A model for mechanistic and system assessments of biochar effects on soils and crops and trade-offs

Abstract

We developed a biochar model within the Agricultural Production Systems sIMulator (APSIM) software that integrates biochar knowledge and enables simulation of biochar effects within cropping systems. The model has algorithms that mechanistically connect biochar to soil organic carbon (SOC), soil water, bulk density (BD), pH, cation exchange capacity, and organic and mineral nitrogen. Soil moisture (SW)–temperature–nitrogen limitations on the rate of biochar decomposition were included as well as biochar-induced priming effect on SOC mineralization. The model has 10 parameters that capture the diversity of biochar types, 15 parameters that address biochar-soil interactions and 4 constants. The range of values and their sensitivity is reported. The biochar model was connected to APSIM's maize and wheat crop models to investigate long-term (30 years) biochar effects on US maize and Australia wheat in various soils. Results from this sensitivity analysis showed that the effect of biochar was the largest in a sandy soil (Australian wheat) and the smallest in clay loam soil (US maize). On average across cropping systems and soils the order of sensitivity and the magnitude of the response of biochar to various soil-plant processes was (from high to low): SOC (11% to 86%) > N₂O emissions (−10% to 43%43%) > plant available water content (0.6% to 12.9%) > BD (−6.5% to −1.7%) > pH (−0.8% to 6.3%) > net N mineralization (−19% to 10%) > CO₂ emissions (−2.0% to 4.3%) > water filled pore space (−3.7% to 3.4%) > grain yield (−3.3% to 1.8%) > biomass (−1.6% to 1.4%). Our analysis showed that biochar has a larger impact on environmental outcomes rather than agricultural production. The mechanistic model has the potential to optimize biochar application strategies to enhance environmental and agronomic outcomes but more work is needed to fill knowledge gaps identified in this work.

References Ameloot N, De Neve S, Jegajeevagan K et al. (2013) Short-term CO₂ and N₂O emissions and microbial properties of biochar amended sandy loam soils. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 57, 401–410. Andales AA, Batchelor WD, Anderson CE, Farnham DE, Whigham DK (2000) Incorporating tillage effects into a soybean model. Agricultural Systems, 66, 69–98. Archontoulis SV, Miguez FE (2015) Nonlinear regression models and applications in agricultural research. Agronomy Journal, 107, 786–798. Archontoulis SV, Miguez FE, Moore KJ (2014) Evaluating APSIM maize, soil water, soil nitrogen, manure and soil temperature modules in the Midwestern United States. Agronomy Journal, 106, 1025–1040. Atkinson CJ, Fitzgerald JD, Hipps NA (2010) Potential mechanisms for achieving agricultural benefits from biochar application to temperate soils: a review. Plant and Soil, 337, 1–18. Basso A, Miguez F, Laird DA, Horton R, Westgate M (2013) Assessing potential of biochar for increasing waterholding capacity of sandy soils. GCB Bioenergy, 5, 132–143. Biederman LA, Harpole WS (2013) Biochar and its effects on plant productivity and nutrient cycling: a meta-analysis. GCB Bioenergy, 5, 202–214. Brewer CE, Unger R, Schmidt-Rohr K, Brown RC (2011) Criteria to select biochars for field studies based on biochar Chemical Properties. Bioenergy Research, 4, 312–323. Brockhoff SR, Christians NE, Killorn RJ, Horton R, Davis DD (2010) Physical and mineral-nutrition properties of sand-based turfgrass root zones amended with biochar. Agronomy Journal, 102, 1627–1631. Brodowski S, Amelung W, Haumaier L, Zech W (2007) Black carbon contribution to stable humus in German arable soils. Geoderma, 139, 220–228. Bruun EW, Ambus P, Egsgaard H, Hauggaard-Nielsen H (2012) Effect of slow and fast pyrolysis on soil C and N turnover dynamics. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 46, 73–79. Bruun EW, Hauggaard-Nielsen H, Ibrahim N et al. (2011a) Influence of fast pyrolysis temperature on biochar labile fraction and short-term carbon loss in a loamy soil. Biomass and Bioenergy, 35, 1182–1189. Bruun EW, Muller-Stover D, Ambus P, Hauggaard-Nielsen H (2011b) Application of biochar to soil and N₂O emissions: potential effects of blending fast-pyrolysis biochar with anaerobically digested slurry. European Journal of Soil Science, 62, 581–589. Case SD, McNamara NP, Reay DS, Whitaker J (2012) The effect of biochar addition on N₂O and CO₂ emissions from a sandy loam soil – the role of soil aeration. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 51, 125–134. Case SD, McNamara NP, Reay DS, Whitaker J (2014) Can biochar reduce greenhouse gas emissions from a Miscanthus bioenergy crop? GCB Bioenergy, 6, 76–89. Case SD, McNamara NP, Reay DS, Stott AW, Grant HK, Whitaker J (2015) Biochar suppresses N2O emissions while maintain N availability in a sandy loam soil. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 81, 178–185. Cayuela ML, van Zwieten L, Singh BP, Jeffery S, Roiga A, Sánchez-Monedero MA (2014) Biochar's role in mitigating soil nitrous oxide emissions: a review andmeta-analysis. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 191, 5–16. Cayuela ML, Jeffery S, van Zwieten L (2015) The molar H:Corg ratio of biochar is a key factor in mitigating N₂O emissions from soil. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 202, 135–138. Cheng CH, Lehmann J, Engelhard MH (2008) Natural oxidation of black carbon in soils: changes in molecular form and surface charge along a climosequence. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 72, 1598–1610. Clough TJ, Bertram JE, Ray JL, Condron LM, O'Callaghan M, Sherlock RR, Wells NS (2010) Unweathered wood biochar impact on nitous oxide emissions from a Bovide-urine-amended pasture soil. Soil Science Society America Journal, 74, 852–860. Cornelissen G, Martinsen V, Shitumbanuma V et al. (2013) Biochar effect on maize yield and soil characteristics in five conservation farming sites in Zambia. Agronomy, 3, 256–274. Crane-Droesch A, Abiven S, Jeffery S, Torn MS (2013) Heterogeneous global crop yield response to biochar: a meta-regression analysis. Environmental Research Letters, 8, 044049. Cross A, Sohi SP (2011) The priming potential of biochar products in relation to labile carbon contents and soil organic matter status. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 43, 2127–2134. Dalgliesh NP, Foale MA (2005) Soil Matters: Monitoring Soil Water and Nutrients in Dryland Farming. Agricultural Production Systems Research Unit, Toowoomba, Australia. ISBN 0643063757. Ding Y, Lie Y-X, Wu W-X, Shi D-Z, Yang M, Zhing Z-K (2010) Evaluation of biochar effects on nitrogen reternion and leaching in lumti-layered soil columns. Water Air Soil Pollution, 213, 47–55. Elliot J, Kelly D, Chyssanthacopoulos J et al. (2014) The parallel system for integrating impacts models and sectors (pSIMS). Environmental Modeling & Software, 62, 509–516. Fidel R (2012) Evaluation and implementation of methods for quantifying organic and inorganic compounds of Biochar alkalinity. MS Thesis, Iowa State University Library. Foereid B, Lehmann J, Major J (2011) Modeling black carbon degradation and movement in soil. Plant and Soil, 345, 223–236. Gai C, Wang H, Liu J, Zhai L, Liu S, Ren T, Liu H (2014) Effects of feedstock and pyrolysis temperature on biochar adsorption of ammonium and nitrate. PLoS One, 9, e113888. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0113888. Guerena D, Lehmann J, Hanley K, Enders A, Hyland C, Riha S (2013) Nitrogen dynamics following field application of biochar in a temperate North American maize-based production system. Plant Soil, 365, 239–254. Haefelea SM, Konboon Y, Wongboon W, Amarante S, Maarifat AA, Pfeiffer AM, Knoblauch C (2011) Effects and fate of biochar from rice residues in rice-based systems. Field Crops Research, 121, 430–440. Herath HMSK, Camps-Arbestain M, Hedley M (2013) Effect of biochar on soil physical properties in two contrasting soils: an Alfisol and an Andisol. Geoderma, 209–210, 188–197. Holzworth DP, Huth NI, de Voil PG et al. (2014) APSIM – evolution towards a new generation of agricultural systems simulation. Environmental Modeling & Software, 62, 327–350. Jassal RS, Johnson MS, Molodovskaya M, Black TA, Jollymore A, Sveinson K (2015) Nitrogen enrichment potential of biochar in relation to pyrolysis temperature and feedstock quality. Journal of Environmental Management, 152, 140–144. Jeffery S, Verheijen FGA, Van der Velde M, Bastos AC (2011) A quantitative review of the effects of biochar application to soils on crop productivity using meta-analysis. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 144, 175–187. Jeffery S, Bezemer TM, Cordelissen G et al. (2015) The way forward in biochar research: targeting trade-offs between the potential wins. GCB Bioenergy, 7, 1–13. doi:10.1111/gcbb.12132. Jien SH, Wange C-S (2013) Effects of biochar on soil properties and erosion potential in a highly weathered soil. Catena, 110, 225–233. Jones DL, Rousk J, Edwards-Jones G, DeLuca TH, Murphy DV (2012) Biochar-mediated changes in soil quality and plant growth in three year field trial. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 45, 113–124. Keating BA, Carberry PS, Hammer GL et al. (2003) An overview of APSIM, a model designed for farming systems simulation. European Journal of Agronomy, 18, 267–288. Kramer RW, Kujawinski EB, Hatcher PG (2004) Identification of black carbon derived structures in a volcanic ash soil humic acid by Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry. Environmental Science and Technology, 38, 3387–3395. Kuzyakov Y, Subbotina I, Chen H, Bogomolova I, Xu X (2009) Black carbon decomposition and incorporation into soil microbial biomass estimated by 14C labeling. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 41, 210–219. Laird DA (2008) The charcoal vision: a win–win–win scenario for simultaneously producing bioenergy, permanently sequestering carbon, while improving soil and water quality. Agronomy Journal, 100, 178–181. Laird DA, Brown RC, Amonette JE, Lehmann J (2009) Review of the pyrolysis platform for coproducing bio-oil and biochar. Biofuels Bioproducts Biorefining, 3, 547–562. Laird DA, Fleming P, Davis DD, Horton R, Wang B, Karlen DL (2010) Impact of biochar amendments on the quality of a typical Midwestern agricultural soil. Geoderma, 158, 443–449. Lehmann J, Rillig MC, Thies J, Masiello CA, Hockaday WC, Crowley D (2011) Biochar effects on soil biota – a review. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 43, 1812–1836. Lim TJ, Spokas KA, Feyereisen G, Novak JM (2016) Predicting the impact of biochar additions on soil hydraulic properties. Chemosphere, 142, 136–144. Liu J, Scjulz H, Brandl S, Miehtke H, Huwe Glaser B (2012) Short-term effect of biochar and compost on soil fertility and water status of a Dystric Cambisol in NE Germany under field conditions. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Soil Science, 175, 698–707. Liu S, Zhang Y, Zong Y, Hu Z, Wu S, Zhuo J, Zou J (2015) Response of soil carbon dioxide fluxes, soil organic carbon and microbial carbon to biochar amendment: a meta-analysis. GCB Bioenergy, in press. doi:10.1111/gcbb.12265. Lychuk TE, Izaurralde RZ, Hill RL, McGill WB, Williams JR (2015) Biochar as a global change adaptation: predicting biochar impacts on crop productivity and soil quality for a tropical soil with the Environmental Policy Integrated Climate (EPIC) model. Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change, 20, 1437–1458. Major J, Rondon M, Molina D, Riha SJ, Lehmann J (2010) Maize yield and nutrition during 4 years after biochar application to a Colombian savanna oxisol. Plant and Soil, 333, 117–128. Morales VL, Perez-Reche FJ, Hapca SM, Hanley KL, Lehmann J, Zhang W (2015) Reverse engineering of biochar. Bioeresource Technology, 183, 163–174. Nelissen V, Rütting T, Huygens D, Staelens J, Ruysschaert G, Boeckx P (2012) Maize biochars accelerate short-term soil nitrogen dynamics in a loamy sand soil. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 55, 20–27. Nelson PN, Su N (2010) Soil pH buffering capacity: a descriptive function and its application to some acidic tropical soils. Australian Journal of Soil Research, 48, 201–207. Peng X, Ye LL, Wang CH, Zhou H, Sun B (2011) Temperature- and duration-dependent rice straw-derived biochar: characteristics and its effects on soil properties of an Ultisol in southern China. Soil and Tillage Research, 112, 159–166. Probert MR, Dimes JP, Keating B, Dalal RC, Strong WM (1998) APSIM's water and nitrogen modules and simulation of the dynamics of water and nitrogen in fallow systems. Agricultural Systems, 56, 1–28. Probert MR, Delve RJ, Kimani SK, Dimes JP (2005) Modeling nitrogen mineralization from manures: representing quality aspects by varying C: N rations of sub-pools. Soil Biology Biochemistry, 37, 279–287. Rogovska N, Laird DA, Rathke SJ, Karlen DL (2014) Biochar impact on Midwestern Mollisols and maize nutrient availability. Geoderma, 230, 340–347. Sarkhot DV, Ghezzehei TA, Berhe AA (2014) Effectiveness of biochar for sorption of ammonium and phosphate from dairy effluent. Journal of Environmental Quality, 42, 1545–1554. Saxton KE, Rawls WJ (2006) Soil water characteristic estimates by texture and organic matter for hydrologic solutions. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 70, 1569–1578. Seybold CA, Grossman RB, Reinsch TG (2005) Predicting cation exchange capacity for soil survey using linear models. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 69, 856–863. Spokas KA, Reicosky DC (2009) Impacts of Sixteen different biochars on soil greenhouse gas production. Annals of Environmental Science, 3, 179–193. Spokas KA, Novak JM, Ventera RT (2011) Biochar's role as an alternative N-fertilizer: ammonia capture. Plant and Soil, 350, 57–69. Spokas KA, Cantrell KB, Novak JM et al. (2012) Biochar: a synthesis of its agronomic impact beyond carbon sequestration. Journal of Environmental Quality, 41, 973–989. Strubel JD, Collins HP, Garcia-Perez M, Tarara J, Granatstein D, Kruger CE (2011) Influence of contrasting biochar types on five soils at increasing rates of application. Soil Science Society of America, 75, 1402–1413. Thorburn PJ, Meier EA, Probert ME (2005) Modelling nitrogen dynamics in sugarcane systems: recent advances and applications. Field Crops Research, 92, 337–351. Thorburn PJ, Probert ME, Robertson FA (2001) Modelling decomposition of sugarcane surface residues with APSIM-Residue. Field Crops Research, 70, 223–232. Thorburn PJ, Biggs JS, Collins K, Probert ME (2010) Using the APSIM model to estimate nitrous oxide emissions from diverse Australian sugarcane production systems. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 136, 343–350. Van Zwieten L, Kimber S, Morris S et al. (2010) Effects of biochar from slow pyrolysis of papermill waste on agronomic performance and soil fertility. Plant and Soil, 327, 235–246. Wang J, Xiong Z, Kuyakov Y (2015) Biochar stability in soil: meta-analysis of decomposition and priming effects. GCB Bioenergy. doi:10.1111/gcbb.12266. Woolf D, Lehmann J (2012) Modelling the long-term response to positive and negative priming of soil organic carbon by black carbon. Biogeochemistry, 111, 83–95 . Woolf D, Amonette JE, Street-Perrott FA, Lehmann J, Joseph S (2010) Sustainable biochar to mitigate global climate change. Nature Communications, 1, 1–9. Yao Y, Gao B, Zhang M, Inyang M, Zimmerman AR (2012) Effect of biochar amendment on sorption and leaching of nitrate, ammonium, and phosphate in a sandy soil. Chemosphere, 89, 1467–1471. Yuan JH, Xu RK, Zhang H (2011) The forms of alkalis in the biochar produced from crop residues at different temperatures. Bioresource Technology, 102, 3488–3497. Zhang Q-Z, Dijkstra FA, X-r Liu, Y-d Wang, Huang J, Lu N (2014) Effects of biochar on soil microbial biomass after four years of consecutive application in the north China plain. PLoS One, 9, e102062. Zimmerman AR, Gao B, Ahn M-Y (2011) Positive and negative carbon mineralization priming effects among a variety of biochar-amended soils. Soil Biology & Biochemistry, 43, 1169–1179.