Content area
Full Text
I
"The trouble with people," observed Josh Billings (Henry Wheeler Shaw, 1818-1885), the great nineteenth-century American humorist, "is not what they don't know but that they know so much that ain't so."
Psychiatrists and people interested in psychiatry "know" that Ronald D. (David) Laing (1927-1989), the Scottish psychiatrist, and I share the same ideas about mental illness and involuntary mental hospitalization. We are lumped together as the cofounders and coleaders of the "antipsychiatry" movement. My aim in this brief essay is to show that it "ain't so."
II
Regarding the management of mental illness, these are some of the opinions Laing expressed and some of the actions he engaged in:
When I certify someone insane, I am not equivocating when I write that he is of unsound mind, may be dangerous to himself and others, and requires care and attention in a mental hospital. (1960, p. 27)
To say that a locked ward functioned as a prison for non-criminal transgressors is not to say that it should not be so. Our society may continue to "need" some such prisons for unacceptable persons. As our society functions at present such places are indispensable. This is not the fault of psychiatrists, nor necessarily the fault of anyone. (1985, p. 6)
It does not follow from such possibly disturbing considerations that the exercise of such [psychiatric] power is not desirable and necessary, or that, by and large, psychiatrists are not the best people to exercise it, or, generally, that most of what does happen in the circumstances is not the best that can happen under the circumstances. (1985, p. 15)
In 1965, Laing and his colleagues founded the Philadelphia Association. The Association's Report for 1965-1969 listed its aim as follows (Philadelphia Association, n.d.): "To relieve mental illness of all description, in particular schizophrenia. To undertake, or further research, into the causes of mental illness, the means of its detection and prevention, and its treatment. . . . To promote and organize training in the treatment of schizophrenia and other forms of mental illness" (p. 3).
Supporters of Laing are likely to object that this wording was necessary for securing tax-exempt status for the Association as a "charity," and was phrased this way solely to accomplish that purpose....