Content area
Full Text
1.
A version of this essay was presented at a retrospective on Nick Salvatore's biography of Debs at the 2007 meeting of the Organization of American Historians. Thanks to Jeff Cowie for organizing the session and to the other panelists for their comments and criticism. Thanks also to Christopher Phelps, Matt Nichter, Nelson Lichtenstein, Judith Stein, Tony Michels, Adolph Reed, Aims McGuiness, Dorothy Sue Cobble, and the anonymous readers at ILWCH.
Eugene V. Debs began "The Negro in the Class Struggle" (1903) by criticizing Socialists who "either share directly in the race hostility against the Negro, or avoid the issue, or apologize for the social obliteration of the color line in the class struggle," so it is remarkable that the essay and its author have come to epitomize white radicals' alleged indifference to racism and its significance to the history of the working class in the United States. Robert Craig expresses the common sense in his assertion that "Like so many well-meaning radicals before and since, Debs tried to subsume the race question in the class struggle, and in the process he moderated his radicalism and failed to come to terms with the unique quality of the African American experience." The term "Debsian" serves as shorthand in the work of David Roediger and Nelson Lichtenstein for white labor leaders who, as Roediger writes, "never reckoned with labor's past where race was concerned." Repeating one of the only well-known phrases from the Socialist leaders' voluminous writings, Nikhil Pal Singh, Beth Bates, and other scholars contend that the racial politics of white radicals and reformers in the early twentieth-century United States were summed up most clearly in Debs's statement that, "we have nothing special to offer the Negro."2
Taking a single passage out of context and interpreting it as the Achilles' heel of American radicalism, scholars have distorted Debs's complex and still poignant critique of white supremacy. That process began soon after the essay was published by the International Socialist Review, which commissioned Debs to respond to a platform adopted by the Socialist Party of Louisiana calling for "separation of the black and white races into separate communities, each race to have charge of its own affairs." Debs happened to be campaigning for president...