Is the hibiscus harlequin bug aposematic? The importance of testing multiple predators

Abstract

Aposematism involves predators learning conspicuous signals of defended prey. However, prey species utilize a wide range of chemical (or physical) defenses, which are not likely to be equally aversive to all predators. Aposematism may therefore only be effective against a physiologically sensitive subset of potential predators, and this can only be identified through behavioral testing. We studied the emerging model organism Tectocoris diophthalmus (Heteroptera: Scutelleridae), an aposematically colored but weakly defended shieldback stinkbug, to test the efficacy of its defenses against a suite of predator types. We predicted the bugs' defenses would be ineffectual against both experienced and naïve birds but aversive to predaceous insects. Surprisingly, the opposite pattern was found. Both habituated wild passerines and naïve chickens avoided the bugs, the chickens after only one or two encounters. To avian predators, T. diophthalmus is aposematic. However, praying mantids showed no repellency, aversion, or toxicity associated with adult or juvenile bugs after multiple trials. Comparison with prior studies on mantids using bugs with chemically similar but more concentrated defenses underscores the importance of dose in addition to chemical identity in the efficacy of chemical defenses. Our results also emphasize the importance of behavioral testing with multiple ecologically relevant predators to understand selective pressures shaping aposematic signals and chemical defenses.

References Alcock, J. 1970. Punishment levels and the response of black-capped chickadees (Parus atricapillus) to three kinds of artificial seeds. Anim. Behav. 18 Part 3 (0):592–599. Alcock, J. 1973. The feeding response of hand-reared red-winged blackbirds (Agelaius phoeniceus) to a stinkbug (Euschistus conspersus). Am. Midl. Nat. 89:307–313. Aldrich, J. R. 1988. Chemical ecology of the heteroptera. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 33:211–238. Ballard, E., and F. G. Holdaway. 1926. The life history of Tectocoris lineola (F.), and its connection with internal boll rots in Queensland. Bull. Entomol. Res. 16:329–346. Benjamini, Y., and Y. Hochberg. 1995. Controlling the false discovery rate: a practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. J. R Stat. Soc. Series B Stat. Methodol. 57:289–300. Berenbaum, M. R., and E. Miliczky. 1984. Mantids Tenodera ardifolia sinensis and milkweed bugs Oncopeltus fasciatus: efficacy of aposematic coloration against invertebrate predators. Am. Midl. Nat. 111:64–68. Bernays, E., J. A. Edgar, and M. Rothschild. 1977. Pyrrolizidine alkaloids sequestered and stored by the aposematic grasshopper, Zonocerus variegatus. J. Zool. 182:85–87. Bowdish, T. I., and T. L. Bultman. 1993. Visual cues used by mantids in learning aversion to aposematically colored prey. Am. Midl. Nat. 129:215–222. Brodie, E. D., and R. R. Howard. 1973. Experimental study of Batesian mimicry in the salamanders Plethodon jordani and Desmognathus ochrophaeus. Am. Midl. Nat. 90:38–46. Davis, D. E., and L. Domm (1943) The influence of hormones on the sexual behavior of domestic fowl. Pp. 171–181 in T. Cowles, and H. M. Evans, eds. Essays in biology, in honor of Herbert M. Evans. Univ. California Press, Berkely, CA. Eliyahu, D., R. A. Ceballos, V. Saeidi, and J. X. Becerra. 2012. Synergy versus potency in the defensive secretions from nymphs of two Pentatomomorphan families (Hemiptera: Coreidae and Pentatomidae). J. Chem. Ecol. 38:1358–1365. Exnerová, A., P. Štys, E. Fučíková, S. Veselá, K. Svádová, M. Prokopová, et al. 2007. Avoidance of aposematic prey in European tits (Paridae): learned or innate? Behav. Ecol. 18:148–156. Fabricant, S. A., D. J. Kemp, J. Krajíček, Z. Bosáková, and M. E. Herberstein. 2013. Mechanisms of color production in a highly variable shield-back stinkbug, Tectocoris diophthalmus (Heteroptera: Scutelleridae), and why it matters. PLoS One 8:e64082. Hoese, F. J., E. A. J. Law, D. Rao, and M. E. Herberstein. 2006. Distinctive yellow bands on a sit-and-wait predator: prey attractant or camouflage? Behaviour 143:763–781. Jakob, E. M., S. D. Marshall, and G. W. Uetz. 1996. Estimating fitness: a comparison of body condition indices. Oikos 77:61–67. Jetz, W., C. Rowe, and T. Guilford. 2001. Non-warning odors trigger innate color aversions—as long as they are novel. Behav. Ecol. 12:134–139. Knight, D. W., B. W. Staddon, and M. J. Thorn. 1985. Presumed sex pheromone from androconial glands of male cotton harlequin bug Tectocoris diophthalmus (Heteroptera; Scutelleridae) identified as 3,5-dihydroxy-4-pyrone. Z. Naturforsch. B J. Chem. Sci. 40:851–853. Lindström, L., R. V. Alatalo, and J. Mappes. 1999. Reactions of hand-reared and wild-caught predators toward warningly colored, gregarious, and conspicuous prey. Behav. Ecol. 10:317–322. McBride, G., I. Parker, and F. Foenander. 1969. The social organization and behaviour of the feral domestic fowl. Soc. Behav. Monogr. 2:125–181. McIver, J. D., and J. D. Lattin. 1990. Evidence for aposematism in the plant bug Lopidea nigridea Uhler (Hemiptera: Miridae: Orthotylinae). Biol. J. Linn. Soc. 40:99–112. Metz, K. J., and P. J. Weatherhead. 1991. Color bands function as secondary sexual traits in male red-winged blackbirds. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 28:23–27. Moore, B. P., and W. V. Brown. 1981. Identification of warning odour components, bitter principles and antifeedants in an aposematic beetle: Metriorrhynchus rhipidius (Coleoptera: Lycidae). Insect Biochem. 11:493–499. Nicol, C. 2006. How animals learn from each other. Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. 100:58–63. Noge, K., K. L. Prudic, and J. X. Becerra. 2012. Defensive roles of (E)-2-alkenals and related compounds in Heteroptera. J. Chem. Ecol. 38:1050–1056. Papaj, D. R., and G. M. Newsom. 2005. A within-species warning function for an aposematic signal. Proc. Biol. Sci. 272:2519–2523. Prudic, K. L., A. K. Skemp, and D. R. Papaj. 2007. Aposematic coloration, luminance contrast, and the benefits of conspicuousness. Behav. Ecol. 18:41–46. Prudic, K. L., K. Noge, and J. X. Becerra. 2008. Adults and nymphs do not smell the same: the different defensive compounds of the giant mesquite bug (Thasus neocalifornicus: Coreidae). J. Chem. Ecol. 34:734–741. Remold, H. 1963. Scent-glands of land-bugs, their physiology and biological function. Nature 198:764–768. Rowe, C., and T. Guilford. 1996. Hidden colour aversions in domestic chicks triggered by pyrazine odours of insect warning displays. Nature 383:520–522. Rowe, C., and T. Guilford. 1999. The evolution of multimodal warning displays. Evol. Ecol. 13:655–671. Rowe, C., and J. Skelhorn. 2005. Colour biases are a question of taste. Anim. Behav. 69:587–594. Ruxton, G. D., T. N. Sherratt, and M. P. Speed. 2004. Avoiding attack: the evolutionary ecology of crypsis, warning signals and mimicry. Pp. 249. Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford, U.K. Schaefer, C. W. 1972. Degree of metathoracic scent-gland development in the trichophorous Heteroptera (Hemiptera). Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 65:810–821. Schlee, M. A. 1986. Avian predation on Heteroptera: experiments on the European Blackbird Turdus m. merula L. Ethology 73:1–18. Schuler, W., and E. Hesse. 1985. On the function of warning coloration: a black and yellow pattern inhibits prey-attack by naive domestic chicks. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 16:249–255. Schwarz, J., R. Gries, K. Hillier, N. Vickers, and G. Gries. 2009. Phenology of semiochemical-mediated host foraging by the western boxelder bug, Boisea rubrolineata, an aposematic seed predator. J. Chem. Ecol. 35:58–70. Sherwin, C., C. Heyes, and C. Nicol. 2002. Social learning influences the preferences of domestic hens for novel food. Anim. Behav. 63:933–942. Smith, R. M. 1978. The defensive secretion of the bugs Lamprophara bifasciata, Adrisa numeensis, and Tectocoris diophthalmus from Fiji. N.Z. J. Zool. 5:821–822. Staddon, B. W. 1979. The scent glands of Heteroptera. Adv. Insect Physiol. 14:351–418. Staddon, B., M. Thorne, and D. Knight. 1987. The scent glands and their chemicals in the aposematic cotton harlequin bug, Tectocoris diophthalmus (Heteroptera, Scutelleridae). Aust. J. Zool. 35:227–234. Staples, J. K., B. S. Krall, R. J. Bartelt, and D. W. Whitman. 2002. Chemical defense in the plant bug Lopidea robiniae (Uhler). J. Chem. Ecol. 28:601–615. Stevens, M. 2005. The role of eyespots as anti-predator mechanisms, principally demonstrated in the Lepidoptera. Biol. Rev. 80:573–588. Stevens, M., I. C. Cuthill, C. Alejandro Parraga, and T. Troscianko. 2006. The effectiveness of disruptive coloration as a concealment strategy. Prog. Brain Res. 155:49–64. Svádová, H., A. Exnerová, M. Kopečková, and P. Štys. 2010. Predator dependent mimetic complexes: do passerine birds avoid Central European red-and-black Heteroptera? Eur. J. Entomol. 107:349–355. Svádová, H., A. Exnerová, M. Kopečková, and P. Štys. 2013. How do predators learn to recognize a mimetic complex: experiments with naïve great tits and aposematic Heteroptera. Ethology 119:814–830. Talianchich, A., W. J. Bailey, and E. L. Ghisalberti. 2003. Palatability and defense in the aposematic diurnal whistling moth, Hecatesia exultans Walker (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae: Agaristinae). Aust. J. Entomol. 42:276–280. Verhoeven, K. J., K. L. Simonsen, and L. M. McIntyre. 2005. Implementing false discovery rate control: increasing your power. Oikos 108:643–647. Williams, L., P. Evans, and W. Bowers. 2001. Defensive chemistry of an aposematic bug, Pachycoris stallii Uhler and volatile compounds of its host plant Croton californicus Muell.-Arg. J. Chem. Ecol. 27:203–216. Wilson, L. T., D. R. Booth, and R. Morton. 1983. The behavioural activity and vertical distribution of the cotton harlequin bug Tectocoris diophthalmus (Thunberg) (Heteroptera: scutelleridae) on cotton plants in a glasshouse. Aust. J. Entomol. 22:311–317.