A validation of an entropy-based artificial intelligence for ultrasound data in breast tumors

Abstract

Background

The application of artificial intelligence (AI) in the ultrasound (US) diagnosis of breast cancer (BCa) is increasingly prevalent. However, the impact of US-probe frequencies on the diagnostic efficacy of AI models has not been clearly established.

Objectives

To explore the impact of using US-video of variable frequencies on the diagnostic efficacy of AI in breast US screening.

Methods

This study utilized different frequency US-probes (L14: frequency range: 3.0-14.0 MHz, central frequency 9 MHz, L9: frequency range: 2.5-9.0 MHz, central frequency 6.5 MHz and L13: frequency range: 3.6-13.5 MHz, central frequency 8 MHz, L7: frequency range: 3-7 MHz, central frequency 4.0 MHz, linear arrays) to collect breast-video and applied an entropy-based deep learning approach for evaluation. We analyzed the average two-dimensional image entropy (2-DIE) of these videos and the performance of AI models in processing videos from these different frequencies to assess how probe frequency affects AI diagnostic performance.

Results

The study found that in testing set 1, L9 was higher than L14 in average 2-DIE; in testing set 2, L13 was higher in average 2-DIE than L7. The diagnostic efficacy of US-data, utilized in AI model analysis, varied across different frequencies (AUC: L9 > L14: 0.849 vs. 0.784; L13 > L7: 0.920 vs. 0.887).

Conclusion

This study indicate that US-data acquired using probes with varying frequencies exhibit diverse average 2-DIE values, and datasets characterized by higher average 2-DIE demonstrate enhanced diagnostic outcomes in AI-driven BCa diagnosis. Unlike other studies, our research emphasizes the importance of US-probe frequency selection on AI model diagnostic performance, rather than focusing solely on the AI algorithms themselves. These insights offer a new perspective for early BCa screening and diagnosis and are of significant for future choices of US equipment and optimization of AI algorithms.