Content area
Full Text
"'He, I say-I cannot say, I.'"
-Robert Louis Stevenson
For several decades, critical commentary on "The Jolly Corner"-James's 1908 tale of Spencer Brydon's return to New York, his encounter with the ghostly double who represents Brydon's unlived American life, and his disavowal of whatever the double obscurely embodies and signifies-has situated the claims of "America" within an undiscerning account of heterosexuality's reclaiming of the expatriate bachelor. Dorothea Krook suggests that this tale is "'The Beast in the Jungle' with a happy ending," an exposition of "the power to receive love" (334); Daniel Mark Fogel asserts that Spencer "accepts the best in his American identity when he is reborn to reciprocal love with Alice Staverton" (196); Millicent Bell argues that Spencer Brydon "is rewarded as are few Jamesian heroes: he has recovered a possibility foregone" (287). Although there are few incontrovertible certainties obtainable in this strange text, it seems evident that the gothic narrative of "The Jolly Corner" explores the insidious reach of heterosexual reclamation as the occasion of profound terror. In order to chart the dimensions of this terror, I must consider, first of all, the particularities of Spencer Brydon's "European" subjectivity, and, second, the odd circumstance that his ghostly, hypothetical "American" double is double-authored by Brydon's melancholic response to an unlived life in conjunction with Alice's equally retrospective heterosexual "script," her mourning of an eclipsed heterosexual vocation.
At this late moment in Jamesian criticism, we have come to understand the precarious situation of the bachelor, his liminal position in dominant culture and his permeable psychic boundaries which admit the rigors of homosexual panic. The bachelor's indeterminate relation to identity and desire aligns this figure neatly with James's narrative investments in "the incalculable." The mapping of the Jamesian bachelor by Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick has situated this recurring, almost generic figure on an incoherent, suspended point along "the treacherous middle stretch of the modern homosocial continuum" at which there is no "identity," only "agonized sexual anesthesia" (Epistemology 188). Nowhere in subsequent criticism can we locate a self-identified, self-knowing "gay" bachelor; yet James, I would argue, establishes precisely such a subjectivity for Spencer Brydon upon his return from prolonged expatriation. James's signalling of Brydon's homosexuality takes the oblique form of connotation, but the play of connotation is...