Content area
Full Text
WAHMAN, Jessica. Narrative Naturalism: An Alternative Framework for Philosophy of Mind. Lanham, Md.: Lexington Books, 2015. xv + 191 pp. Cloth, $85.00-In the early twentieth century, George Santayana was the most prominent of the new American naturalist philosophers, only later eclipsed by Dewey. His poetic materialism defied inherited categories and open new avenues for thought. But since mid-century he has been largely absent from debates about that characteristically American product, nonreductive naturalism.
Jessica Wahman has organized a sophisticated and well-written Santayanan counterattack. Her aim is to show that Santayana's naturalism is suited to contribute to current debates over reductionism and the philosophy of mind. Wahman rejects mechanism and physicalism as philosophical misinterpretations of the natural sciences. She employs careful arguments in epistemology and neuroscience to display Santayana's scheme as an alternative to both reductive physicalism and emergence.
Wahman begins by mobilizing Santayana's pragmatism as a theory of knowing which recognizes the relational and interest-related nature of scientific theorizing, bringing construction, metaphor, and narrative into our knowledge of nature. The objects of our consciousness ("essences," we will see below) are not material things or aspects thereof, nor are they copies of such things or properties of consciousness. Human (and animal) knowing does...