS; 2014. National AIDS Council. Zambia Country Report: Monitoring the Declaration of Commitment on HIV and AIDS and the Universal Access. 2014. Winskell K, Hill E, Obyerodhyambo O. Comparing HIV-related symbolic stigma in six African countries: social representations in young people's narratives. Soc Sci Med. 2011;73(8):1257–65. Parsons JA, Bond VA, Nixon SA. ‘Are We Not Human?’ stories of stigma, disability and HIV from Lusaka, Zambia and their implications for access to health services. PLoS ONE. 2015;10(6):e0127392. Bond V, Chilikwela L, Clay S, Kafuma T, Nyblade L, Bettega N. Kanayaka “The lights is on”: understanding HIV and AIDS related stigma in urban and rural Zambia. Zambia: Zambart Project and Int Centre Res Women; 2003. Vale B, Hodes R, Cluver L. Negotiations of blame and care among HIV-positive mothers and daughters in South Africa's Eastern Cape. Med Anthropol Q. 2017. https://doi.org/10.1111/maq.12351. Vale B, Thabeng M. Redeeming lost mothers: adolescent antiretroviral treatment and the making of home in South Africa. Med Anthropol. 2016;35(6):489–502. Bond V, Hoddinott G, Viljoen L, Simuyaba M, Musheke M, Seeley J. Good health and moral responsibility: key concepts underlying the interpretation of treatment as prevention in South Africa and Zambia before rolling out universal HIV testing and treatment. AIDS Patient Care STDS. 2016;30(9):425–34. Roura M, Nsigaye R, Nhandi B, Wamoyi J, Busza J, Urassa M, et al. “Driving the devil away”: qualitative insights into miraculous cures for AIDS in a rural Tanzanian ward. BMC Public Health. 2010;10:427. Reynolds P. Dance civet cat: child labour in the Zambezi valley. Scott Quadrangle, University of Ohio, Athens, Ohio 45701: Ohio University Press; 1991. Wamoyi J, Wight D. ‘Mum never loved me’. How structural factors influence adolescent sexual and reproductive health through parent-child connectedness: a qualitative study in rural Tanzania. Afr J AIDS Res. 2014;13(2):169–78. Wamoyi J, Fenwick A, Urassa M, Zaba B, Stones W. Parental control and monitoring of young people's sexual behaviour in rural North-Western Tanzania: implications for sexual and reproductive health interventions. BMC Public Health. 2011;11:106. Philbin MM. “What I got to go through”: normalization and HIV-positive adolescents. Med Anthropol. 2014;33(4):288–302. Busza J, Dauya E, Bandason T, Mujuru H, Ferrand RA. “I don't want financial support but verbal support”. How do caregivers manage children's access to and retention in HIV care in urban Zimbabwe?. J Int AIDS Soc. 2014;17:18839. Trochim WM. Pattern matching, validity, and conceptualization in program evaluation. Evaluation Rev. 1985;9:575–604. Butler-Kisber L, Poldma T. The power of visual approaches in qualitative inquiry: the use of collage making and concept mapping in experiential research. J Res Pract. 2010;6(2):M18. Gourlay A, Mshana G, Birdthistle I, Bulugu G, Zaba B, Urassa M. Using vignettes in qualitative research to explore barriers and facilitating factors to the uptake of prevention of mother-to-child transmission services in rural Tanzania: a critical analysis. BMC Med Res Methodol. 2014;14:21. Wallman S. Eight London households. London & New York: Tavistock Publications; 1984. Bond VA. “It is not an easy decision on HIV, especially in Zambia”: opting for silence, limited disclosure and implicit understanding to retain a wider identity. AIDS Care. 2010;22 (Suppl 1):6–13. Denison JA, Banda H, Dennis AC, Packer C, Nyambe N, Stalter RM, et al. “The sky is the limit”: adhering to antiretroviral therapy and HIV self-management from the perspectives of adolescents living with HIV and their adult caregivers. J Int AIDS Soc. 2015;18:19358. Shanaube K, Schapp A, Chaila MJ, Mackworth-Young C, Floyd S, Hoddinott G, et al. Community intervention improves knowledge of HIV status of adolescents in Zambia: findings from an adolescent sub-study of the HPTN 071(PopART) study AIDS. Under review. Simpson A, Bond V. Narratives of nationhood and HIV/AIDS: reflections on multidisciplinary research on the HIV/AIDS epidemic in Zambia over the last 30 years. J South Afr Stud. 2014;40(5):1065–89. Winskell K, Beres L, Hill E, Chigozie Mbakwem B, Obyerodhyambo O. Making sense of abstinence: social representations in young Africans’ HIV-related narratives from six countries. Cult Health Sex. 2011;13(8):945–59. Busza J, Besana GV, Mapunda P, Oliveras E. “I have grown up controlling myself a lot”. Fear and misconceptions about sex among adolescents vertically-infected with HIV in Tanzania. Reprod Health Matters. 2013;21(41):87–96. Fernet M, Wong K, Richard ME, Otis J, Levy JJ, Lapointe N, et al. Romantic relationships and sexual activities of the first generation of youth living with HIV since birth. AIDS Care. 2011;23(4):393–400. UNAIDS. No adolescent living with HIV left behind: a coalition for action. Geneva, Switzerland: UNAIDS; 2014. WHO. Guideline on when to start antiretroviral therapy and on pre-exposure prophylaxis for HIV. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO; 2015. Vujovic M, Struthers H, Meyersfeld S, Dlamini K, Mabizela N. Addressing the sexual and reproductive health needs of young adolescents living with HIV in South Africa. Child Youth Serv Rev. 2014;45:122–8. Bernays S, Paparini S, Gibb D, Seeley J. When information does not suffice: young people living with HIV and communication about ART adherence in the clinic. Vulnerable Child Youth Stud. 2016;11(1):60–8. Bernays S, Seeley J, Rhodes T, Mupambireyi Z. What am I ‘living’ with? growing up with HIV in Uganda and Zimbabwe. Sociol Health Illn. 2015;37(2):270–83. Mupambireyi Z, Bernays S, Bwakura-Dangarembizi M, Cowan FM. “I don't feel shy because I will be among others who are just like me.”: the role of support groups for children perinatally infected with HIV in Zimbabwe. Child Youth Serv Rev. 2014;45:106–13. Bernays S, Paparini S, Seeley J, Rhodes T. ‘not taking it will just be like a sin’: young people living with HIV and the stigmatization of less-than-perfect adherence to antiretroviral therapy. Med Anthropol. 2017;18:1–15. Fetzer BC, Mupenda B, Lusiama J, Kitetele F, Golin C, Behets F. Barriers to and facilitators of adherence to pediatric antiretroviral therapy in a sub-Saharan setting: insights from a qualitative study. AIDS Patient Care STDS. 2011;25(10):611–21. Denison JA, McCauley AP, Dunnett-Dagg WA, Lungu N, Sweat MD. The HIV testing experiences of adolescents in Ndola, Zambia: do families and friends matter? AIDS Care. 2008;20(1):101–5. Wamoyi J, Fenwick A, Urassa M, Zaba B, Stones W. Parent-child communication about sexual and reproductive health in rural Tanzania: implications for young people's sexual health interventions. Reprod Health. 2010;7:6. Wamoyi J, Wight D, Remes P. The structural influence of family and parenting on young people's sexual and reproductive health in rural northern Tanzania. Cult Health Sex. 2015;17(6):718–32. Nguyen VK. Counselling against HIV in Africa: a genealogy of confessional technologies. Cult Health Sex. 2013;15 (Suppl 4):S440–52. Wamoyi J, Mshana G, Mongi A, Neke N, Kapiga S, Changalucha J. A review of interventions addressing structural drivers of adolescents’ sexual and reproductive health vulnerability in sub-Saharan Africa: implications for sexual health programming. Reproductive Health. 2014;11:88.