Switching from monoculture to polyculture farming benefits birds in oil palm production landscapes: Evidence from mist netting data

Abstract

Monoculture farming is pervasive in industrial oil palm agriculture, including those RSPO plantations certified as sustainably managed. This farming practice does not promote the maintenance of farmland biodiversity. However, little scientific attention has been given to polyculture farming in oil palm production landscapes. Polyculture farming is likely to increase the floristic diversity and stand structural complexity that underpins biodiversity. Mist nets were used to sample birds at 120 smallholdings in Peninsular Malaysia. At each site, 12 vegetation structure characteristics were measured. We compared bird species richness, abundance, and composition between monoculture and polyculture smallholdings and used predictive models to examine the effects of habitat quality on avian biodiversity. Bird species richness was significantly greater in polyculture than that of monoculture smallholdings. The number of fallen and standing, dead oil palms were also important positive predictors of species richness. Bird abundance was also strongly increased by standing and dead oil palms and decreased with oil palm stand height. Our results indicate that polyculture farming can improve bird species richness in oil palm production landscapes. In addition, key habitat variables that are closely associated with farming practices, such as the removal of dead trees, should and can be managed by oil palm growers in order to promote biodiversity. To increase the sustainability of oil palm agriculture, it is imperative that stakeholders modify the way oil palms are currently planted and managed. Our findings can guide policy makers and certification bodies to promote oil palm production landscapes that will function more sustainably and increase existing biodiversity of oil palm landscapes.

REFERENCES Aratrakorn, S., Thunhikorn, S., & Donald, P. F. (2006). Changes in bird communities following conversion of lowland forest to oil palm and rubber plantations in southern Thailand. Bird Conservation International, 16, 71–82. Asmah, S., Ghazali, A., Syafiq, M., Yahya, M. S., Peng, T. L., & Norhisham, A. R., … Lindenmayer, D. B. (2016). Effects of polyculture and monoculture farming in oil palm smallholdings on tropical fruit-feeding butterfly diversity. Agricultural and Forest Entomology, 19, 70–80. Azhar, B., Lindenmayer, D. B., Wood, J., Fischer, J., Manning, A., McElhinny, C., & Zakaria, M. (2011). The conservation value of oil palm plantation estates, smallholdings and logged peat swamp forest for birds. Forest Ecology and Management, 262, 2306–2315. Azhar, B., Lindenmayer, D. B., Wood, J., Fischer, J., Manning, A., McElhinny, C., & Zakaria, M. (2013). The influence of agricultural system, stand structural complexity and landscape context on foraging birds in oil palm landscapes. Ibis, 155, 297–312. Azhar, B., Puan, C. L., Aziz, N., Sainuddin, M., Adila, N., & Samsuddin, S., … Jamian, S. (2015). Effects of in situ habitat quality and landscape characteristics in the oil palm agricultural matrix on tropical understory birds, fruit bats and butterflies. Biodiversity and Conservation, 24, 3125–3144. Azhar, B., Puan, C. L., Zakaria, M., Hassan, N., & Arif, M. (2014). Effects of monoculture and polyculture practices in oil palm smallholdings on tropical farmland birds. Basic and Applied Ecology, 15, 336–346. Azhar, B., Saadun, N., Puan, C. L., Kamarudin, N., Aziz, N., Nurhidayu, S., & Fischer, J. (2015). Promoting landscape heterogeneity to improve the biodiversity benefits of certified palm oil production: Evidence from Peninsular Malaysia. Global Ecology and Conservation, 3, 553–561. Basiron, Y. (2007). Palm oil production through sustainable plantations. European Journal of Lipid Science and Technology, 109, 289–295. Carron, M. P., Auriac, Q., Snoeck, D., Villenave, C., Blanchart, E., Ribeyre, F., … Caliman, J. P. (2015). Spatial heterogeneity of soil quality around mature oil palms receiving mineral fertilization. European Journal of Soil Biology, 66, 24–31. Clarke, K. R., & Gorley, R. N. (2006). PRIMER v6: User manual/tutorial. Plymouth: PRIMER-E. Colwell, R. K. (2013). EstimateS: Statistical estimation of species richness and shared species from samples. 2005. Consultado en. Retrieved from http://viceroy.eeb.uconn.edu/estimates Colwell, R. K., Mao, C. X., & Chang, J. (2004). Interpolating, extrapolating and comparing incidence-based species accumulation curves. Ecology, 85, 2717–2727. Corley, R. H. V. (2009). How much palm oil do we need? Environmental Science & Policy, 12, 134–139. De Clerck, F. A., & Negreros-Castillo, P. (2000). Plant species of traditional mayan homegardens of Mexico as analogs for multistrata agroforests. Agroforestry Systems, 48, 303–317. Dislich, C., Keyel, A. C., Salecker, J., Kisel, Y., Meyer, K. M., Auliya, M., … Hess, B. (2016). A review of the ecosystem functions in oil palm plantations, using forests as a reference system. Biological Reviews, DOI: 10.1111/brv.12295. Dormann, C. F., Elith, J., Bacher, S., Buchmann, C., Carl, G., & Carré, G., … Münkemüller, T. (2013). Collinearity: A review of methods to deal with it and a simulation study evaluating their performance. Ecography, 36, 27–46. Edwards, D. P., Hodgson, J. A., Hamer, K. C., Mitchell, S. L., Ahmad, A. H., Cornell, S. J., & Wilcove, D. S. (2010). Wildlife-friendly oil palm plantations fail to protect biodiversity effectively. Conservation Letters, 3, 236–242. FAOSTAT. (2016). Statistics. Retrieved from http://www.fao.org/statistics/en/ Fayle, T. M., Turner, E. C., Snaddon, J. L., Chey, V. K., Chung, A. Y., Eggleton, P., & Foster, W. A. (2010). Oil palm expansion into rain forest greatly reduces ant biodiversity in canopy, epiphytes and leaf-litter. Basic and Applied Ecology, 11, 337–345. Feintrenie, L., Chong, W. K., & Levang, P. (2010). Why do farmers prefer oil palm? Lessons learnt from Bungo district Indonesia. Small-Scale Forestry, 9, 379–396. Felton, A., Lindbladh, M., Brunet, J., & Fritz, Ö. (2010). Replacing coniferous monocultures with mixed-species production stands: An assessment of the potential benefits for forest biodiversity in Northern Europe. Forest Ecology and Management, 260, 939–947. Fitzherbert, E. B., Struebig, M. J., Morel, A., Danielsen, F., Brühl, C. A., Donald, P. F., & Phalan, B. (2008). How will oil palm expansion affect biodiversity?. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 23, 538–545. Foster, W. A., Snaddon, J. L., Turner, E. C., Fayle, T. M., Cockerill, T. D., & Ellwood, M. F., … Yusah, K. M. (2011). Establishing the evidence base for maintaining biodiversity and ecosystem function in the oil palm landscapes of South East Asia. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences, 366, 3277–3291. Franklin, J. F., Lindenmayer, D. B., MacMahon, J. A., McKee, A., Magnusson, J., Perry, D. A., … Foster, D. R. (2000). Threads of continuity: Ecosystem disturbances, biological legacies and ecosystem recovery. Conservation Biology in Practice, 1, 8–16. Gallmetzer, N., & Schulze, C. H. (2015). Impact of oil palm agriculture on understory amphibians and reptiles: A Mesoamerican perspective. Global Ecology and Conservation, 4, 95–109. Gardner, T. A., Barlow, J., Chazdon, R., Ewers, R. M., Harvey, C. A., Peres, C. A., & Sodhi, N. S. (2009). Prospects for tropical forest biodiversity in a human-modified world. Ecology Letters, 12, 561–582. Ghazali, A., Asmah, S., Syafiq, M., Yahya, M. S., Aziz, N., & Tan, L. P., … Azhar, B. (2016). Effects of monoculture and polyculture farming in oil palm smallholdings on terrestrial arthropod diversity. Journal of Asia-Pacific Entomology, 19, 415–421. Gibbons, P., & Lindenmayer, D. B. (2002). Tree hollows and wildlife conservation in Australia. Melbourne: CSIRO Publishing. Gray, C. L., Slade, E. M., Mann, D. J., & Lewis, O. T. (2014). Do riparian reserves support dung beetle biodiversity and ecosystem services in oil palm-dominated tropical landscapes? Ecology and Evolution, 4, 1049–1060. Guby, N. B., & Dobbertin, M. (1996). Quantitative estimates of coarse woody debris and standing dead trees in selected Swiss forests. Global Ecology and Biogeography Letters, 5, 327–341. Härdter, R., Chow, W. Y., & Hock, O. S. (1997). Intensive plantation cropping, a source of sustainable food and energy production in the tropical rain forest areas in Southeast Asia. Forest Ecology and Management, 91, 93–102. Hawa, A., Azhar, B., Top, M. M., & Zubaid, A. (2016). Depauperate avifauna in tropical peat swamp forests following logging and conversion to oil palm agriculture: Evidence from mist-netting data. Wetlands, 36, 899–908. Henders, S., Persson, U. M., & Kastner, T. (2015). Trading forests: Land-use change and carbon emissions embodied in production and exports of forest-risk commodities. Environmental Research Letters, 10, 125012. Hughes, R. F., Kauffman, J. B., & Jaramillo, V. J. (1999). Biomass, carbon, and nutrient dynamics of secondary forests in a humid tropical region of Mexico. Ecology, 80, 1892–1907. Hushiarian, R., Yusof, N. A., & Dutse, S. W. (2013). Detection and control of Ganoderma boninense: Strategies and perspectives. SpringerPlus, 2, 555. Jones, G. A., & Sieving, K. E. (2006). Intercropping sunflower in organic vegetables to augment bird predators of arthropods. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 117, 171–177. Khor, Y. L. (2011). The oil palm industry bows to NGO campaigns. Lipid Technology, 23, 102–104. Koczberski, G., & Curry, G. N. (2005). Making a living: Land pressures and changing livelihood strategies among oil palm settlers in Papua New Guinea. Agricultural Systems, 85, 324–339. Koh, L. P., Levang, P., & Ghazoul, J. (2009). Designer landscapes for sustainable biofuels. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 24, 431–438. Koh, L. P., & Wilcove, D. S. (2007). Cashing in palm oil for conservation. Nature, 448, 993–994. Kremen, C. (2015). Reframing the land-sparing/land-sharing debate for biodiversity conservation. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1355, 52–76. Lindenmayer, D. B., & Noss, R. F. (2006). Salvage logging, ecosystem processes, and biodiversity conservation. Conservation Biology, 20, 949–958. Linkie, M., Martyr, D. J., Holden, J., Yanuar, A., Hartana, A. T., Sugardjito, J., & Leader-Williams, N. (2003). Habitat destruction and poaching threaten the sumatran tiger in kerinciseblat national park Sumatra. Oryx, 37, 41–48. Lucey, J. M., Tawatao, N., Senior, M. J., Chey, V. K., Benedick, S., & Hamer, K. C, … Hill, J. K. (2014). Tropical forest fragments contribute to species richness in adjacent oil palm plantations. Biological Conservation, 169, 268–276. Luskin, M. S., & Potts, M. D. (2011). Microclimate and habitat heterogeneity through the oil palm lifecycle. Basic and Applied Ecology, 12, 540–551. Malézieux, E., Crozat, Y., Dupraz, C., Laurans, M., Makowski, D., & Ozier-Lafontaine, H., … Valantin-Morison, M. (2009). Mixing plant species in cropping systems: Concepts, tools and models: A review. In E. Lichtfouse, M. Navarrete, P. Debaeke, S. Véronique & C. Alberola (Eds.), Sustainable Agriculture (pp. 329–353). Netherlands: Springer. Mandal, J., & Shankar Raman, T. R. (2016). Shifting agriculture supports more tropical forest birds than oil palm or teak plantations in Mizoram, Northeast India. The Condor, 118, 345–359. McWethy, D. B., Hansen, A. J., & Verschuyl, J. P. (2010). Bird response to disturbance varies with forest productivity in the Northwestern United States. Landscape Ecology, 25, 533–549. Mitchell, A. (2005). The ESRI Guide to GIS Analysis, Volume 2: Spatial measurements and statistics. USA: ESRI Press. Montagnini, F., & Nair, P. K. R. (2004). Carbon sequestration: An underexploited environmental benefit of agroforestry systems. Agroforestry Systems, 61, 281. Morissette, J. L., Cobb, T. P., Brigham, R. M., & James, P. C. (2002). The response of boreal forest songbird communities to fire and post-fire harvesting. Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 12, 2169–2183. Morrison, M. L., Block, W. M., Strickland, M. D., Collier, B. A., & Peterson, M. J. (2008). Wildlife study design. Springer Science & Business Media Nájera, A., & Simonetti, J. A. (2010). Can oil palm plantations become bird friendly? Agroforestry Systems, 80, 203–209. Perfecto, I., & Vandermeer, J. (2008). Biodiversity conservation in tropical agroecosystems. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1134, 173–200. Prabowo, W. E., Darras, K., Clough, Y., Toledo-Hernandez, M., Arlettaz, R., Mulyani, Y. A., & Tscharntke, T. (2016). Bird responses to lowland rainforest conversion in sumatran smallholder landscapes Indonesia. PLoS ONE, 11, e0154876. Prescott, G. W., Edwards, D. P., & Foster, W. A. (2015). Retaining biodiversity in intensive farmland: Epiphyte removal in oil palm plantations does not affect yield. Ecology and Evolution, 5, 1944–1954. Ralph, C. J., Sauer, J. R., & Droege, S. (1995). Monitoring bird populations by point counts. Berkeley, CA: Pacific Southwest Research Station. Seibold, S., Bässler, C., Brandl, R., Gossner, M. M., Thorn, S., Ulyshen, M. D., & Müller, J. (2015). Experimental studies of dead-wood biodiversity—a review identifying global gaps in knowledge. Biological Conservation, 191, 139–149. Srinivas, A., & Koh, L. P. (2016). Oil palm expansion drives avifaunal decline in the pucallpa region of peruvian amazonia. Global Ecology and Conservation, 7, 183–200. Syafiq, M., Atiqah, A. R. N., Ghazali, A., Asmah, S., Yahya, M. S., & Aziz, N., … Azhar, B. (2016). Responses of tropical fruit bats to monoculture and polyculture farming in oil palm smallholdings. Acta Oecologica, 74, 11–18. Tejeda-Cruz, C., & Sutherland, W. J. (2004). Bird responses to shade coffee production. Animal Conservation, 7, 169–179. Teuscher, M., Gérard, A., Brose, U., Buchori, D., Clough, Y., & Ehbrecht, M., … Kreft, H. (2016). Experimental biodiversity enrichment in oil-palm-dominated landscapes in Indonesia. Frontiers in Plant Science, 7, 1538. Turner, E. C., & Foster, W. A. (2006). Assessing the influence of bird's nest ferns (Asplenium spp.) on the local microclimate across a range of habitat disturbances in Sabah Malaysia. Selbyana, 27, 195–200. Wicke, B., Sikkema, R., Dornburg, V., & Faaij, A. (2011). Exploring land use changes and the role of palm oil production in Indonesia and Malaysia. Land Use Policy, 28, 193–206. Wilcove, D. S., & Koh, L. P. (2010). Addressing the threats to biodiversity from oil-palm agriculture. Biodiversity and Conservation, 19, 999–1007.