Content area
Full text
Tropics of Savagery: The Culture of Japanese Empire in Comparative Frame, by Robert Thomas Tierney. Asia Pacific Modern Series 5. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2010. isbn 978-0-520-26578-3; xi + 307 pages, notes, bibliography, index. us $57.95.
Nanyo-Orientalism: Japanese Representations of the Pacific, by Naoto Sudo. Amherst, ny: Cambria Press, 2010. isbn 978-1-604-97731-8, viii + 221 pages, notes, bibliography, index, us $104.99.
For many years, disciplinary boundaries have hindered the production of major analytic works on Japan's Pacific empire, particularly in Micronesia. As Robert Tierney notes in the introduction to Tropics of Savagery, postcolonial theory tends to be relentlessly focused on Europe and its colonies, and the tendency of many universities to relegate scholars of Japan to area studies programs only exacerbates the problem. Even within Japanese Empire studies, the politically anomalous position of Micronesia within a League of Nations Mandate and its relatively smaller population have caused it to be neglected in favor of other, more visible colonies. Micronesia scholars like Wakako Higuchi, Keith Camacho, and Greg Dvorak have made important contributions to the growing body of scholarship on the region's Japanese occupation, but sustained engagement between Pacific studies and East Asian studies remains rare.
Tropics of Savagery and NanyoOrientalism are ambitious, theo- retically rich studies of the culture of Japan's Pacific empire and welcome contributions to the field. Tierney, a scholar of Japanese literature, focuses primarily on the figure of the "savage" in colonial discourse during Japan's occupations of Taiwan (1895-1945) and Micronesia (1914-1945). This trope of savagery, Tierney argues, is central to understanding the imagination of Japanese colonial writers and the imperial culture they helped to produce. Tierney is careful to note that the savage was "without a referent or indeed without any basis in reality" but that it nevertheless operated as a "polyvalent signifier" for a conflicted and evolving imperial culture (7). Imperial culture, both different from and mimetic of Western imperialism, embraced the image of the savage as a foil against which Japan could be made over into a modern, civilized nation. At the same time, the savage functioned within a "rhetoric of sameness" (21) through which Japanese authors claimed a closer kinship to the people they colonized than Western imperial rulers could.
While Tropics of Savagery mainly seeks to...