Content area
Full Text
Fiona Tolan. Margaret Atwood: Feminism and Fiction. Amsterdam: Rodopi, 2007. 322 pp.
Margaret Atwood's fiction has tended to attract a fairly conventional critical approach, and this book by Fiona Tolan is no exception. As a writer of enormous range, whose work spans over four decades, Atwood presents a particular challenge for those who would hazard generalizations about her writing. The temptation is to run the work through various categories, the theories that have influenced her: identity politics, the body, the Gothic, the environment, Canada, the post-colonial, science fiction, historiography-and, of course, feminism. Anyone using feminism as a category in which to examine Atwood's novels today runs into certain difficulties. First, there is Atwood's repeated refusal of the label for her work. This refusal, however, should not deter us in a reader's world, and Tolan is right to insist that feminist discourse is not exclusive but "by its very nature . . . permeable and diffusive" (3). More serious, however, is the fact that the category has come to seem increasingly inadequate, even obsolete in relation to Atwood's work, particularly in the last couple of decades.
Atwood does of course deal centrally with gender issues, and there is no doubt that in such novels of the 1960s-1980s as The Edible Woman, Surfacing, Lady Oracle, Bodily Harm, and The Handmaid's Tale feminist debates provide an important context. Tolan summarizes in detail the impact of Simone de Beauvoir's Second Sex, Betty Friedan's Feminine Mystique, socio-psychologcal object-relations theory (Nancy Chodorow, Dorothy Dinnerstein), French feminism (Hélène Cixous, Luce Irigaray), ecofeminism (Mary Daly), femininity as a masquerade (Joan Riviere), and the debates between feminism and postmodernism, among others. The parallels are convincingly drawn, if rather familiar. Some of the most illuminating references are in fact to works that lie outside a strictly feminist context-for example Charles Taylor's communitarian theory and the politics of recognition or Edward Wilson on sociobiology.
Where the feminist context begins to distract from, rather than enhance, the experience of reading Atwood's writing is in the novels from Cat's Eye (1988) onward: the decade and a half of dazzling...