Medical Students - Self-Assessed Confidence Level Before a Major Physiology Examination: Affective Factors in a Nigerian Medical School

Abstract

Self-reported confidence before any examination in all levels of medical training is a product of previous experience, attitudinal inclinations overtime, degree of self subjection to tenets of professionalism and possibly, the inadvertent role of the medical school environment including colleagues, teachers and faculty members, comfort, satisfaction and psychosocial stability; which may be addressed as sub-factors that determine the level of preparedness. Let medical schools in Nigeria; adopt a continuous and regular assessment of students' self confidence before any minor or major examination, to monitor and ensure a certain psychological and academic level of preparedness among the students. This will avoid some cases of attrition resulting from self-doubt and lack of preparedness.

Medical Students Self-Assessed Confidence Level Before a Major Physiology Examination: Affective Factors in a Nigerian Medical School

153

AIM 2011; 19(3): 153-157 doi: 10.5455/aim.2011.19.153-157

Medical Students Self-Assessed Confidence Level Before a Major Physiology Examination: Affective Factors in a Nigerian Medical School

Ogugua Augustine Egwu1, Uche dimkpa2, Jude Ogbonnaya Orji3, Clinton Ogbannaya Njoku4, Egwu Ogbonnia Eni5, Elizabeth Besong6department of Anatomy, Nuamdi Azikiwe university, Nuewi Campus, Nigeria1department of Physiology, Ebony State university, Abakaliki, Nigeria2department of Anatomy, Nuamdi Azikiwe university, Nuewi Campus, Nigeria3

Original paper

SUMMARYSelf-reported confidence before any examination in all levels of medical training is a product of previous experience, attitudinal inclinations overtime, degree of self subjection to tenets of professionalism and possibly, the inadvertent role of the medical

school environment including colleagues, teachers and faculty members, comfort, satisfaction and psychosocial stability; which may be addressed as sub-factors that determine the level of preparedness. Let medical schools in Nigeria; adopt a continuous and regular assessment of students self confidence before any minor or major

examination, to monitor and ensure a certain psychological and academic level of preparedness among the students. This will avoid some cases of attrition resulting from self-doubt and lack of preparedness. Key words: medical schools, Nigeria, affective factors, self-assessed confidence level.

1. INTRODUCTION

The essence of medical education is to train knowledgeable, competent and professional physicians that will promote the nations health, advance the science of medicine and promote public health (1). In Nigeria, the medical education leading to the award of Bachelor of Medicine and Bachelor of Surgery (MBBS) is a six (6) year program consisting of twelve (12) months of studying the basic sciences and eighteen (18) months of preclinical training involving Anatomy, Physiology and Biochemistry. The remaining period of the study is devoted to clinical training. These periods of intense academic activities are marked by high frequencies of depression, anxiety and stress among the students2 that may alter their perception of themselves and the value of training (2, 3).

Little and Rodnick (1) stated that self reported condence of medical students is thought to reect the inuences of prior and current attitudes as well as of the information

gained through formal and informal educational experiences; all of which is pointer to the attitudinal changes during training (4). Therefore, it is possible that these attitudinal changes may aect the condence of these students towards their professional examinations.

Studies have attempted to establish a relationship between clinical experiences and students condence in Medicine and Surgery clerkships (3, 5). Others have also attempted to measure students condence in the context of specic student-patient encounters during clinical experience (6). However extenisive studies on condence of students have not been carried out in the preclinical setting which forms the foundation of clinical training and condence in the profession. The new studies should be developed and monitored over the period of training; and generally, literature on the issues of medical students condence during and aer training is scarce. We believe that self reported condence should

have a straight link with good self esteem which has been associated with the individuals position on success. This is because the individuals with low self-esteem downplay the importance of appearing competent to others (7). Therefore, the condence should be considered as an important variable as it has been shown to be a subjective marker of competence and one component of the ability to function competently (5).

As a result, this study is designed

to assess the level of self reported condence of medical students in a Nigerian University preparing for their second MBBS professional examination in physiology. The study has purposely chosen this specic population of students because it is at this stage of preclinical training (Basic Medical Sciences) that the highest rate of attrition is recorded among the medical students8 and level of self-assessed condence may be related to student attrition. Secondly, it is important to note that no studyso far has attempted to as-

AIM 2011; 19(3): 153-157 | Original paper

VOL 19 NO 3 SEPTEMBER 2011

154

Medical Students Self-Assessed Confidence Level Before a Major Physiology Examination: Affective Factors in a Nigerian Medical School

sess the factors that inuence the self reported condence of medical students to face professional examinations at both preclinical and clinical stages of their training. In this regard, it is important to X-ray these factors in order to make appropriate recommendations for a more eective training, professionalism and learning in our medical school environments.

2. SUBJECTS AND METHODS

The data used in this study was obtained from sixty six (66) medical students of Ebonyi State University, Abakaliki, Southeast Nigeria who were just about to face their second professional (2nd MBBS) examination in Physiology. These students were eligible candidates who had met all laid down criteria, qualied for the examination and were consenting and randomly selected.

A Self-administered questionnaire approved by the ethics/research committee of the Faculty of Basic Medical Sciences, Ebonyi State University, was developed and used to assess the condence level of the medical students. The questionnaire was designed to elicit data that are qualitative and quantitative for factual and attitudinal information to be gathered. It consists of three sections - one that requires demographic information, the other that assesses self -condence before the examination and possible factors that may be associated with self -condence. Condence level was assessed using a visual analogue scale of 1-10 where 1 was the lowest level of condence and 10, the highest. The students were subjected to ascertaining the degree of eect of some factors hypothesized to be associated with improved self - reported condence. These examined factors include number of attempts at the examination, role of the learning environment, role of teachers and faculty and role of colleagues and classmates. The third part is an open ended part of the questionnaire where the respondents were asked to state any group of factors that could aect their condence to achieve success in medical train-

ing. The stability and validity of the questionnaire was tested through the test retest procedure by using the individuals not involved in this study. A correlation coefficient () of 0.74 was obtained which indicated a relatively high stability of research instrument. Results from the open ended section were literarily transcribed and categorized into major themes. Finally, the obtained results obtained were analyzed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS 16.0). Independent sample t-test was used tomake comparisonbetween the condence levels of theaective variables.

3. RESULTS AND ANALYSIS OF RESULTS

The 66 students who responded to questionnaire were aged between 20 and 34 years (the mean was: 23.09 2.62). They were 42 males and 24 females. They had a condence level of 6.981.75 (4-10). 92.4% of the students were unmarried and 87.9% of them were residing outside the campus. 78.8% were sitting for the examination the rst time while 21.8% were repeat candidates. Only 28.8% of the medical students agreed to the postponement of the examination while the rest disagreed.

As Table 1 indicates, 60% of therespondents agreed that the learning environment aects their level of self assessed condence while 89.4% and 90.9% were aected by their teachers and colleagues respectively.

Table 2 shows that most of the variables did not show any signicant dierence in the condence level of the students in the respective categories at P0.05 as being signicant. However, eect of learning environment and the eect of teachers and faculty showed signicant dierence in self-assessed condence between the positives and the negatives (P=0.02 and P=0.01 respectively).

Table 3 indicates that majority of the students (24.1%) believe that

Examined Factors that may affectconfidence level Agree (%) Disagree (%)

Positive Contribution of learningenvironment 60.6 39.4

Contribution of Teachers andFaculty 89.4 10.6

Colleagues contribution 90.9 9.1

Table 1. Examined factors associated with improved confidence and percentage of Medical Students that agreed/disagreed

Variable Confidence level P-value Sex: Male

Female

7.01.666.951.94 0.927 Residence: Within campus

Off-campus

7.252.186.941.71 0.653

N0 of attempts: 1st-attempt. 2nd attempt (Repeat)

6.881.717.351.94 0.376 Postponement of exam: Agree

Disagree

6.781.817.061.74 0.570 Effect of learning environment:

Agree Disagree

7.401.616.341.81 0.02* Effect of Teachers/Faculty:

Agree Disagree

7.101.806.00.81 0.01*

Effect of Colleagues:

Agree Disagree

6.981.717.002.36 0.987

Table 2. Comparative analysis of confidence levels between some variables using independent sample t-test (level of Significance, P0.05)

Factors that affect confidence before anexamination Percentage occurrence.

Lecturer/Faculty- Student relationship 16.5%

Level of preparedness 24.1% Poor Learning Environment 22.0% Level of Anxiety/Psychological Stability/poorhealth and finance. 13.3%

Relationship with Classmates/Family/God 13.8%

Academic ability/Performance in previous

Exams 10.3%

Table 3. Medical Students opinion of factors that affect Self-assessed confidence level before an Examination.

their level of preparedness has most eect on their self-assessed condence before any examination while their individual academic ability and performance in previous examinations was ranked lowest

VOL 19 NO 3 SEPTEMBER 2011

Original paper | AIM 2011; 19(3): 153-157

Medical Students Self-Assessed Confidence Level Before a Major Physiology Examination: Affective Factors in a Nigerian Medical School

155

(10.3%) among factors that aect their self-assessed condence.

4. DISCUSSION

Medical school curriculum is designed to ensure that every graduate is knowledgeable, skillful, and professional (9), which should lead to a conscious development of Self-condence. Self-condence can be described as belief in ones abilities; the ability to achieve the competence in your responsibilities and the absolute absence of self doubt. Self condence bridges the gap between knowledgeableness and performance. For medical students in training, it involves great belief in the ability to pull through the rigors of medical training and achieve the highly cherished medical certicate. These rigors are patterned in such a way that every stage is marked by its own level of anxiety, stress and pressure. Ability to believe in ones self in the face of these rigors makes a condent medical trainee.

The results from this study have shown the self-assessed condence level of medical students before sitting for a professional examination in physiology. The condence level was quite high (6.981.75 ranging from 4-10), which is indicative of a general belief in the ability to achieve success in Physiology main examination and may also be linked to the general level of interest in course/subject.

However, the other side of condence, (i.e doubt in ones abilities-self doubt), which also manifested in this study may be related to the previous experience of the students, of gradual failure in physiology in-course assessments without a conscious repositioning of the individuals mind to succeed in the professional examination- a factor in low self-esteem and psychological disbelief. This nding was corroborated in the students opinion of factors that aect self-assessed condence in Physiology examination where 10.3% of them stated that academic ability and performance in previous assessments could aect their condence in the main examination.

In this study, 92.4% of the subjects were unmarried and all subjects

were within the age of 20-34 years typifying most African academic settings with a mix of the young and relatively mature. Personal life events, which may include marital status, of medical students have been reported to impart on their cognitive outcomes10. However, it did not signicantly aect the level of condence in this case possibly because only few students reported to have been married.

Students place of residence should be a principal component of comfort and satisfaction and was assessed to check relationship with the level of self-assessed condence. In this case, a greater and large percentage of the students (87.9%) lived o-campus which is indicative of a non-accommodating in-campus environment. As a result, the students may be exposed to a myriad of social distractions that may affect the discipline required for professional training of future clinicians. In this study, surprisingly, the comparative analysis of self-assessed condence between o-campus and in-campus students didnt indicate any signicant dierence (P=0.653) even though the in-campus students reported a higher level of condence (7.252.18 as against 6.941.71). This could be attributed to the fact that the o-campus students may have acclimatized with the inconvenience of coming to school from the outside and possibly have achieved comfort in their o-campus residence.

Repeating and re-sitting of the exams are normal trends in medical training. They are based on the fact that previous experiences can aect self-reported condences. The eect on self-assessed condence was determined by comparing the condence level of repeaters and rst timers. The insignicant dierence observed could possibly be due to the a result of the few (21.2%) repeating students who participated in the study. Surprisingly, repeated candidates showed a higher level of condence, which may be indicative of an improved interest and determination to succeed.

Students who opined that the examination be postponed showed a

lower condence level than those who agreed with non-postponement (though not signicant). This outcome expected and may be due to low level of preparedness on the side of the students. This level of preparedness topped the list of factors that inuence the self-assessed condence in the students opinion pool. Level of preparedness, though subjective, has two (2) sub-factors: The students psychological preparedness and academic preparedness. These factors work pari passu and should absolutely complement each other for a high level of preparedness, which could also be a product of all other factors in the students opinions.

A greater percentage (60%) of students believed that the learning environment has a huge inuence on their self-assessed condence before an examination. The self-assessed condence of students who were positive about the learning environment was signicantly higher (P<0.5) than students who were unhappy with their learning environment (Table 2). In their opinion, 22.4% of the students believed that the learning environment aects the self-assessed condence before any examination. Anyaehie et al (11), in a study of medical students evaluation of physiology learning environment reported that students predominant learning environment were lectures, practical classes, peer-tutored discussions and private study. They went even further to state that the lecture and practical environments were made unfriendly by large groups, time constraints and the lack of interactions. However, the other components of the learning environment were friendly, allowing for a livelier environment that may be improved by improving the electricity supply.

There was also a signicantly higher level of condence (P<0.05) among students who believed that Teachers and faculty have positively aected their training. This supports the students opinion where 16.5% of the respondents opined that lecturer/faculty-student relationship inuences their level of self-assessed condence. Therefore, avenues for

AIM 2011; 19(3): 153-157 | Original paper

VOL 19 NO 3 SEPTEMBER 2011

156

Medical Students Self-Assessed Confidence Level Before a Major Physiology Examination: Affective Factors in a Nigerian Medical School

sta-students interaction should be created for students to emulate and get oriented on the principles of positive learning, time management in examinations, and general principles of professionalism.

Contrary to already established fact that peer tutored discussions form the most preferred part of the learning environment (11, 12), just 13.8% of the respondents believed it (Contribution from colleagues and mates) inuences self-assessed condence. In the comparative analysis, there was no signicant dierence in condence level between those who were positively inuenced by colleagues and those who were not; even though 90.9% of the students thought they were aected positively by colleagues. This high percentage of thought could be attributed to the fact that their colleagues truly present a more interactive environment that may lead to a dierent understanding of subject (11), but some of these interactions may not be properly structured by the trainees leading to a certain degree of smoke screen on important subject matters. Therefore, faculty should aid students to structure more organized peer-tutored discussions that should entail discipline and objective communications.

Other factors reported by students to aect the self-assessed condence level before examinations include health and nancial status, relationship with God and level of Psychological stability and anxiety. Obviously, the health status of a student has the ability to reduce self-condence to the worst level and even psychological instability and anxiety are mental-health-undermining factors.

Over many years, the anxiety and psychological morbidity have been observed among medical students (13, 14, 15). This nding has been linked to poor academic performance; an outcome of failed condence and the belief in ones self. Fandem et al15 established a correlation between the academic performance and parental income and nancial status. This may be a pointer to the eect of nancial status on the level of an individuals self-

assessed condence because condence and competence/performance should be related.

Since the level of preparedness constitutes the highest cause of low self-assessed condence during examinations, it could be the resulting factor of all other mentioned causes. Psychological instability and mental and physical health, low nancial status, poor learning environment and poor faculty-student relationship could eventually lead to poor level of preparedness. How can a high level of preparedness be achieved among the medical students about to face a major professional examination? How can we enhance the absolute condence associated with knowledgeableness in the medical training?

The teachers and faculty have a huge role to play in the continuous/ regular assessment of medical students self-assessed condence before any major professional examination since it is a pointer to level of preparedness.

And to ensure a high level of preparedness, programs that monitor students psycho sociocognitive inclinations should be designed and adopted to ensure easy identication of struggling students who may have been hunted by health (physical and mental) problems, nancial problems, religious problems since Nigeria is a very religious country; and the teacher/faculty-student relationship should be enhanced by the division of students classes into smaller bond-groups and teachers made to have regular counseling meetings with the member students.

This should avail an opportunity to clear all self-doubts of the students and reposition them for a more condent disposition in facing challenges of examinations and training in the medical school.

Even though Morgan and Cli-Hogg (16) and Bansley et al (17) have reported a lack of relationship between condence and performance in clinical skills, it is absolutely necessary to re-emphasize the need for self condence in medical training and practice. This is needed because ithis practice enhances a near-per-

fect belief in the practitioner by patients (that should not be false) and by doing so, the tenets of professionalism are further enthroned.

It should be importantly stated that examination(s) used in the context of this study may also imply all forms of the cognitive assessments during training and this report may serve as a guidepost to future outcomes of self-assessed condence of future student trainees and post-graduate trainees.

5. CONCLUSION

Self-reported condence before any examination at all levels of medical training is a product of previous experience, attitudinal inclinations achieved, degree of self subjection to tenets of professionalism and possibly, the inadvertent role of the medical school environment including colleagues, teachers and faculty members, comfort, satisfaction and psychosocial stability. All of the above mentioned factors may be addressed as sub-factors that determine the level of the psychological and academic preparedness. Let medical schools in Nigeria; adopt a continuous and regular assessment of students self condence before any minor or major examination, to monitor and ensure a certain psychological and academic level of preparedness among the students. This action shall avoid some cases of attrition resulting from self-doubt and a lack of preparedness.

REFERENCES

1. Amini M, Safaee Ardekani GH. Golkar A, Jafari P, Hosseini Alhashemi HR, Moghadami M, Hosseini MM, Zahraee N. Quality of life of Medical Students in Dierent stages- A Multi centre study. J Med Educ. Winter & Spring, 2007; 11(1,2): 13-19.

2. Guthrie EA, Black D, Shaw CM, Hamilton J, Creed FH, Tomenson B. Embarking upon a medical career: psychological mobidity in rst year medical students. Med Educ. 1995; 29: 337-341.3. Little M, Rodnick JE. Evaluating student experiences in a family medicine clerkship. Fam Med. 1988; 20: 347-351.

VOL 19 NO 3 SEPTEMBER 2011

Original paper | AIM 2011; 19(3): 153-157

Medical Students Self-Assessed Confidence Level Before a Major Physiology Examination: Affective Factors in a Nigerian Medical School

157

4. Woloscuk W, Harasym PH, Temple W. Attitude change during medical school: a cohort study. Med Educ. 2004; 38(5): 522-534.

5. Cohen A, Cohen R. Development of competence in clerkship. Med. Teach. 1990; 12: 47-55.

6. Harrel PL, Kearl GW, Reed EL, Grigsby DG, Caudill TS. Medical Students condence and the characteristics of their clinical experiences in a primary care clerkship. Acad Med. 1993; 68 (7): 577-579.

7. Park LE, Crocher J, Kiefer AK. Contingencies of self-worth, academic failure, and goal pursuit. Pers Soc Psychol Bull. 2007; 33: 15031517.

8. Egwu OA, Anyanwu GE. Five year Survey of Medical Student attrition in a Medical School in Nigeria: A pilot study. Adv in Med Educ and Pract. 2010; 1:53- 57.

9. Laison Committee on Medical Education. Functions and structure of a medical school. Standards for accreditation of medical education programmes leading to the MD

degree. Washington DC. AAMC. 2005. Available from: http:/www. lcme.org/pubs.htm#fands.Accessed 2010, May 15.10. Dyrbye LN, Thomas MR, Huntington JL, Lawson KL, Novotny PJ, Sloan JA, Shanafelt TD.Personal life events and Medical student Burnout: A multicenter study. Acad Med. 2006; 81: 374-384.

11. Anyaehie USB, Nwobodo E, Oze G, Nwagha U I, Orizu T, Okeke T, Anyanwu GE. Medical Students evaluation of physiology learning environments in two Nigerian medical schools. Adv Physiol Educ 2001; 35.

12. Anyaehie UB, Nwobodo Ed, Njoku CJ. Comparative evaluation of active learning and the traditional lectures on physiology: a case study of 200 level medical Laboratory students of Imo state University, Owerri. Niger J Physio. 2007; Sc 22: 117- 121.

13. Stewart SM, Lam TH, Betson CL, Wong CM, Wong AM. A prospective analysis of stress and academic

performance in the rst two years of medical school. Med Educ. 1999; 33: 243-250.14. Wolf TM, Faucett JM, Randall HM, Balson PM. Graduating Medical Students ratings of stresses, pleasures and coping strategies. J med Educ. 1988; 63: 636-642.

15. Fandem B, Schuchman M, Simring SS. The relationship between parental income and academic performance of medical students. Acad Med. 1995; 70(12): 1142-1144.

16. Morgan PJ, Cleave-Hogg. Comparicon between medical students experience, condence and competence. Med Educ. 2002; 36(6): 534-539.

17. Barnsley L, Lyon PM, Ralston SJ, Hibbert EJ, Cunningham I, Gordon FC, Field MJ. Clinical skills in junior medical officers: a comparison of self- reported condence and observed competence. Med Educ. 2004; 38(4): 358-367.

Corresponding author: Ogugua Augustine Egwu, MD.

Department of Anatomy, Nuamdi Azikiwe university.

Nuewi campus, Nigeria.

AIM 2011; 19(3): 153-157 | Original paper

VOL 19 NO 3 SEPTEMBER 2011