Content area
Full Text
BRITISH HISTORIAN ARNOLD J. TOYNBEE in his twelve volume A Study of History, (1934-1961), on the rise and decline of twenty-three civilizations, depicted the Jews as a "fossil" civilization. Toynbee presented history as the rise and fall of civilizations, rather than the history of nation-states or of ethnic groups. He identified his civilizations according to cultural rather than national criteria.
With the civilizations as units identified, he presented the history of each in terms of challenge-and-response. Civilizations arose in response to some set of challenges of extreme difficulty, when "creative minorities" devised solutions that reoriented their entire society. When a civilization responds to challenges, it grows. When it fails to respond to a challenge, it enters its period of decline. Toynbee argued that "Civilizations die from suicide, not by murder."
Although Toynbee's defenders deny he was anti-Semitic, Elie Kedourie pointed out that Toynbee did not hesitate to describe the Jews as a "fossil" civilization or, in 1948, to equate the Palestinian Jews, battling to establish the state of Israel, with the Nazis. When he finally got around to reconsidering his position on Judaism, it was in the context of celebrating the idea of world government and insisting that the Jews lead the way in demonstrating to mankind the folly of capitalism, nationalism, and territorial attachment.
Yaacov Herzog Israel's ambassador to Canada challenged Toynbee to a debate which took place in January 1961 at McGill University, Montreal in which he convincingly refuted Toynbee's thesis.
Little credit for Herzog's success was attributed to Abba Eban, Israel's ambassador to the United States, who had provided the main thrust of Herzog's argument in an address on The Toynbee Heresy delivered six years earlier. During the debate Herzog noted that Toynbee's ideas had 'been challenged by historians of great eminence and writers', and cited the 'Toynbee Heresy'. However, it was Toynbee himself who had to remind Herzog that this term was formulated and elucidated upon by Abba Eban. Furthermore, there is no recognition of Eban's contribution either in Herzog's bookv4 People That Dwells Alone (London, 1976) or in Michael Bar-Zohar's, Yaacov Herzog-A Biography (London, 2005).
Abba Eban read Classics and Oriental languages at Cambridge where he achieved the extraordinary distinction of a "Triple First" and a clutch of prizes and...