Prevalence and drivers of HIV stigma among health providers in urban India: implications for interventions

Abstract

Introduction

HIV stigma inflicts hardship and suffering on people living with HIV (PLHIV) and interferes with both prevention and treatment efforts. Health professionals are often named by PLHIV as an important source of stigma. This study was designed to examine rates and drivers of stigma and discrimination among doctors, nurses and ward staff in different urban healthcare settings in high HIV prevalence states in India.

Methods

This cross-sectional study enrolled 305 doctors, 369 nurses and 346 ward staff in both governmental and non-governmental healthcare settings in Mumbai and Bengaluru, India. The approximately one-hour long interviews focused on knowledge related to HIV transmission, personal and professional experiences with PLHIV, instrumental and symbolic stigma, endorsement of coercive policies, and intent to discriminate in professional and personal situations that involve high and low risk of fluid exposure.

Results

High levels of stigma were reported by all groups. This included a willingness to prohibit female PLHIV from having children (55 to 80%), endorsement of mandatory testing for female sex workers (94 to 97%) and surgery patients (90 to 99%), and stating that people who acquired HIV through sex or drugs “got what they deserved” (50 to 83%). In addition, 89% of doctors, 88% of nurses and 73% of ward staff stated that they would discriminate against PLHIV in professional situations that involved high likelihood of fluid exposure, and 57% doctors, 40% nurses and 71% ward staff stated that they would do so in low-risk situations as well. Significant and modifiable drivers of stigma and discrimination included having less frequent contact with PLHIV, and a greater number of transmission misconceptions, blame, instrumental and symbolic stigma. Participants in all three groups reported high rates of endorsement of coercive measures and intent to discriminate against PLHIV. Stigma and discrimination were associated with multiple modifiable drivers, which are consistent with previous research, and which need to be targeted in future interventions.

Conclusions

Stigma reduction intervention programmes targeting healthcare providers in urban India need to address fear of transmission, improve universal precaution skills, and involve PLHIV at all stages of the intervention to reduce symbolic stigma and ensure that relevant patient interaction skills are taught.

References Krishna V, Bhatti R, Chandra P, Juvva S. Unheard voices: experiences of families living with HIV/AIDS in India*. Contemp Fam Ther. 2005;27(4):483–506. Ma W, Detels R, Feng Y, Wu Z, Shen L, Li Y, et al. Acceptance of and barriers to voluntary HIV counselling and testing among adults in Guizhou province, China. AIDS. 2007;21(Suppl 8):S129–35. Obermeyer CM, Osborn M. The utilization of testing and counseling for HIV: a review of the social and behavioral evidence. Am J Public Health. 2007;97(10):1762–74. Nguyen TA, Oosterhoff P, Pham YN, Hardon A, Wright P. Health workers’ views on quality of prevention of mother-to-child transmission and postnatal care for HIV-infected women and their children. Hum Resour Health. 2009;7:39. Varga CA, Sherman GG, Jones SA. HIV-disclosure in the context of vertical transmission: HIV-positive mothers in Johannesburg, South Africa. AIDS Care. 2006;18(8):952–60. Eide M, Myhre M, Lindbaek M, Sundby J, Arimi P, Thior I. Social consequences of HIV-positive women's participation in prevention of mother-to-child transmission programmes. Patient Educ Couns. 2006;60(2):146–51. Bond V, Chase E, Aggleton P. Stigma, HIV/AIDS and prevention of mother-to-child transmission in Zambia. Eval Program Plann. 2002;25(4):347–56. Nyblade L, Field ML. Community involvement in prevention of mother-to-child transmission (PMTCT) initiative. Women, communities and the prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV: issues and findings from community research in Botswana and Zambia. Washington, DC: Interventional Center for Research on Women; 2000. Madiba S. The impact of fear, secrecy, and stigma on parental disclosure of HIV status to children: a qualitative exploration with HIV positive parents attending an ART clinic in South Africa. Glob J Health Sci. 2013;5(2):49–61. Calin T, Green J, Hetherton J, Brook G. Disclosure of HIV among black African men and women attending a London HIV clinic. AIDS Care. 2007;19(3):385–91. Chandra PS, Deepthivarma S, Manjula V. Disclosure of HIV infection in south India: patterns, reasons and reactions. AIDS Care. 2003;15(2):207–15. Kumarasamy N, Safren SA, Raminani SR, Pickard R, James R, Krishnan AK, et al. Barriers and facilitators to antiretroviral medication adherence among patients with HIV in Chennai, India: a qualitative study. AIDS Patient Care STDS. 2005;19(8):526–37. Steward WT, Herek GM, Ramakrishna J, Bharat S, Chandy S, Wrubel J, et al. HIV-related stigma: adapting a theoretical framework for use in India. Soc Sci Med. 2008;67(8):1225–35. Nyblade L, Singh S, Ashburn K, Brady L, Olenja J. “Once I begin to participate, people will run away from me”: understanding stigma as a barrier to HIV vaccine research participation in Kenya. Vaccine. 2011;29(48):8924–8. Bharat S, Aggleton P, Tyrer P. India: HIV and AIDS-related discrimination, stigma and denial. Geneva: UNAIDS; 2001. ISBN 92-9173-104–8. Kinsler JJ, Wong MD, Sayles JN, Davis C, Cunningham WE. The effect of perceived stigma from a health care provider on access to care among a low-income HIV-positive population. AIDS Patient Care STDS. 2007;21(8):584–92. Morrison SD, Banushi VH, Sarnquist C, Gashi VH, Osterberg L, Maldonado Y, et al. Barriers to care and current medical and social needs of HIV-positive patients in Albania. Cent Eur J Public Health. 2011;19(2):91–7. Paterson DL, Swindells S, Mohr J, Brester M, Vergis EN, Squier C, et al. Adherence to protease inhibitor therapy and outcomes in patients with HIV infection. Ann Intern Med. 2000;133(1):21–30. Bangsberg DR, Hecht FM, Charlebois ED, Zolopa AR, Holodniy M, Sheiner L, et al. Adherence to protease inhibitors, HIV-1 viral load, and development of drug resistance in an indigent population. AIDS. 2000;14(4):357–66. Arnsten JH, Demas PA, Farzadegan H, Grant RW, Gourevitch MN, Chang CJ, et al. Antiretroviral therapy adherence and viral suppression in HIV-infected drug users: comparison of self-report and electronic monitoring. Clin Infect Dis. 2001;33(8):1417–23. Bangsberg DR, Perry S, Charlebois ED, Clark RA, Roberston M, Zolopa AR, et al. Non-adherence to highly active antiretroviral therapy predicts progression to AIDS. AIDS. 2001;15(9):1181–3. Ford K, Wirawan DN, Sumantera GM, Sawitri AA, Stahre M. Voluntary HIV testing, disclosure, and stigma among injection drug users in Bali, Indonesia. AIDS Educ Prev. 2004;16(6):487–98. Niang CI, Tapsoba P, Weiss E, Diagne M, Niang Y, Moreau AM, et al. It's raining stones': stigma, violence and HIV vulnerability among men who have sex with men in Dakar, Senegal. Cult Health Sex. 2003;5(6):499–512. Wolfe WR, Weiser SD, Leiter K, Steward WT, Percy-De Korte F, Phaladze N, et al. The impact of universal access to antiretroviral therapy on HIV stigma in Botswana. Am J Public Health. 2008;98(10):1865–71. White RC, Carr R. Homosexuality and HIV/AIDS stigma in Jamaica. Cult Health Sex. 2005;7(4):347–59. Feyissa GT, Abebe L, Girma E, Woldie M. Stigma and discrimination against people living with HIV by healthcare providers, Southwest Ethiopia. BMC Public Health. 2012;12:522. Banteyerga H, Kidanu A, Nyblade L, MacQuarrie K, Pande R. Yicha-laliko! Exploring HIV and AIDS stigma and related discrimination in Ethiopia: causes, manifestations, consequences, and coping mechanisms. Addis Ababa: Miz-Hasab Research Center; 2004. Working report measuring HIV stigma: results of a field test in Tanzania. Tanzania Stigma-Indicators Field Test Group: United States Agency International Development (USAID); 2005. Available from: http://www.icrw.org/files/publications/Working-Report-Measuring-HIV-Stigma-Results-of-a-Field-Test-in-Tanzania.pdf Hassan ZM, Wahsheh MA. Knowledge and attitudes of Jordanian nurses towards patients with HIV/AIDS: findings from a nationwide survey. Issues Ment Health Nurs. 2011;32(12):774–84. Vyas KJ, Patel GR, Shukla D, Mathews WC. A comparison in HIV-associated stigma among healthcare workers in urban and rural Gujarat. SAHARA J. 2010;7(2):71–5. Mahendra VS, Gilborn L, Bharat S, Mudoi R, Gupta I, George B, et al. Understanding and measuring AIDS-related stigma in health care settings: a developing country perspective. SAHARA J. 2007;4(2):616–25. Bharat S. Facing the HIV/AIDS challenge: a study on household and community responses. Health Millions. 1998;24(1):15–16, 19. Kurien M, Thomas K, Ahuja RC, Patel A, Shyla PR, Wig N, et al. Screening for HIV infection by health professionals in India. Natl Med J India. 2007;20(2):59–66. Kermode M, Holmes W, Langkham B, Thomas MS, Gifford S. HIV-related knowledge, attitudes and risk perception amongst nurses, doctors and other healthcare workers in rural India. Indian J Med Res. 2005;122(3):258–64. Kumar R, Mohan N, Seenu V, Kumar A, Nandi M, Sarma RK. Knowledge, attitude and practices towards HIV among nurses in a tertiary care teaching hospital: two decades after the discovery. J Commun Dis. 2002;34(4):245–56. Bharat S. A systematic review of HIV/AIDS-related stigma and discrimination in India: current understanding and future needs. SAHARA J. 2011;8(3):138–49. Mahendra VS, Gilborn L, George B, Samson L, Mudoi R, Jadav S, et al. Reducing AIDS-related stigma and discrimination in Indian hospitals. New Delhi: Population Council; 2006. Ekstrand ML, Bharat S, Ramakrishna J, Heylen E. Blame, symbolic stigma and HIV misconceptions are associated with support for coercive measures in urban India. AIDS Behav. 2012;16:700–10. Singh D, Chaudoir SR, Escobar MC, Kalichman S. Stigma, burden, social support, and willingness to care among caregivers of PLWHA in home-based care in South Africa. AIDS Care. 2011;23(7):839–45. Messer LC, Pence BW, Whetten K, Whetten R, Thielman N, O'Donnell K, et al. Prevalence and predictors of HIV-related stigma among institutional- and community-based caregivers of orphans and vulnerable children living in five less-wealthy countries. BMC Public Health. 2010;10:504. Weiss MG, Ramakrishna J, Somma D. Health-related stigma: rethinking concepts and interventions. Psychol Health Med. 2006;11(3):277–87. Steward WT, Bharat S, Ramakrishna J, Heylen E, Ekstrand ML. Stigma is associated with delays in seeking care among HIV-infected people in India. J Int Assoc Provid AIDS Care. 2013;12(2):103–9. Steward WT, Chandy S, Singh G, Panicker ST, Osmand TA, Heylen E, et al. Depression is not an inevitable outcome of disclosure avoidance: HIV stigma and mental health in a cohort of HIV-infected individuals from Southern India. Psychol Health Med. 2011;16(1):74–85. National AIDS Control Organization. Available from: http://naco.gov.in/upload/Surveillance/Reports%20&%20Publication/HIV%20Sentinel%20Surveillance%20India%20Country%20Report,%202008-09.pdf Herek GM Thinking about AIDS and stigma: a psychologist's perspective. J Law Med Ethics. 2002;30(4):594–607. Herek GM. AIDS and stigma. Am Behav Sci. 1997;42:1102–12. Herek GM. Confronting sexual stigma and prejudice: theory and practice. J Soc Issues. 2007;63:905–25. Herek GM, Capitanio JP. Public reactions to AIDS in the United States: a second decade of stigma. Am J Public Health. 1993;83(4):574–7. Herek GM, Mitnick L, Burris S, Chesney M, Devine P, Fullilove MT, et al. Workshop report: AIDS and stigma: a conceptual framework and research agenda. AIDS Public Policy J. 1998;13(1):36–47. Hosmer D, Lemeshow S. Applied logistic regression. New York: Wiley; 2000.