Content area
Full Text
Founding Brothers: The Revolutionary Generation. By Joseph J. Ellis. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2000.288 pages. $26.00. Reviewed by Dr. Robert M. S. McDonald, assistant professor of history, US Military Academy.
Joseph J. Ellis's Pulitzer Prize-winning group portrait of the revolutionary generation renders the Founding Fathers not as statuesque patriarchs but instead as a sometimes raucous fraternity of strong-willed statesmen competing and collaborating to answer questions that the War for Independence posed but did not answer: When coinciding claims of liberty, equality, and union come into conflict, which would prevail? Did the new republic derive its authority from laws or men? Would sovereignty reside in the states, the national government, or, as the Constitution of 1787-88 somewhat imaginatively claimed, an "American" people who at the outset of the federal experiment did not really exist? As Ellis's expert account makes clear, the founders proved themselves so adept at constructing alternative responses that today these questions continue to resonate.
Ellis is selective in characterizing this generation, which he describes (notwithstanding recent claims by...